Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6841)
Adam
Review left Sep 16 2026
Review
Easy process for moving cards quickly. I tried the e-Bay route and was met with higher fees, postage, and massive spreadsheets for tracking. By using Manabox to inventory and pre-sort cards, list matching was a snap and easier than scoping several buy lists. My disappointments were really my reality
...
Read more
Easy process for moving cards quickly. I tried the e-Bay route and was met with higher fees, postage, and massive spreadsheets for tracking. By using Manabox to inventory and pre-sort cards, list matching was a snap and easier than scoping several buy lists. My disappointments were really my reality check: Not all cards (rare/mythic/foil) are on lists, my idea of conditions/grading are different, and you're not going to get that e-Bay market price for every card. If your inventory app you use says you have $1K in market price cards, do not expect that will be your payout. Conditions and demands greatly effect offer prices. Additional, this service does a fantastic job of keeping you informed through the whole process. I felt valued as a customer when seeing my sale go through each of the steps.
Jake
Review left Sep 16 2026
Review
Had about 400 cards that I wasn’t using and didn’t have plans to use, typed them into the sorted service option, shipped them out, and received a fair offer within 3 days. The service gives you a price estimate before you send the cards so there are no surprises along the way. A+ service. Will use again!
Had about 400 cards that I wasn’t using and didn’t have plans to use, typed them into the sorted service option, shipped them out, and received a fair offer within 3 days. The service gives you a price estimate before you send the cards so there are no surprises along the way. A+ service. Will use again!
Cory
Review left Sep 16 2026
Review
Card Conduit made the entire process easy to follow and quickly provided me with a payment for my cards.
Card Conduit made the entire process easy to follow and quickly provided me with a payment for my cards.
Kevin Tran
Review left Sep 16 2026
Review
Easy i basically just stock pile rares and send it to them now
Easy i basically just stock pile rares and send it to them now
Brian B.
Review left Sep 16 2026
Review
This was the best experience I have ever had in selling cards off in bulk amounts. Card conduit was super fast and transparent through the entire process. I have talked non-stop about how seamless everything was from start to finish with all of my other card collecting friends. Will without a doubt
...
Read more
This was the best experience I have ever had in selling cards off in bulk amounts. Card conduit was super fast and transparent through the entire process. I have talked non-stop about how seamless everything was from start to finish with all of my other card collecting friends. Will without a doubt be utilizing Card Conduit and their amazing staff again very soon for another order as well as the foreseeable future. Keep up the amazing work!
David Ding
Review left Sep 15 2026
Review
I felt that I received good value for the cards that I sold.
I felt that I received good value for the cards that I sold.
Marcel R
Review left Sep 14 2026
Review
Extremely happy with the Card Conduit process! I sent a bunch of unused cards that I didn't really expect to have a return, but the payout was far beyond what I thought. Thanks Card Conduit for making the process so easy and efficient!
Extremely happy with the Card Conduit process! I sent a bunch of unused cards that I didn't really expect to have a return, but the payout was far beyond what I thought. Thanks Card Conduit for making the process so easy and efficient!
Maxime
Review left Sep 14 2026
Review
Been selling cards through CC for a while now. I keep coming back because the experience is always smooth and reliable. Their grading is fair and their process clearly streamlined. Will keep using them in the future.
Been selling cards through CC for a while now. I keep coming back because the experience is always smooth and reliable. Their grading is fair and their process clearly streamlined. Will keep using them in the future.
chris H
Review left Sep 13 2026
Review
Sent off another shipment and Card Conduit delivered again. Sorting and selling singles individually is an exhausting grind, so having a service that accurately grades, breaks down the numbers transparently, and pays out quickly is a huge relief. Consistent, reliable, and well worth it.
Sent off another shipment and Card Conduit delivered again. Sorting and selling singles individually is an exhausting grind, so having a service that accurately grades, breaks down the numbers transparently, and pays out quickly is a huge relief. Consistent, reliable, and well worth it.
David
Review left Sep 12 2026
Review
The process was super easy and fast and I got great value for my cards.
The process was super easy and fast and I got great value for my cards.
Clint McCaslin
Review left Sep 12 2026
Shipment processed Aug 25 2026
Review
My only problem was that the check took a long time to arrive after payment was confirmed.
My only problem was that the check took a long time to arrive after payment was confirmed.
Justin chan
Review left Sep 12 2026
Review
The process from start to finish was great. They even followed up with me to make sure I was paid appropriately. Everything was detailed in the report and I got back more money than I expected. I plan to use this service again if I have extra magic bulk
The process from start to finish was great. They even followed up with me to make sure I was paid appropriately. Everything was detailed in the report and I got back more money than I expected. I plan to use this service again if I have extra magic bulk
Rowell C.
Review left Sep 11 2026
Review
The process was super easy and I believe a fair price and assessment was given for the cards.
The process was super easy and I believe a fair price and assessment was given for the cards.
Dustin
Review left Sep 10 2026
Review
I got a lot of value out of card conduit. It did take me about 2 days to prepare and ship my 100ish cards as I sorted them myself and went above and beyond with my packaging and shipping. If you are willing to accept that you are gonna pay for shipping and do the work of making sure it's the exact
...
Read more
I got a lot of value out of card conduit. It did take me about 2 days to prepare and ship my 100ish cards as I sorted them myself and went above and beyond with my packaging and shipping. If you are willing to accept that you are gonna pay for shipping and do the work of making sure it's the exact version of each card and triple checking the list order its wonderful. I would do it again for sure.
Tyrel Somers
Review left Sep 10 2026
Review
If you are on the fence about Card Conduit, do not be. They are top-notch. Communication and speed are beyond expectation. I recommend them 100%.
If you are on the fence about Card Conduit, do not be. They are top-notch. Communication and speed are beyond expectation. I recommend them 100%.
Mitchell Lesteberg
Review left Sep 10 2026
Review
Everything went well!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Everything went well!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
C S
Review left Sep 10 2026
Review
Sold the bulk of my collection, more than 3,000 cards in a single shipment and the process was very easy. The most frustrating part was getting the shipping itself organized, but that is not at fault of Card Conduit. Once my cards got there, I could see updates along the way as it was being processe
...
Read more
Sold the bulk of my collection, more than 3,000 cards in a single shipment and the process was very easy. The most frustrating part was getting the shipping itself organized, but that is not at fault of Card Conduit. Once my cards got there, I could see updates along the way as it was being processed and how much more was needed to be done. Very satisfied with the final payout and the stats showing the breakdown of all the cards. Payment was received quickly and without issue and I will definitely be recommending for anyone looking for an easy way to sell of their cards like this.
Johnny
Review left Sep 09 2026
Review
I've used Card Conduit multiple times now. I find their grading very fair and their customer service excellent. I'll be using them every time I sell going forward.
I've used Card Conduit multiple times now. I find their grading very fair and their customer service excellent. I'll be using them every time I sell going forward.
Scott Liebenhaut
Review left Sep 09 2026
Review
This was beyond easy! They were open and up-front from the beginning, and I feel was more than fair, way more than ANY other site to sell to. The report I received before finalizing was awesome, and I've shown all my friends who might be interested in selling some of their collections. I highly recommend! Will definitely do business with again!
This was beyond easy! They were open and up-front from the beginning, and I feel was more than fair, way more than ANY other site to sell to. The report I received before finalizing was awesome, and I've shown all my friends who might be interested in selling some of their collections. I highly recommend! Will definitely do business with again!
Corey Hart
Review left Sep 09 2026
Review
From start to finish, the process was seamless. The tools card conduit offers to help sort, stage, and ship made the process super user-friendly. If, and when I’m ready to unload more inventory card conduit will definitely be my source.
From start to finish, the process was seamless. The tools card conduit offers to help sort, stage, and ship made the process super user-friendly. If, and when I’m ready to unload more inventory card conduit will definitely be my source.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).