Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6842)
Maye
Review left Jul 31 2026
Review
Never going to a LGS again to sell my cards. Straight up just no point anymore. I love yall
Never going to a LGS again to sell my cards. Straight up just no point anymore. I love yall
Eva
Review left Jul 31 2026
Review
I put off selling my magic collection for so long because it was so daunting. I’m so grateful a service like card conduit exists now so my cards don’t have to collect dust in the closet. It was really easy to make the shipments, and payment was very speedy through direct deposit. Highly recommend!
I put off selling my magic collection for so long because it was so daunting. I’m so grateful a service like card conduit exists now so my cards don’t have to collect dust in the closet. It was really easy to make the shipments, and payment was very speedy through direct deposit. Highly recommend!
Jarrett Hostler
Review left Jul 31 2026
Review
Process was easy and everything went as I expected. Got my check quickly. Had a great experience overall
Process was easy and everything went as I expected. Got my check quickly. Had a great experience overall
Thinning the collection when I move
Review left Jul 31 2026
Review
Best place to sell cards, blows tcg player and card kingdom out of the water!
Best place to sell cards, blows tcg player and card kingdom out of the water!
Eli W
Review left Jul 31 2026
Review
The process of buylisting my bulk rares with Card Conduit was incredibly easy and rewarding. I got way more value out of the singles than I would have if using a major online retailer or LGS. Super easy to use and relatively quick turnaround time.
The process of buylisting my bulk rares with Card Conduit was incredibly easy and rewarding. I got way more value out of the singles than I would have if using a major online retailer or LGS. Super easy to use and relatively quick turnaround time.
Cody K
Review left Jul 31 2026
Review
The process was easy and fast! Their collection estimate and condition assessment seemed fair. Would recommend! Plan to use again.
The process was easy and fast! Their collection estimate and condition assessment seemed fair. Would recommend! Plan to use again.
Ryan Grieser
Review left Jul 30 2026
Review
Process was simple, fair pricing, quick payout. No complaints
Process was simple, fair pricing, quick payout. No complaints
Kishan
Review left Jul 30 2026
Review
I felt like a few of the more expensive cards I submitted should’ve been graded at NM but overall I was happy with the results
I felt like a few of the more expensive cards I submitted should’ve been graded at NM but overall I was happy with the results
Daniel Beard
Review left Jul 30 2026
Shipment processed Jul 21 2026
Review
Great service and acceptable prices. I was comfortable with the whole experience
Great service and acceptable prices. I was comfortable with the whole experience
Eric Allen
Review left Jul 30 2026
Shipment processed Jul 20 2026
Review
All and all a good experience. Tough on grading tho.
All and all a good experience. Tough on grading tho.
Robert R
Review left Jul 30 2026
Shipment processed Jul 28 2026
Review
easy to use, fast processing, fast payout.........
easy to use, fast processing, fast payout.........
Curtis Hames
Review left Jul 29 2026
Review
thanks again for the excellent transaction, great work as always. Easy way to convert old cards into cash.
thanks again for the excellent transaction, great work as always. Easy way to convert old cards into cash.
Kristen Stadler
Review left Jul 29 2026
Review
Had an extremely simple time selling cards. Got a good, fair payout for what I sent in and it was very easy to do. I'm already preparing another shipment to sell.
Had an extremely simple time selling cards. Got a good, fair payout for what I sent in and it was very easy to do. I'm already preparing another shipment to sell.
Patrick Cox
Review left Jul 28 2026
Review
If you are looking to turn cards into cash quickly there simply is not a better sight. I have turned unused EDH decks into pauper, value vintage, dan dan, and countless other formats to enjoy magic.
If you are looking to turn cards into cash quickly there simply is not a better sight. I have turned unused EDH decks into pauper, value vintage, dan dan, and countless other formats to enjoy magic.
Zeb Hillard
Review left Jul 28 2026
Review
Every time, best in convenience and value all the way around
Every time, best in convenience and value all the way around
Ris Fulmer
Review left Jul 28 2026
Review
Their interface for searching for cards and selling cards was easier to use than Card Kingdom's. I got reasonable prices for the cards I sent in.
Their interface for searching for cards and selling cards was easier to use than Card Kingdom's. I got reasonable prices for the cards I sent in.
Hudson Scher
Review left Jul 28 2026
Review
Very easy process, helpful and communicative staff, good value (condition graded a little harshly but not too bad), would recommend especially for bulk.
Very easy process, helpful and communicative staff, good value (condition graded a little harshly but not too bad), would recommend especially for bulk.
Nick Burger
Review left Jul 27 2026
Review
Another great experience with Card Conduit. Fast processing and payment, great customer service, super easy and hassle-free. Would definitely recommend for anyone looking to get sell a large quantity of Magic cards!
Another great experience with Card Conduit. Fast processing and payment, great customer service, super easy and hassle-free. Would definitely recommend for anyone looking to get sell a large quantity of Magic cards!
Q H
Review left Jul 27 2026
Shipment processed Apr 16 2026
Review
The selling process with Card Conduit is always incredibly fast and easy. Every step is communicated to the seller and the prices are more than fair. I will continue to use their services as long as I play magic. Cannot recommend highly enough!
The selling process with Card Conduit is always incredibly fast and easy. Every step is communicated to the seller and the prices are more than fair. I will continue to use their services as long as I play magic. Cannot recommend highly enough!
Melissa Gower-Siegfried
Review left Jul 27 2026
Shipment processed Jun 23 2026
Review
I had a few high value cards to sell and was concerned about the best way to do that. Card Conduit made the process very easy, they kept me informed throughout the entire process and paid me in a timely manner. I would highly recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell MTG cards.
I had a few high value cards to sell and was concerned about the best way to do that. Card Conduit made the process very easy, they kept me informed throughout the entire process and paid me in a timely manner. I would highly recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell MTG cards.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).