Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5628)
Scott Stanton
Review left Jan 03 2026
Review
I elected the self sorted method and was happy with the end result and quick payment
I elected the self sorted method and was happy with the end result and quick payment
Justin Atienza
Review left Jan 03 2026
Review
This is the second time I've used card conduit to sell multiple cards. I really needed money this time so I had to sell over 500 cards. I used the sorted option to get the most money out of it. It's just a little time consuming, but that's why we get more money for this. Plus, maybe it's just me, bu
...
Read more
This is the second time I've used card conduit to sell multiple cards. I really needed money this time so I had to sell over 500 cards. I used the sorted option to get the most money out of it. It's just a little time consuming, but that's why we get more money for this. Plus, maybe it's just me, but I love sorting my cards lol. So it's super enjoyable and I get a lot more money than selling at my local shop. It's also way faster and easier than trying to sell on marketplace or ebay or something. At the end of the day, if I need to sell a bunch of cards, I'm always going to Card Conduit.
Daniel Hamlin
Review left Jan 02 2026
Review
The whole process is slick. Doesn't take too much time or anything. N I was paid promptly. Overall great gig.
The whole process is slick. Doesn't take too much time or anything. N I was paid promptly. Overall great gig.
Travis Empey
Review left Jan 02 2026
Shipment processed Dec 06 2025
Review
Initially, I was hoping to get rid of 200lbs+ of Magic Cards. Ultimately, I decided to submit a more curated list of approximately 2,700 cards. Their process is very fast, transparent, and convenient. I only ran into one issue with the shipping. My box was returned to me for some reason (it may have
...
Read more
Initially, I was hoping to get rid of 200lbs+ of Magic Cards. Ultimately, I decided to submit a more curated list of approximately 2,700 cards. Their process is very fast, transparent, and convenient. I only ran into one issue with the shipping. My box was returned to me for some reason (it may have been an issue with the Post Office).
Overall, it was a great way to offload a large number of Magic cards that were gathering dust! Highly recommend.
Overall, it was a great way to offload a large number of Magic cards that were gathering dust! Highly recommend.
Eddie Morales
Review left Jan 02 2026
Review
I have never sold my MTG cards online but after looking at the process provided by Card Conduit, I gave them a chance, and I was pleasantly surprised by how easy it was to use their online process. You only need to follow the steps and the whole transaction was done in a matter of days once the card
...
Read more
I have never sold my MTG cards online but after looking at the process provided by Card Conduit, I gave them a chance, and I was pleasantly surprised by how easy it was to use their online process. You only need to follow the steps and the whole transaction was done in a matter of days once the cards got shipped and received. I got a very fair offer, and I got my payment sent soon thereafter directly to my bank account. I would recommend Card Conduit if anyone wants to sell their MTG cards quick and easy.
John Boyer
Review left Jan 02 2026
Review
I was hesitant going through Card Conduit to sell my cards , but I'm really glad that I did. The process is seamless and the even the staff reaching out to us in a separate email after the shipment had been confirmed was really nice actually and was more than we expected. I will continue to utilize selling my cards through CC. Great company.
I was hesitant going through Card Conduit to sell my cards , but I'm really glad that I did. The process is seamless and the even the staff reaching out to us in a separate email after the shipment had been confirmed was really nice actually and was more than we expected. I will continue to utilize selling my cards through CC. Great company.
Frederick Balsley
Review left Jan 01 2026
Review
I will be using them again, Many times hopefully!!
I will be using them again, Many times hopefully!!
Joshua Cunningham
Review left Jan 01 2026
Review
Speedy processing with notifications throught the whole of it. Very fair grading standards. Will utilize the service again!
Speedy processing with notifications throught the whole of it. Very fair grading standards. Will utilize the service again!
Chris Clear
Review left Jan 01 2026
Review
Another bulk filled with some wonderful hidden gems that I wasn't aware of before sending to Card Conduit but I am very pleased with their payout process and the detailed review sheet they provided! Card Conduit has now become a well-known name among all of my friends who collect bulk.
Another bulk filled with some wonderful hidden gems that I wasn't aware of before sending to Card Conduit but I am very pleased with their payout process and the detailed review sheet they provided! Card Conduit has now become a well-known name among all of my friends who collect bulk.
Josh
Review left Jan 01 2026
Review
Before choosing to sell my cards to Card Conduit I made sure to look at all of my options. I compared offers from my LGS, eBay, TCGPlayer, and Card Conduit. Card Conduit offered extremely competitive prices, and had the most streamlined and transparent process out of all of the options.
I chose ... Read more
I chose ... Read more
Before choosing to sell my cards to Card Conduit I made sure to look at all of my options. I compared offers from my LGS, eBay, TCGPlayer, and Card Conduit. Card Conduit offered extremely competitive prices, and had the most streamlined and transparent process out of all of the options.
I chose to use their pre sorted option, and was paid within a week of them receiving my cards. Their assessment of the condition of my cards was very fair, and I received consistent communication from them during the process.
I would highly recommend selling to Card Conduit for anyone looking to cash out their MTG collection.
I chose to use their pre sorted option, and was paid within a week of them receiving my cards. Their assessment of the condition of my cards was very fair, and I received consistent communication from them during the process.
I would highly recommend selling to Card Conduit for anyone looking to cash out their MTG collection.
Travis
Review left Jan 01 2026
Review
I did a sorted sale of a large lot of cards I wanted to get a decent price on, but it was too many to sell individually. After picking my cards and maybe half an hour or sorting I was ready to ship to cardconduit, they had a very fast turnaround time and were quite fair with the pricing on the items I sold. I definitely would use cardconduit again.
I did a sorted sale of a large lot of cards I wanted to get a decent price on, but it was too many to sell individually. After picking my cards and maybe half an hour or sorting I was ready to ship to cardconduit, they had a very fast turnaround time and were quite fair with the pricing on the items I sold. I definitely would use cardconduit again.
Eric Omelia
Review left Jan 01 2026
Review
This is my second time selling to Card Conduit and I am just as impressed as last time. The order was handled professionally and quickly despite being right before the holiday. Compensation was fair. Only complaint was from the shippers end and not card conduit. Choose your shipper wisely!
This is my second time selling to Card Conduit and I am just as impressed as last time. The order was handled professionally and quickly despite being right before the holiday. Compensation was fair. Only complaint was from the shippers end and not card conduit. Choose your shipper wisely!
Roy Campbell
Review left Jan 01 2026
Review
Highly recommend definitely great pricing fast results
Highly recommend definitely great pricing fast results
Christina
Review left Jan 01 2026
Review
I loved that I could see the steps as they occurred and communication was wonderful and easy! I appreciated the helpful info on their site, which I felt set me up for success. :)
I loved that I could see the steps as they occurred and communication was wonderful and easy! I appreciated the helpful info on their site, which I felt set me up for success. :)
Will
Review left Jan 01 2026
Review
The process was very easy, the gradings were fair. Very pleased and will use their service again.
The process was very easy, the gradings were fair. Very pleased and will use their service again.
John
Review left Dec 31 2025
Shipment processed Nov 29 2025
Review
Card Conduit probably makes this process as easy as it could be. They give helpful instructions the whole way through the process. I was satisfied with the amount I received for my cards and was thankful that I didn't have to attempt to sell everything individually. Their communication is great. I w
...
Read more
Card Conduit probably makes this process as easy as it could be. They give helpful instructions the whole way through the process. I was satisfied with the amount I received for my cards and was thankful that I didn't have to attempt to sell everything individually. Their communication is great. I would recommend this service if you want to get rid of your cards and don't want to deal with the hassle of trying to sell them yourself.
Luc Michalski
Review left Dec 31 2025
Review
I love using card conduit to sell cards, they make it so simple, they keep you informed every step of the way, it's super easy to understand and get paid. I wish every company worked the way they work!
I love using card conduit to sell cards, they make it so simple, they keep you informed every step of the way, it's super easy to understand and get paid. I wish every company worked the way they work!
Mike Smith
Review left Dec 31 2025
Review
I have used Card Conduit multiple times, and they are my go to for selling cards.
I have used Card Conduit multiple times, and they are my go to for selling cards.
Chris
Review left Dec 31 2025
Review
Super easy to use and very prompt on communication and next steps. Have used them 3 times and always a great experience.
Super easy to use and very prompt on communication and next steps. Have used them 3 times and always a great experience.
Ethan Wasserburger
Review left Dec 31 2025
Review
I would say that this service was more than fair with their review of cards and their conditions. As part of my internal skepticism, all of the cards I sent in the Dr. Who set were completely brand new and never used. None of them were rated below "near mint" which made me feel like the cards were t
...
Read more
I would say that this service was more than fair with their review of cards and their conditions. As part of my internal skepticism, all of the cards I sent in the Dr. Who set were completely brand new and never used. None of them were rated below "near mint" which made me feel like the cards were thoroughly checked.
Roughly 12 of the cards had fallen below the 50 cent minimum value in the 2 weeks between shipping to grading results. However, all of them were still given 50 cent credit which was great to see that the full collection was paid for.
I'm planning to proxy my cards from now on so this will likely be the only time I sell my collection. I have no regrets about this service.
Roughly 12 of the cards had fallen below the 50 cent minimum value in the 2 weeks between shipping to grading results. However, all of them were still given 50 cent credit which was great to see that the full collection was paid for.
I'm planning to proxy my cards from now on so this will likely be the only time I sell my collection. I have no regrets about this service.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).