Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5856)
Tara
Review left Feb 03 2026
Review
This was my first time using the website and I appreciated the step-by-step process outline and ease of adding cards to the buylist. You even get an itemized report at the end - a step up from the oftentimes obfuscated price estimate you get from other buyers. I also received my payout quite quick
...
Read more
This was my first time using the website and I appreciated the step-by-step process outline and ease of adding cards to the buylist. You even get an itemized report at the end - a step up from the oftentimes obfuscated price estimate you get from other buyers. I also received my payout quite quickly.
Nick even reached out and provided some guidance as I had some inauthentic cards in my collection as to how to root those out in the future. I'm currently paring down my collection and if I have more cards I want to sell then I will certainly use this service again.
Nick even reached out and provided some guidance as I had some inauthentic cards in my collection as to how to root those out in the future. I'm currently paring down my collection and if I have more cards I want to sell then I will certainly use this service again.
Cristian Villaran
Review left Feb 03 2026
Review
I refuse to elaborate. I will hit this fifty character minimum and move on.
I refuse to elaborate. I will hit this fifty character minimum and move on.
James Fagan
Review left Feb 03 2026
Review
I appreciated having the option to organize the cards ahead of time to maintain more of the profit! Would highly recommend this site for folks trying to get money for cards
I appreciated having the option to organize the cards ahead of time to maintain more of the profit! Would highly recommend this site for folks trying to get money for cards
kingjrod
Review left Feb 03 2026
Review
this was my first this through with Card Conduit, the process was really straight forward, and when i had questions the comms from the CC team were great. I would highly recommend their service
this was my first this through with Card Conduit, the process was really straight forward, and when i had questions the comms from the CC team were great. I would highly recommend their service
craig
Review left Feb 03 2026
Review
Highly recommend for anyone who has excess cards laying around that they do not use to convert into something they will play with!
Highly recommend for anyone who has excess cards laying around that they do not use to convert into something they will play with!
Jonathan Klaskala
Review left Feb 02 2026
Review
Suggest sorting it yourself to save money, fair pricing, really easy and worth it.
Suggest sorting it yourself to save money, fair pricing, really easy and worth it.
Walter
Review left Feb 02 2026
Review
the stuck to their timeframe they initially gave me, no delays!
the stuck to their timeframe they initially gave me, no delays!
Cody Bujnowski
Review left Feb 02 2026
Review
The process was easy with lost of direction for what to do and follow ups to guarantee accuracy. I am likely to recommend to others.
The process was easy with lost of direction for what to do and follow ups to guarantee accuracy. I am likely to recommend to others.
John
Review left Feb 02 2026
Review
Fast, easy and clean process. Very happy with the quickness the whole process takes.
Fast, easy and clean process. Very happy with the quickness the whole process takes.
Lorelei
Review left Feb 02 2026
Review
I used the sorted service. Once I got everything packed and in order, Card Conduit made the rest a breeze. The buy list prices they paid out were optimum, and they completed cataloguing and grading within their estimated window of service. Thanks Card Conduit!
I used the sorted service. Once I got everything packed and in order, Card Conduit made the rest a breeze. The buy list prices they paid out were optimum, and they completed cataloguing and grading within their estimated window of service. Thanks Card Conduit!
Jason
Review left Feb 01 2026
Review
Easy quick process. Good stuff. Took about 14 days start to finish
Easy quick process. Good stuff. Took about 14 days start to finish
Estevan Salcido
Review left Feb 01 2026
Review
Process was fun and easy when you use a scanning app and import the data directly. I didn't have to do much with the curated service and got paid fast!
Process was fun and easy when you use a scanning app and import the data directly. I didn't have to do much with the curated service and got paid fast!
R. Kaplan
Review left Feb 01 2026
Review
Once again a very streamlined process. CC comes through, realistic, fun, and not all that difficult to navigate. No hiccups again, I'll be sending more cards soon! Thanks guys and gals.
Once again a very streamlined process. CC comes through, realistic, fun, and not all that difficult to navigate. No hiccups again, I'll be sending more cards soon! Thanks guys and gals.
Sam P
Review left Feb 01 2026
Review
Very clear about the pricing, transparent about grading and communication is pretty top notch. Overall happy with the whole deal and got more money than I thought I would bringing my cards to different places. Card look up is easy and quick as well.
Very clear about the pricing, transparent about grading and communication is pretty top notch. Overall happy with the whole deal and got more money than I thought I would bringing my cards to different places. Card look up is easy and quick as well.
Oakland, CA
Review left Feb 01 2026
Shipment processed Jan 21 2026
$358.01
payout, $7.31
fees
Review
Card Conduit's purchasing process was great. I opted for a sorted shipment, because I wanted to keep my bulk and only sell the cards that were worth something. When I uploaded my list, Card Conduit provided a clear spreadsheet showing me what each card was selling for. That let me pull out a few car
...
Read more
Card Conduit's purchasing process was great. I opted for a sorted shipment, because I wanted to keep my bulk and only sell the cards that were worth something. When I uploaded my list, Card Conduit provided a clear spreadsheet showing me what each card was selling for. That let me pull out a few cards that I wanted to save, then sort and ship the rest. The shipment was easy, their grading was fair, and everything went by the numbers!
If I *didn't* want to keep my bulk, it would 100% be worth it to use one of the services where they go through your cards for you, and charge a slightly higher fee. I've already recommended them to other folks who have cards gathering dust.
If I *didn't* want to keep my bulk, it would 100% be worth it to use one of the services where they go through your cards for you, and charge a slightly higher fee. I've already recommended them to other folks who have cards gathering dust.
AJ
Review left Feb 01 2026
Review
Best way to get cash for your collection if you don't have the time or energy necessary to sell individual cards. Would and will continue to recommend.
Best way to get cash for your collection if you don't have the time or energy necessary to sell individual cards. Would and will continue to recommend.
Erik Blaser
Review left Jan 31 2026
Review
Clear, transparent, rational, communicative. Great service all around!
Clear, transparent, rational, communicative. Great service all around!
Jeremy
Review left Jan 31 2026
Review
Easy process throughout and I received a very fair price. I will be using the service much more in the future.
Easy process throughout and I received a very fair price. I will be using the service much more in the future.
A Bonin
Review left Jan 31 2026
Shipment processed Jan 22 2026
Review
The process was very easy. I did the curated choice and sent about 175 cards. I sent via UPS and put extra insurance on the package since I estimated the value at over $2000. With the insurance, shipping was about $55 from Florida to Utah. Once received it only took about 4 days for the card gradin
...
Read more
The process was very easy. I did the curated choice and sent about 175 cards. I sent via UPS and put extra insurance on the package since I estimated the value at over $2000. With the insurance, shipping was about $55 from Florida to Utah. Once received it only took about 4 days for the card grading and value results to come. I was very pleased with the offer. I would say the payout was about 70% of value. Payment followed directly to my bank within two days of the result. So much easier than trying to sell thru other methods, and better payout. Will definitely use them again. Also, using the promo code saved me a few dollars as well! Highly recommended.
Dan
Review left Jan 31 2026
Review
I have used this service multiple times and I have never been disappointed.
I have used this service multiple times and I have never been disappointed.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).