Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5643)
caleb nedegaard
Review left Oct 05 2023
Review
It was a very smooth transaction. They kept me in the loop the whole process I knew exactly what stage my order was in only took about two weeks to get everything said and done and I sent a ton of cards in.
It was a very smooth transaction. They kept me in the loop the whole process I knew exactly what stage my order was in only took about two weeks to get everything said and done and I sent a ton of cards in.
Dayton
Review left Oct 05 2023
Review
Quick processing and clear reporting after receiving my collection. The staff was also quick to answer any questions I had about their process as a first time user.
Quick processing and clear reporting after receiving my collection. The staff was also quick to answer any questions I had about their process as a first time user.
Zakary M Shapiro
Review left Oct 04 2023
Review
Easy process, I was happy with the value they were able to provide so I could get some much needed cash out of cards I am not currently using
Easy process, I was happy with the value they were able to provide so I could get some much needed cash out of cards I am not currently using
Rob Pelletier
Review left Oct 04 2023
Shipment processed Sep 23 2023
Review
I think the process was very easy to sell my cards to card conduit. I got a very fair price for them and I had the money in my account within 10 days of them receiving my cards. The report was detailed and easy to understand how they graded my cards and the value for each one. Very positive experien
...
Read more
I think the process was very easy to sell my cards to card conduit. I got a very fair price for them and I had the money in my account within 10 days of them receiving my cards. The report was detailed and easy to understand how they graded my cards and the value for each one. Very positive experience for me and I will be using the service again to sell more cards in the future
Jeremy Miller
Review left Oct 04 2023
Shipment processed Sep 23 2023
$8.41
payout, No
fees
*Fees were waived during a special promotion.
Review
I was in need to shrink my collection to make space amoung other reasons and discovered Card Conduit. I sent in 400+ cards via UPS and wasn't expecting a massive payout or anything because of what I sent. They were far more than fair on the prices and service costs. I highly recommend using card con
...
Read more
I was in need to shrink my collection to make space amoung other reasons and discovered Card Conduit. I sent in 400+ cards via UPS and wasn't expecting a massive payout or anything because of what I sent. They were far more than fair on the prices and service costs. I highly recommend using card conduit if you are in need to either shrink your collection or sell it quickly as a whole.
Matthew Martin
Review left Oct 04 2023
Shipment processed Sep 23 2023
$1,706.46
payout, $169.10
fees
Review
Ya'll are remarkable! There is unbelievebale value in using your service. The process was so easy. So painless. I sent moderately sorted bulk from my shelves and was so shocked when I saw the amount they offered. I will use this service as often as I need to sell cards.
Ya'll are remarkable! There is unbelievebale value in using your service. The process was so easy. So painless. I sent moderately sorted bulk from my shelves and was so shocked when I saw the amount they offered. I will use this service as often as I need to sell cards.
Sammy A.
Review left Oct 03 2023
Review
Very straightforward and easy process. Very good prices. Customer service was fantastic. I was updated at each step of the way. I would recommend this to everyone I know and will only be using Card Conduit for here on out.
Very straightforward and easy process. Very good prices. Customer service was fantastic. I was updated at each step of the way. I would recommend this to everyone I know and will only be using Card Conduit for here on out.
Mike M.
Review left Oct 02 2023
Shipment processed Sep 22 2023
Review
Process was super easy and user friendly. I got good pricing for all my cards and skipped major fees and runs to the post office.
Process was super easy and user friendly. I got good pricing for all my cards and skipped major fees and runs to the post office.
Scott M.
Review left Oct 02 2023
Review
Other options may provide better net returns, but Card Conduit made selling off a collection accumulated over several years simple and straightforward. Saving the time that would otherwise have been required to individually sort and grade cards was well worth the processing fees to me and the final
...
Read more
Other options may provide better net returns, but Card Conduit made selling off a collection accumulated over several years simple and straightforward. Saving the time that would otherwise have been required to individually sort and grade cards was well worth the processing fees to me and the final payouts felt perfectly reasonable. I'm grateful for the service and would (and have) recommend them for anyone in a similar position.
Bernard
Review left Oct 02 2023
Shipment processed Sep 22 2023
Review
Been selling cards from card conduit thanks to playing with power!!! They told me everything I need to sell hwre and I love sending cards I dont need. Thanks Nick for the best customer service!!! Would have given 10 stars if I could!!
Been selling cards from card conduit thanks to playing with power!!! They told me everything I need to sell hwre and I love sending cards I dont need. Thanks Nick for the best customer service!!! Would have given 10 stars if I could!!
Sean
Review left Oct 02 2023
Review
I sorted approximately 170 cards myself to do the self sort option for the lowest fee. In hindsight it may have been better to do the curated, since it took me some time to catalogue and sort. This shows how good they are that the curated isn’t too much more of a fee, because that work can be cumb
...
Read more
I sorted approximately 170 cards myself to do the self sort option for the lowest fee. In hindsight it may have been better to do the curated, since it took me some time to catalogue and sort. This shows how good they are that the curated isn’t too much more of a fee, because that work can be cumbersome. Instructions were clear and easy. Shipping was easy, I got updates every step of the way. Will use again, possibly the standard service for my lower value cards in higher volume.
Isaac
Review left Oct 02 2023
Review
Good website. Good user interface. Good and fair payout. Good communication. Clear instructions.
All around good experience.
All around good experience.
Good website. Good user interface. Good and fair payout. Good communication. Clear instructions.
All around good experience.
All around good experience.
Joey Lewis
Review left Oct 02 2023
Review
The whole process was quite simple and hassle free. Would highly recommend a friend to use this platform.
The whole process was quite simple and hassle free. Would highly recommend a friend to use this platform.
Mike
Review left Oct 01 2023
Review
Easy, simple, and fast. Sure I could make more by selling them individually, but I don’t have time for that. Highly recommend.
Easy, simple, and fast. Sure I could make more by selling them individually, but I don’t have time for that. Highly recommend.
Alessandro
Review left Oct 01 2023
Review
Simple and smooth as expected. Service recommended
Simple and smooth as expected. Service recommended
Daniel A.
Review left Oct 01 2023
Review
The experience from Card Conduit was A+ top-notch. Everything about the service was properly disclosed and communicated ahead of time. All my questions were answered and the order was fulfilled as promised within the timeline. I was happy with the valuation which came in close to my estimations.
...
Read more
The experience from Card Conduit was A+ top-notch. Everything about the service was properly disclosed and communicated ahead of time. All my questions were answered and the order was fulfilled as promised within the timeline. I was happy with the valuation which came in close to my estimations. This is a perfect hassle-free solution for getting value out of the cards you're not actively playing with and their fees are reasonable r for the service.
Logan
Review left Oct 01 2023
Shipment processed Sep 18 2023
Review
I'm really happy with my experience. Very easy and fast
I'm really happy with my experience. Very easy and fast
Shain H
Review left Oct 01 2023
Review
Process was easy and the step by step guide was very informative during the whole process. I received a what I felt was a good value for my cards.
Process was easy and the step by step guide was very informative during the whole process. I received a what I felt was a good value for my cards.
Bethany H.
Review left Sep 30 2023
Review
My stepson had a large collection of cards (This shipment was 1 of 3!) that we didn't have the time or energy to go through card-by-card. We had a rough idea of what the collection might be worth, and tried to sell it personally. However, after no bites, we found Card Conduit. Thank goodness! Card
...
Read more
My stepson had a large collection of cards (This shipment was 1 of 3!) that we didn't have the time or energy to go through card-by-card. We had a rough idea of what the collection might be worth, and tried to sell it personally. However, after no bites, we found Card Conduit. Thank goodness! Card Conduit not only paid us fairly, their expert and thorough process ended up paying us out more than TWICE what we estimated we might get for the collection! Would ABSOLUTELY recommend to anyone looking for an easy shipping process and fair payout.
Phil Hedges
Review left Sep 29 2023
Review
I actually sent 1000 Magic the Gathering cards to another consignment company initially which required me to sleeve and topload every card. Once they received my order, they said my order was full of cards that didn't meet their minimum so they shipped all 1000 back to me in two boxes of just shippi
...
Read more
I actually sent 1000 Magic the Gathering cards to another consignment company initially which required me to sleeve and topload every card. Once they received my order, they said my order was full of cards that didn't meet their minimum so they shipped all 1000 back to me in two boxes of just shipping peanuts without securing the cards. I am actually surprised more weren't damaged. I reached out to a friend about other consignment companies and he pointed me in the direction of Card Conduit. I untoploaded all 1000 cards, left a large amount sleeved and shipped them off to Card Conduit. Within my package arriving in 24 hours to Card Conduit I had an update that it would take 4-5 business days to get my cards inspected and priced. I was blown away once I received the in-depth report of pricing, which in my eyes saved me a ton of time of having to list my cards myself and felt the offer was extremely fair. Payment was received within a couple of days after I got the chance to review the report and would recommend anyone looking to sell MTG cards to go through Card Conduit.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).