Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5628)
Tony Clavelli
Review left Dec 01 2025
Review
A really great way to trade in cards I wasn't using--much easier than when I've done the buylist thing, and really thorough with details. I definitely plan to do this again.
A really great way to trade in cards I wasn't using--much easier than when I've done the buylist thing, and really thorough with details. I definitely plan to do this again.
Aaron
Review left Nov 30 2025
Review
The whole process is super easy and I got back a lot more money than I was expecting from my collection! I would recommend everyone use this when they need to sell cards!
The whole process is super easy and I got back a lot more money than I was expecting from my collection! I would recommend everyone use this when they need to sell cards!
Nicole
Review left Nov 30 2025
Review
Easy to ship, website was simple to navigate and use plus I got more than what I was getting on tcg.
Easy to ship, website was simple to navigate and use plus I got more than what I was getting on tcg.
Mike
Review left Nov 30 2025
Review
I sent in about 66 cards and had money in my account in a little over 2 weeks time. Everything went smoothly and I even had a question about the condition of one of my cards that Nate was able to answer promptly and confidently. I will definitely be using Card Conduit again to offload other cards I don't need.
I sent in about 66 cards and had money in my account in a little over 2 weeks time. Everything went smoothly and I even had a question about the condition of one of my cards that Nate was able to answer promptly and confidently. I will definitely be using Card Conduit again to offload other cards I don't need.
Jacob C
Review left Nov 29 2025
Review
I've been sitting on my collection for a while but haven't played the game in forever due to getting into another card game and disagreements with the direction MTG was taking (not to say it's bad, just not what I was there for). Finally decided to pull the trigger and map out my collection with Gol
...
Read more
I've been sitting on my collection for a while but haven't played the game in forever due to getting into another card game and disagreements with the direction MTG was taking (not to say it's bad, just not what I was there for). Finally decided to pull the trigger and map out my collection with Goldfish and I saw the ad for card conduit and figured I'd look into it. I had been prepping to talk to my LGS about it first, but after seeing the fee percentages and expected payout it was an easy choice to go with card conduit. Process was pretty quick, about 2 weeks in total from prepping my shipment and mailing it out, to getting payment. Every step was clearly communicated and the detailed report of cards, their conditions, and pricing was superb. I'd highly recommend their service if you have extra cards laying around, I don't think anyone else on the market provides the same caliber of service.
deangelo
Review left Nov 29 2025
Review
the process is easy. it doesnt take a longtime to process the cards. always had a great experience with Card Conduit.
the process is easy. it doesnt take a longtime to process the cards. always had a great experience with Card Conduit.
Christopher J
Review left Nov 29 2025
Review
Reasonable timing. Thorough and excellent value, none better.
Reasonable timing. Thorough and excellent value, none better.
Lolo
Review left Nov 29 2025
Shipment processed Nov 27 2025
$3,135.90
payout, $64.00
fees
Review
As always process is super simple and transparent with the CC crew.
I submitted two boxes around the holiday, fully expecting a delay.. they finished and sent my report on a holiday! I'm not saying anyone should expect it.. but that's some incredible service!
I submitted two boxes around the holiday, fully expecting a delay.. they finished and sent my report on a holiday! I'm not saying anyone should expect it.. but that's some incredible service!
As always process is super simple and transparent with the CC crew.
I submitted two boxes around the holiday, fully expecting a delay.. they finished and sent my report on a holiday! I'm not saying anyone should expect it.. but that's some incredible service!
I submitted two boxes around the holiday, fully expecting a delay.. they finished and sent my report on a holiday! I'm not saying anyone should expect it.. but that's some incredible service!
Parker Madsen
Review left Nov 28 2025
Review
Far easier than most services and way fairer price
Far easier than most services and way fairer price
Michael
Review left Nov 28 2025
Review
Using card conduit to buylist is easy. Tracking your whole order being processed is transparent and trackable the whole way through. If you do run into any issues, reaching out to support is easy. Highly recommend.
Using card conduit to buylist is easy. Tracking your whole order being processed is transparent and trackable the whole way through. If you do run into any issues, reaching out to support is easy. Highly recommend.
Michael
Review left Nov 28 2025
Review
Still highly recommend after using this service several times.
Still highly recommend after using this service several times.
John K
Review left Nov 28 2025
Shipment processed Nov 20 2025
$2,391.86
payout, $112.71
fees
Review
I sold about 700 mid-value cards recently. Card conduit finished right on target for their projected date, and paid out higher than I was expecting (literally hundreds of dollars more than the offer from my LGS). The team was communicative and professional. Special shout-out to Nick!
I sold about 700 mid-value cards recently. Card conduit finished right on target for their projected date, and paid out higher than I was expecting (literally hundreds of dollars more than the offer from my LGS). The team was communicative and professional. Special shout-out to Nick!
Taylor
Review left Nov 28 2025
Review
The process was very simple to follow and I got more money back from cards I've had sitting around for years. One of the service reps even helped me pick a better processing service so that way I would get more money back on my shipments. I will gladly use this service when I need to purge my collection.
The process was very simple to follow and I got more money back from cards I've had sitting around for years. One of the service reps even helped me pick a better processing service so that way I would get more money back on my shipments. I will gladly use this service when I need to purge my collection.
CJ Slaughter
Review left Nov 27 2025
Shipment processed Nov 20 2025
Review
The process was super easy, and after dealing with rude employees at my local LGS this definitely made my experience with CC a much needed change and i couldn't be more pleased with the results.
The process was super easy, and after dealing with rude employees at my local LGS this definitely made my experience with CC a much needed change and i couldn't be more pleased with the results.
Walter D
Review left Nov 26 2025
Review
This is the third time I have now sent in cards and they have always be quick to process the cards and send out payment. I also think they are quite fair in their grading and have not had any cards I would say deviated from my grading expectations. But I suppose ones mileage my vary a little dependi
...
Read more
This is the third time I have now sent in cards and they have always be quick to process the cards and send out payment. I also think they are quite fair in their grading and have not had any cards I would say deviated from my grading expectations. But I suppose ones mileage my vary a little depending on their expectations and how they treat/store their cards.
Definitely recommend card conduit's services and intend to keep using it for any future cards I am looking to part with.
Definitely recommend card conduit's services and intend to keep using it for any future cards I am looking to part with.
Joseph
Review left Nov 25 2025
Review
The process was simple and easy to understand. The value was better than the cards sitting around. I would tell other about card conduit.
The process was simple and easy to understand. The value was better than the cards sitting around. I would tell other about card conduit.
Zikri Hasanbasri
Review left Nov 25 2025
Review
Long story short, I have an old collection of cards that were just sitting there, unlikely to be played. I didn't expect much out of it, but I figured someone could use it better. I was happy with any amount they were willing to give me, but they reduced some fees because of my low average value for
...
Read more
Long story short, I have an old collection of cards that were just sitting there, unlikely to be played. I didn't expect much out of it, but I figured someone could use it better. I was happy with any amount they were willing to give me, but they reduced some fees because of my low average value for these cards. They didn't need to do that, and I wouldn't expect them to do that every time. But, they cared for a first time customer, and I'm glad I sent my cards to them.
brandon
Review left Nov 25 2025
Review
Based on my overall experience i am extremely satisfied. Everything was done in a timely manner. The amount i received was a good value for what i sent in. I plan on using Card Conduit again soon. Would recommend to anyone.
Based on my overall experience i am extremely satisfied. Everything was done in a timely manner. The amount i received was a good value for what i sent in. I plan on using Card Conduit again soon. Would recommend to anyone.
Tanner Bethany
Review left Nov 25 2025
Review
First time using you guys and it was way easier than expected! Definitely going to be using you guys more!
First time using you guys and it was way easier than expected! Definitely going to be using you guys more!
Aaron Friend
Review left Nov 25 2025
Review
I have used a lot of companies over the years I've been playing Magic. I started playing during Ice Age and stopped shortly after Apocalypse came out. I collected the card Show and Tell from Urza's Saga for fun. In 2013 I had some friends in the office playing in the meeting room after work and I
...
Read more
I have used a lot of companies over the years I've been playing Magic. I started playing during Ice Age and stopped shortly after Apocalypse came out. I collected the card Show and Tell from Urza's Saga for fun. In 2013 I had some friends in the office playing in the meeting room after work and I had no idea how relevant my cards still were. So I started drafting again and played the Grand Prix that year in Nashville. I got into tournament playing again, but then found myself spending too much time on it and quit again in 2020. I found myself back into Commander casually with friends this past year, and wanted to sell some cards to get some staples for my deck. I'm very thankful for an organized and honest company to review and offer a fair price.
The entire process from signing up to the payout date was 12 days (that includes shipping time, review time, and payment processing). That is better than MTG Seattle and Star City Games. Also their payouts tend to be about 15-20% more.
If I need to offload any cards again, I will definitely be using Card Conduit!
The entire process from signing up to the payout date was 12 days (that includes shipping time, review time, and payment processing). That is better than MTG Seattle and Star City Games. Also their payouts tend to be about 15-20% more.
If I need to offload any cards again, I will definitely be using Card Conduit!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).