Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service

GJ
Review left Dec 21 2023
Shipment processed Nov 11 2023
$232.38 payout, $41.14 fees

Review

Got some cash for cards I had just sitting around, highly recommend
Got some cash for cards I had just sitting around, highly recommend
GJ
Review left Dec 21 2023
Shipment processed Nov 10 2023
$909.82 payout, $16.68 fees

Review

Send in cards, get money. As simple as that. Highly recommend.
Send in cards, get money. As simple as that. Highly recommend.
El
Review left Dec 21 2023
Shipment processed Dec 14 2023
$1,752.61 payout, $32.12 fees

Review

Typically, I always subtract $100 from the "quoted" near mint price because that is always what it ends up being, but keeping that in mind this service is always easy and not too stressful. I actually have another order in the pipeline with the expected report tomorrow! Would recommend.
Typically, I always subtract $100 from the "quoted" near mint price because that is always what it ends up being, but keeping that in mind this service is always easy and not too stressful. I actually have another order in the pipeline with the expected report tomorrow! Would recommend.
Peter
Review left Dec 21 2023
Shipment processed Dec 09 2023
$901.82 payout, $16.53 fees

Review

This is the best way to sell a large portion of your collection. Thank you for all of your hard work Card Conduit!
This is the best way to sell a large portion of your collection. Thank you for all of your hard work Card Conduit!
Evan Miller Watelet
Review left Dec 20 2023
Shipment processed Dec 09 2023
$906.36 payout, $16.61 fees

Review

It's relatively easy to use Card Conduit's price checker tool to sort your cards, and both times I've used them, they got me my money within 3 weeks. Plus, their fee is super reasonable!
It's relatively easy to use Card Conduit's price checker tool to sort your cards, and both times I've used them, they got me my money within 3 weeks. Plus, their fee is super reasonable!
Samo
Review left Dec 20 2023
Shipment processed Dec 09 2023
$120.46 payout, $5.68 fees

Review

I couldn’t be more pleased with this service. I will say that it takes some learning to optimize the experience for yourself, but in all it seems far and away the best thing you could possibly do with an unused collection.
I couldn’t be more pleased with this service. I will say that it takes some learning to optimize the experience for yourself, but in all it seems far and away the best thing you could possibly do with an unused collection.
Jason
Review left Dec 20 2023
Shipment processed Dec 08 2023
$318.37 payout, $6.50 fees

Review

Being newer to the hobby I was nervous but the entire process was super simple. I was very happy with everything, the communication, the process and the payouts. The fee seemed much smaller than any other company I was considering. Will definitely use Card Conduit again!
Being newer to the hobby I was nervous but the entire process was super simple. I was very happy with everything, the communication, the process and the payouts. The fee seemed much smaller than any other company I was considering. Will definitely use Card Conduit again!
Christopher L French
Review left Dec 20 2023
Shipment processed Nov 17 2023
$525.68 payout, $10.73 fees

Review

I recently had the pleasure of using Card Conduit's Curated and Sorted service for selling my Magic cards, and I must say, the experience was nothing short of exceptional. The process was straightforward and highly efficient. Card Conduit's new tools made the entire experience smooth and hassle-free ... Read more
I recently had the pleasure of using Card Conduit's Curated and Sorted service for selling my Magic cards, and I must say, the experience was nothing short of exceptional. The process was straightforward and highly efficient. Card Conduit's new tools made the entire experience smooth and hassle-free. Their professionalism and reliability were evident throughout the transaction, ensuring that I was comfortable and informed at every step.

One aspect I particularly appreciated was their rigorous grading standards. While initially, I found it challenging to align my expectations with their grading, especially for cards I personally curated from booster packs, I realized the importance of this approach. Their stringent grading mirrors the expectations of card exchanges, ensuring a fair and transparent process. This experience has been educational for me, helping me refine my understanding of card conditions.

Beyond the technicalities, what stood out was the friendly and trustworthy nature of their service. The team at Card Conduit was always approachable and responsive, making me feel valued as a customer. Their commitment to providing a reliable service is commendable.

In conclusion, I highly recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell Magic cards. Their professional, reliable, and customer-centric approach makes them a standout in the field. Whether you're a seasoned collector or new to the game, their service is tailored to meet your needs with utmost integrity and efficiency.
Tyler
Review left Dec 20 2023
Shipment processed Nov 17 2023
$219.92 payout, $4.49 fees

Review

We have had several transactions now with Card conduit, and they have all been fantastic. The pricing is more than fair compared to other buyers, and the process is completely streamlined. I would have no hesitation to use Card conduit again!
We have had several transactions now with Card conduit, and they have all been fantastic. The pricing is more than fair compared to other buyers, and the process is completely streamlined. I would have no hesitation to use Card conduit again!
Andy
Review left Dec 20 2023
Shipment processed Dec 14 2023
$387.77 payout, $7.11 fees

Review

The communication and customer service is amazing. I put a hold on this shipment just in case I didn’t like the final assessed value on one of the higher value cards. Card conduit communicated well and shipped the card back promptly while issuing payment for the remaining assessed cards.
The communication and customer service is amazing. I put a hold on this shipment just in case I didn’t like the final assessed value on one of the higher value cards. Card conduit communicated well and shipped the card back promptly while issuing payment for the remaining assessed cards.
James
Review left Dec 20 2023
Shipment processed Dec 16 2023
$1,030.30 payout, $21.03 fees

Review

Could not recommend Card Conduit more. The process was easy, well communicated, and fast, with my final payout being only slightly lower than the top end estimate. 10/10 will sell here again.
Could not recommend Card Conduit more. The process was easy, well communicated, and fast, with my final payout being only slightly lower than the top end estimate. 10/10 will sell here again.
Timothy
Review left Dec 19 2023
Shipment processed Dec 13 2023
$114.71 payout, $32.94 fees

Review

The process was good. Decent return. Would recommend to a friend. Can't beat the convenience.
The process was good. Decent return. Would recommend to a friend. Can't beat the convenience.
Justin Vandergriff
Review left Dec 19 2023
Shipment processed Dec 12 2023
$87.89 payout, $1.79 fees

Review

easy peasy! Sorting the cards wasnt really an issue but nice to know that i could just send in a bulk stack of cards if i wanted. overall nice experience! checking my prices before i shipped was super useful and made this a no brainer over other buylist services.
easy peasy! Sorting the cards wasnt really an issue but nice to know that i could just send in a bulk stack of cards if i wanted. overall nice experience! checking my prices before i shipped was super useful and made this a no brainer over other buylist services.
Tim
Review left Dec 19 2023
Shipment processed Dec 16 2023
$1,785.32 payout, $36.43 fees

Review

Service was great if you're in the market to sell a lot of cards. Great value for my collection. Only pain point is paying for shipping and shipping materials.
Service was great if you're in the market to sell a lot of cards. Great value for my collection. Only pain point is paying for shipping and shipping materials.
Jared S
Review left Dec 19 2023
Shipment processed Nov 15 2023
$1,972.53 payout, $192.38 fees

Review

It's always a pleasure being able to pack up a large amount of cards and ship them out knowing I will get the best value for them. It's quick and easy and headache free.
It's always a pleasure being able to pack up a large amount of cards and ship them out knowing I will get the best value for them. It's quick and easy and headache free.
JOHN HOPKINS
Review left Dec 19 2023
Shipment processed Nov 15 2023
$202.93 payout, $35.95 fees

Review

Will use this service many more times in the future!
Will use this service many more times in the future!
Tommy
Review left Dec 19 2023
Shipment processed Dec 02 2023
$2,437.06 payout, $128.27 fees

Review

Quick processing, fair pricing for what I was gonna try to do myself (sell at half price but include bulk to get rid of 20+ 5000ct boxes of .01 to .95 cards!) but this process was faster and helped save my business for the last 6 months of slowing jobs , bad economy and very few of us small and owne ... Read more
Quick processing, fair pricing for what I was gonna try to do myself (sell at half price but include bulk to get rid of 20+ 5000ct boxes of .01 to .95 cards!) but this process was faster and helped save my business for the last 6 months of slowing jobs , bad economy and very few of us small and owner/operator businesses made it through the Country shutdowns!! So Greatfull Thanks for y’all’s constant and consistent service!!
Nathan
Review left Dec 19 2023
Shipment processed Dec 07 2023

Review

Super fast process! The report provided is great and easy to understand. Payment was fast. I feel so much lighter without all my bulk Uncommon cards!
Super fast process! The report provided is great and easy to understand. Payment was fast. I feel so much lighter without all my bulk Uncommon cards!
Jacob Schacher
Review left Dec 18 2023
Shipment processed Dec 08 2023
$1,373.93 payout, $28.04 fees

Review

The service that Card Conduit offers is unlike any other.
Other Magic players out there might be unsure if it’s worth it or not. I assure you, it is!
The service that Card Conduit offers is unlike any other.
Other Magic players out there might be unsure if it’s worth it or not. I assure you, it is!
Chris
Review left Dec 17 2023
Shipment processed Dec 02 2023
$2,168.35 payout, $102.18 fees

Review

Great way to out a bunch of semi-sorted cards at once (I don't really get out to trade or sell singles any more, so I sent the contents of some trade binders and 'spec box' where I throw cards I'm not using when I notice they're worth something). Service was very smooth and I had payment within abo ... Read more
Great way to out a bunch of semi-sorted cards at once (I don't really get out to trade or sell singles any more, so I sent the contents of some trade binders and 'spec box' where I throw cards I'm not using when I notice they're worth something). Service was very smooth and I had payment within about a week of them receiving my cards. The Price Check feature is very helpful if you want to see an estimate of what you'll get for a card. Fees seem reasonable given the service they are providing. I think the only area that is likely to surprise people is the conservative grading of condition, which makes perfect sense to me with their business model. Unless you have a lot of experience with grading and have gone over your cards with a loupe, expect grades to be about one grade down from what you would say on a quick inspection with the naked eye, and you won't be disappointed.
1 2 ... 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 ... 274 275
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every previous customer to leave a review. Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page. We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).