Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6603)
Christopher Sampson
Review left Jul 04 2026
Review
I would recommend using Card Conduit, so simple and easy and they were there to answer any questions I had and gave me a very fair assessment of my cards. Thank you!!!
I would recommend using Card Conduit, so simple and easy and they were there to answer any questions I had and gave me a very fair assessment of my cards. Thank you!!!
Nick S
Review left Jul 04 2026
Review
The hardest part is sorting the cards according to the CSV they provide! Quick and easy. Got my money about a week after shipping the cards off.
My only “con” is that they are very strict on card condition. I was expecting around $2900 but got around $2550.
My only “con” is that they are very strict on card condition. I was expecting around $2900 but got around $2550.
The hardest part is sorting the cards according to the CSV they provide! Quick and easy. Got my money about a week after shipping the cards off.
My only “con” is that they are very strict on card condition. I was expecting around $2900 but got around $2550.
My only “con” is that they are very strict on card condition. I was expecting around $2900 but got around $2550.
Zezhong Huang
Review left Jul 04 2026
Review
This was my first and last time selling cards, in a good way. It was very easy for a beginner like me to leave my entire collection in your hands.
This was my first and last time selling cards, in a good way. It was very easy for a beginner like me to leave my entire collection in your hands.
Daren Carmola
Review left Jul 04 2026
Shipment processed Jun 24 2026
Review
It was good seeing the step by step process of my shipment. Upon completing the order, you get a breakdown of the items that was sent in. That's was a great addition to the service.
It was good seeing the step by step process of my shipment. Upon completing the order, you get a breakdown of the items that was sent in. That's was a great addition to the service.
Alex
Review left Jul 04 2026
Review
Wonderful customer service and up front pricing guides. Simple and straight forward with packing/shipping instructions. 12/10
Wonderful customer service and up front pricing guides. Simple and straight forward with packing/shipping instructions. 12/10
Jonathan C
Review left Jul 04 2026
Shipment processed Jun 24 2026
Review
Tried the auto-sifter method this time. I'm quite pleased with the analysis and the value I received.
Tried the auto-sifter method this time. I'm quite pleased with the analysis and the value I received.
Patrick A.
Review left Jul 03 2026
Review
From clear instructions on how to best ship the cards, to step by step status updates as the cards went thru their checks all the way up to the super fast payment - it was so easy to use Card Conduit! Start to finish with Card Conduit really was basically one week. It was awesome and I highly recommend them!
From clear instructions on how to best ship the cards, to step by step status updates as the cards went thru their checks all the way up to the super fast payment - it was so easy to use Card Conduit! Start to finish with Card Conduit really was basically one week. It was awesome and I highly recommend them!
Michael
Review left Jul 03 2026
Review
Easy process as always. This is still my absolute favorite way to buylist my unused cards!
Easy process as always. This is still my absolute favorite way to buylist my unused cards!
Dan B.
Review left Jul 03 2026
Review
I've used the Sorted service a few times now, and have been satisfied in each case. My one nitpick in the past was that their processing times were slower than a certain other well-known service provider. However, the turnaround for this order felt noticeably faster. If that continues, I expect to e
...
Read more
I've used the Sorted service a few times now, and have been satisfied in each case. My one nitpick in the past was that their processing times were slower than a certain other well-known service provider. However, the turnaround for this order felt noticeably faster. If that continues, I expect to exclusively use CC for mail/courier-based buy-listing going forward.
Marco
Review left Jul 03 2026
Review
would recommend 10/10. great communication. always helpful
would recommend 10/10. great communication. always helpful
Marco
Review left Jul 03 2026
Review
would recommend 10/10. great communication. always helpful
would recommend 10/10. great communication. always helpful
Marco
Review left Jul 03 2026
Review
would recommend 10/10. great communication. always helpful
would recommend 10/10. great communication. always helpful
Marco
Review left Jul 03 2026
Review
would recommend 10/10. great communication. always helpful
would recommend 10/10. great communication. always helpful
marco
Review left Jul 03 2026
Review
would recommend 10/10. great communication. always helpful
would recommend 10/10. great communication. always helpful
Marco
Review left Jul 03 2026
Review
would recommend 10/10. great communication. always helpful
would recommend 10/10. great communication. always helpful
Brett Anderson
Review left Jul 02 2026
Shipment processed Jun 17 2026
Review
The process was very straight forward. I was kept up to date and informed of what was happening with my order. I am off loading a lot of cards and their business is the best i have come across.
The process was very straight forward. I was kept up to date and informed of what was happening with my order. I am off loading a lot of cards and their business is the best i have come across.
Mtg
Review left Jul 02 2026
Review
No complaints - fair offer for not much time invested
No complaints - fair offer for not much time invested
Jeff
Review left Jul 02 2026
Review
Great job. They did everything fast and got it done sooner then expected. However I sent 1 card that they stated was lightly played and got $50.00 less. It pulled straight from pack to sleeve and never played. And was in my mind nearly mint. Have read other comments that have mentioned similar.
Great job. They did everything fast and got it done sooner then expected. However I sent 1 card that they stated was lightly played and got $50.00 less. It pulled straight from pack to sleeve and never played. And was in my mind nearly mint. Have read other comments that have mentioned similar.
Garrett
Review left Jul 02 2026
Review
The process was super easy. I appreciated the upfront information on grading and how it may affect pricing.
The process was super easy. I appreciated the upfront information on grading and how it may affect pricing.
sam
Review left Jul 02 2026
Review
offload a bunch of cards quick processing and great communication
offload a bunch of cards quick processing and great communication
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).