Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5628)
Phil S.
Review left Dec 05 2025
Review
I did a fair amount of legwork so I could get the curated option but overall, the service was wonderful and I was happy with the payment. I was able to lower my collection of a lot of cards.
I did a fair amount of legwork so I could get the curated option but overall, the service was wonderful and I was happy with the payment. I was able to lower my collection of a lot of cards.
Adam Moates
Review left Dec 05 2025
Review
This was my first time using card conduit. I did send some cards I thought had decent to high value but those were not evaluated as such. I have to say that the grading process is a little tough cause some of my cards came straight out of a pack and were not graded NM. But as a whole, they make it s
...
Read more
This was my first time using card conduit. I did send some cards I thought had decent to high value but those were not evaluated as such. I have to say that the grading process is a little tough cause some of my cards came straight out of a pack and were not graded NM. But as a whole, they make it simple to get cash for cards. I will be using them again because I have a lot of cards and this was just to see how it all works. I just hope next time some of the values are a bit higher
Aaron K.
Review left Dec 05 2025
Review
Looking up cards was extremely easy, the requested sorting for my cards made perfect sense. All communication was quick, courteous, and transparent. The assessment was fair and explained. It was a great experience and I believe I will be comfortable to sell to CardConduit in the future.
Looking up cards was extremely easy, the requested sorting for my cards made perfect sense. All communication was quick, courteous, and transparent. The assessment was fair and explained. It was a great experience and I believe I will be comfortable to sell to CardConduit in the future.
Travis Pryor
Review left Dec 04 2025
Shipment processed Dec 04 2025
Review
Easy and great service . They get your card done in a timely manner and your money to you quickly as well.
Easy and great service . They get your card done in a timely manner and your money to you quickly as well.
Sebastian
Review left Dec 04 2025
Review
I first used Card Conduit in 2023 and was very pleased with the results. Now it’s 2025 and I just completed my third shipment.
I love how easy they make it to downsize my collection and trim what not actually using, without having to go through the hassle of individually listing and selling ca ... Read more
I love how easy they make it to downsize my collection and trim what not actually using, without having to go through the hassle of individually listing and selling ca ... Read more
I first used Card Conduit in 2023 and was very pleased with the results. Now it’s 2025 and I just completed my third shipment.
I love how easy they make it to downsize my collection and trim what not actually using, without having to go through the hassle of individually listing and selling cards. Customer service is friendly and everything is reasonably fast.
If you use them I highly recommend you unsleeve all the cards you’re shipping first. It’s a little extra work on your part but it’s worth it.
I love how easy they make it to downsize my collection and trim what not actually using, without having to go through the hassle of individually listing and selling cards. Customer service is friendly and everything is reasonably fast.
If you use them I highly recommend you unsleeve all the cards you’re shipping first. It’s a little extra work on your part but it’s worth it.
Connor Cranston
Review left Dec 04 2025
Review
Everything was as easy as could be. The team communicated with me every step of the way, and I loved the little stats review they give once the order is fully processed. 100% satisfied with my experience.
Everything was as easy as could be. The team communicated with me every step of the way, and I loved the little stats review they give once the order is fully processed. 100% satisfied with my experience.
Martishius Magic
Review left Dec 04 2025
Review
One thing I learned with this order is that it's important to pre-grade your cards-- at the very least you should glance over them and do your best to be aware of their condition before you send them in. If you only look at the NM price when using the price checker, you will be disappointed. Custome
...
Read more
One thing I learned with this order is that it's important to pre-grade your cards-- at the very least you should glance over them and do your best to be aware of their condition before you send them in. If you only look at the NM price when using the price checker, you will be disappointed. Customer Service is great and showed me card conditions and gave me a thorough breakdown of my card grades. This is a great service and is super helpful to people who just don't have unlimited time to list everything. Being able to just send stuff out is super helpful.
Keith Lewis
Review left Dec 03 2025
Review
Card Conduit is my first stop after every prelease these days. After I get through with playing for the weekend, I take the big hits and ship them right out to them. It has been great at keeping the hobby affordable for me, and these cards were from two events at my LGS, so I actually made a little
...
Read more
Card Conduit is my first stop after every prelease these days. After I get through with playing for the weekend, I take the big hits and ship them right out to them. It has been great at keeping the hobby affordable for me, and these cards were from two events at my LGS, so I actually made a little profit this set release.
With Card Conduit, I got to play a bunch of magic, kept a ton of cool cards from the set, and sold a few bombs for a profit. Everybody wins!
With Card Conduit, I got to play a bunch of magic, kept a ton of cool cards from the set, and sold a few bombs for a profit. Everybody wins!
Jamie
Review left Dec 03 2025
Review
Everything was super easy and fast to process and turnaround. Will definitely use again when I've sorted more cards
Everything was super easy and fast to process and turnaround. Will definitely use again when I've sorted more cards
S
Review left Dec 03 2025
Review
I would definitely recommend Card Conduit. What really made it a no-brainer was the ability to import and export my collection in sane data formats that already worked with Moxfield. At that point, all I had to do was remove my sleeves and arrange them in order. Too easy.
I would definitely recommend Card Conduit. What really made it a no-brainer was the ability to import and export my collection in sane data formats that already worked with Moxfield. At that point, all I had to do was remove my sleeves and arrange them in order. Too easy.
Adam Berendt
Review left Dec 03 2025
Review
This is a great way to sell alot of mid to low value cards vs trying to sell them all yourself one at a time. Shipped and very quickly they gave me a very fair offer on my cards. Paid me within 2 days. I will use the service again.
This is a great way to sell alot of mid to low value cards vs trying to sell them all yourself one at a time. Shipped and very quickly they gave me a very fair offer on my cards. Paid me within 2 days. I will use the service again.
Caleb Grimes
Review left Dec 03 2025
Review
I like the process, the wait time isn’t bad, and card conduit gives the right value of what’s its worth. As long as you’re willing to do the sorting work, it’s the best buck for a card. Thank you. I’ll continue to use this platform as I process my collection
I like the process, the wait time isn’t bad, and card conduit gives the right value of what’s its worth. As long as you’re willing to do the sorting work, it’s the best buck for a card. Thank you. I’ll continue to use this platform as I process my collection
Luis Juarez
Review left Dec 03 2025
Review
Highly recommend using Card Conduit to sell your cards, as long as your collection is in good quality you'll get the best value for your cards. Does take around 1-2 weeks but well worth the wait.
Highly recommend using Card Conduit to sell your cards, as long as your collection is in good quality you'll get the best value for your cards. Does take around 1-2 weeks but well worth the wait.
Justin McAdams
Review left Dec 02 2025
Review
The process is simple and streamline no matter which route you take, the communication throughout the process and explanation at each step is wonderful. I've had a great experience selling cards and will definitely come back to do so again.
The process is simple and streamline no matter which route you take, the communication throughout the process and explanation at each step is wonderful. I've had a great experience selling cards and will definitely come back to do so again.
Leo VanderWhitte Ma
Review left Dec 02 2025
Review
Good communication and faq page/ shipping guide, sorted is the way to go
Good communication and faq page/ shipping guide, sorted is the way to go
Mike P
Review left Dec 02 2025
Shipment processed Nov 12 2025
Review
Have been clearing out my older bulk for MTG before i move and card conduit has been a great help in making it easy to ship off a lot of my cards for some extra value. Service is quick and the communication is top notch. Thank you all!
Have been clearing out my older bulk for MTG before i move and card conduit has been a great help in making it easy to ship off a lot of my cards for some extra value. Service is quick and the communication is top notch. Thank you all!
JC
Review left Dec 02 2025
Review
There just isn't an easier way available to turn some of your unused cardboard into cash. I am appreciative of this service.
There just isn't an easier way available to turn some of your unused cardboard into cash. I am appreciative of this service.
J.
Review left Dec 02 2025
Review
Hassle free way to cash in old cards from storage. Fair grading. Would recommend.
Hassle free way to cash in old cards from storage. Fair grading. Would recommend.
Anonymous
Review left Dec 01 2025
Shipment processed Nov 19 2025
$516.80
payout, $53.57
fees
Review
I have used Card Conduit many times to sell cards and the process is always low stress and satisfying with a high level of customer service. I recommend them!
I have used Card Conduit many times to sell cards and the process is always low stress and satisfying with a high level of customer service. I recommend them!
Nicholas
Review left Dec 01 2025
Review
I have been selling my Magic cards exclusively through Card Conduit for over a year now, and I simply cannot recommend them enough. Every single time, they consistently deliver the highest possible value for my collections.
Beyond the great value, the speed of their service is incredible. The en ... Read more
Beyond the great value, the speed of their service is incredible. The en ... Read more
I have been selling my Magic cards exclusively through Card Conduit for over a year now, and I simply cannot recommend them enough. Every single time, they consistently deliver the highest possible value for my collections.
Beyond the great value, the speed of their service is incredible. The entire process, from shipping to final payment, is remarkably fast. What truly sets them apart is their phenomenal customer experience and communication. They are transparent, responsive, and make you feel confident and informed throughout the whole submission process.
If you are looking to sell your MTG cards efficiently and profitably, Card Conduit is the only choice. They always deliver.
Beyond the great value, the speed of their service is incredible. The entire process, from shipping to final payment, is remarkably fast. What truly sets them apart is their phenomenal customer experience and communication. They are transparent, responsive, and make you feel confident and informed throughout the whole submission process.
If you are looking to sell your MTG cards efficiently and profitably, Card Conduit is the only choice. They always deliver.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).