Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5868)
Hannah
Review left Jun 14 2023
Shipment processed May 26 2023
Review
Super easy process! Incredibly fast going through the shipment and prompt payout. Thank you!
Super easy process! Incredibly fast going through the shipment and prompt payout. Thank you!
Brody F
Review left Jun 14 2023
Review
It was simple for me to make a list on the TCG Player app and put it in the collection estimator. It generated my estimated value and the service level they recommend. After shipping and review I received cash in my bank account. Will use again!
It was simple for me to make a list on the TCG Player app and put it in the collection estimator. It generated my estimated value and the service level they recommend. After shipping and review I received cash in my bank account. Will use again!
Dan Hurley
Review left Jun 14 2023
Review
I used their sorted service. Their sorting and shipping tool made the process easy. Once the cards were shipped the sorting and payment happened quickly.
I used their sorted service. Their sorting and shipping tool made the process easy. Once the cards were shipped the sorting and payment happened quickly.
Pippin
Review left Jun 14 2023
Shipment processed Jun 10 2023
$3,264.73
payout, $59.84
fees
Review
The service is straight forward and easy to use. I got more for my cards using card conduit than I was offered elsewhere. The report showing the card grade and prices paid per card is super helpful.
The service is straight forward and easy to use. I got more for my cards using card conduit than I was offered elsewhere. The report showing the card grade and prices paid per card is super helpful.
Paul
Review left Jun 13 2023
Review
I used the sorted list both times which becomes easier once you learn the process. I really have nothing negative to say, and only positives.
This is really a great service...I imagine, especially for those who haven't been in to MTG for a long time. Fortunately, I've been collecting since th ... Read more
This is really a great service...I imagine, especially for those who haven't been in to MTG for a long time. Fortunately, I've been collecting since th ... Read more
I used the sorted list both times which becomes easier once you learn the process. I really have nothing negative to say, and only positives.
This is really a great service...I imagine, especially for those who haven't been in to MTG for a long time. Fortunately, I've been collecting since the mid 90's playing off and on throughout the years so card familiarity helps a ton when sorting through your own cards. I couldn't imagine sending in cards without knowing their value, but this may be the best service for that if you're in that position.
Also, if you're selling cards through eBay or tcgplayer...you still have to pay them out, sit on product until it sells, deal with more instances of shipping, and of course spend much more time dealing with these singular transactions. If you think about it, card conduit is actually a great service for more expensive cards as well. I sold a Chrome Mox (mrd) in NM condition for $75 off ebay. after shipping and fees, I made $60 which is roughly what card conduit would've given me.
Look forward to selling more cards to card conduit!
This is really a great service...I imagine, especially for those who haven't been in to MTG for a long time. Fortunately, I've been collecting since the mid 90's playing off and on throughout the years so card familiarity helps a ton when sorting through your own cards. I couldn't imagine sending in cards without knowing their value, but this may be the best service for that if you're in that position.
Also, if you're selling cards through eBay or tcgplayer...you still have to pay them out, sit on product until it sells, deal with more instances of shipping, and of course spend much more time dealing with these singular transactions. If you think about it, card conduit is actually a great service for more expensive cards as well. I sold a Chrome Mox (mrd) in NM condition for $75 off ebay. after shipping and fees, I made $60 which is roughly what card conduit would've given me.
Look forward to selling more cards to card conduit!
Chance Blackwell
Review left Jun 13 2023
Review
The process was incredibly smooth and painless and the customer support was fantastic. The fees were well worth the time it saved me from doing everything myself. I will be very likely to use the service again in the future if I have another large sell-off to complete.
The process was incredibly smooth and painless and the customer support was fantastic. The fees were well worth the time it saved me from doing everything myself. I will be very likely to use the service again in the future if I have another large sell-off to complete.
Samuel Boss
Review left Jun 13 2023
Review
Importing my list of cards from MTGGoldfish took a single click, shipping instructions were very well detailed, offer for my collection was competitively-priced. Once delivered, sorting only took a couple days (grading of cards was very reasonable) & was personally reached out to & informed I was up
...
Read more
Importing my list of cards from MTGGoldfish took a single click, shipping instructions were very well detailed, offer for my collection was competitively-priced. Once delivered, sorting only took a couple days (grading of cards was very reasonable) & was personally reached out to & informed I was upgraded to their curated service due to the value of my collection. Received my payment a couple days later. Genuinely impressed with this service, could not recommend enough. Thanks y'all!
LF
Review left Jun 13 2023
Review
Thanks for making this easy. Probably have done 5 shipments now? EZ PZ LEMON SQZY
Thanks for making this easy. Probably have done 5 shipments now? EZ PZ LEMON SQZY
Paul
Review left Jun 12 2023
Review
I used the sorted list service and it was pretty awesome. As others mentioned, the sweet spot may be for cards worth $2-$10, although I submitted more expensive cards as well. My reasoning is that I am not a card shop and do not want to go through many single transactions to get all my cards sold.
...
Read more
I used the sorted list service and it was pretty awesome. As others mentioned, the sweet spot may be for cards worth $2-$10, although I submitted more expensive cards as well. My reasoning is that I am not a card shop and do not want to go through many single transactions to get all my cards sold. The sorted list you do a bit more work, and may be better for someone who is familiar with their collection.
The grading was pretty spot on especially if you are realistic with yourself. They do a great job of communicating through the website as it provides accurate updates and were quick with the payout. I really don't have anything negative to say.
The grading was pretty spot on especially if you are realistic with yourself. They do a great job of communicating through the website as it provides accurate updates and were quick with the payout. I really don't have anything negative to say.
Sam W.
Review left Jun 12 2023
Review
Card Conduit did a great job of helping me find card values, rebuying them, and providing prompt payment.
Card Conduit did a great job of helping me find card values, rebuying them, and providing prompt payment.
Thomas
Review left Jun 12 2023
Review
They were in constant communication through the whole process and made everything so quick and easy. I would recommend this process to anyone selling cards.
They were in constant communication through the whole process and made everything so quick and easy. I would recommend this process to anyone selling cards.
Ashley
Review left Jun 12 2023
Review
I had a ton of cards that were old and copies upon copies. Shipping was easy, processing was quick, and Card Conduit was able to do a pricing process that worked better for my particular situation. Very happy with them and would gladly use them again in the future.
I had a ton of cards that were old and copies upon copies. Shipping was easy, processing was quick, and Card Conduit was able to do a pricing process that worked better for my particular situation. Very happy with them and would gladly use them again in the future.
Alexis Enriquez
Review left Jun 11 2023
Shipment processed May 31 2023
Review
The process was easier than expected and yielded more than expected! Nick Anderson communicated to me a change to my processing options that I feel greatly improved the amount I got back. Im greatful to have experienced CardConduit! Good job everybody.
The process was easier than expected and yielded more than expected! Nick Anderson communicated to me a change to my processing options that I feel greatly improved the amount I got back. Im greatful to have experienced CardConduit! Good job everybody.
Min
Review left Jun 11 2023
Review
The process was super easy. You would get more money from them than say if you sell it to eBay or marketplace and you don’t have to deal with hagglers.
The process was super easy. You would get more money from them than say if you sell it to eBay or marketplace and you don’t have to deal with hagglers.
Joe Lemke
Review left Jun 10 2023
Review
Given the option to thoroughly sorry my cards myself for a HEAVY discount to get the money I deserve got my cards was WELL worth it, will use again in future
Given the option to thoroughly sorry my cards myself for a HEAVY discount to get the money I deserve got my cards was WELL worth it, will use again in future
Andrew Tardie
Review left Jun 10 2023
Shipment processed May 27 2023
Review
Super easy, good value, would highly recommend! A++
Super easy, good value, would highly recommend! A++
Tim C
Review left Jun 09 2023
Review
I've been fretting over unloading my magic cards for almost a year now and decided to take the plunge with Card Conduit. Everything is laid out simply and the process is supremely transparent. I will be using the service again!
I've been fretting over unloading my magic cards for almost a year now and decided to take the plunge with Card Conduit. Everything is laid out simply and the process is supremely transparent. I will be using the service again!
Daniel Zimmer
Review left Jun 09 2023
Review
Easy to use, fast processing and great customer service!
Easy to use, fast processing and great customer service!
Todd Morzelewski
Review left Jun 09 2023
Review
Professional, communicative, and very fast! Super awesome!
Professional, communicative, and very fast! Super awesome!
Ian
Review left Jun 09 2023
Review
The entire process from start to finish was very easy for me to navigate. One of the biggest anxieties I have when sending cards in is determining their quality, and the definitions of phrases like "lightly played" are different from one buy list to another. Card Conduit took that stress off and hon
...
Read more
The entire process from start to finish was very easy for me to navigate. One of the biggest anxieties I have when sending cards in is determining their quality, and the definitions of phrases like "lightly played" are different from one buy list to another. Card Conduit took that stress off and honestly, that was worth any extra I spent.
If you do 100 or less cards, their cheapest option is very feasible and shipping isn't even too expensive. I think the only other way I would have maximized my value would have been selling cards individually myself, but honestly, unless the cards you're selling are individually quite popular and fairly valuable, it's going to take you some time. If your time is valuable and you've got a solid amount of $5-$20 bulk lying around, Card Conduit is likely to serve you well.
Also, editing to add, but their communication was constant and clear throughout the process as well. I knew why I was getting the value I did, how long until they anticipated finishing, etc. It was great!
If you do 100 or less cards, their cheapest option is very feasible and shipping isn't even too expensive. I think the only other way I would have maximized my value would have been selling cards individually myself, but honestly, unless the cards you're selling are individually quite popular and fairly valuable, it's going to take you some time. If your time is valuable and you've got a solid amount of $5-$20 bulk lying around, Card Conduit is likely to serve you well.
Also, editing to add, but their communication was constant and clear throughout the process as well. I knew why I was getting the value I did, how long until they anticipated finishing, etc. It was great!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).