Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5627)
Taylor Troxtel
Review left Jan 12 2026
Review
Super easy to ship out some high value cards and get cash quickly. Upon arriving at the processing place, the team processed my trade in within 4 days and I got paid out within 10 business days of shipping. Definitely going to use Card Conduit again!
Super easy to ship out some high value cards and get cash quickly. Upon arriving at the processing place, the team processed my trade in within 4 days and I got paid out within 10 business days of shipping. Definitely going to use Card Conduit again!
Michael
Review left Jan 12 2026
Review
I've sold Magic cards to Card Conduit before and I've always had a good experience. Typically I make my own sell lists, but this time I just threw them all in a box and sent them in unsorted. They did the work for me and gave me a fair offer. Overall it was easy and I'd definitely do it again ;-)
I've sold Magic cards to Card Conduit before and I've always had a good experience. Typically I make my own sell lists, but this time I just threw them all in a box and sent them in unsorted. They did the work for me and gave me a fair offer. Overall it was easy and I'd definitely do it again ;-)
Frederick K Brenchley
Review left Jan 11 2026
Review
The process was so easy, and if the US Postal service wouldnt of sent my cards to Georgia for no reason, things would of happened much sooner! Will use again! Thanks Card Conduit!
The process was so easy, and if the US Postal service wouldnt of sent my cards to Georgia for no reason, things would of happened much sooner! Will use again! Thanks Card Conduit!
Brandon
Review left Jan 11 2026
Review
Sent in a large collection of bulk rares or cards I didn't think I'd ever play. Got a check in 10 days. Right around the holidays too. Superb company.
Sent in a large collection of bulk rares or cards I didn't think I'd ever play. Got a check in 10 days. Right around the holidays too. Superb company.
Chris
Review left Jan 11 2026
Review
This was a helpful service for selling cards without the hassle of ebay. When I noticed that the quoted price for a damaged card seemed low. They sent it back without a fuss, and I ebay'd it myself.
This was a helpful service for selling cards without the hassle of ebay. When I noticed that the quoted price for a damaged card seemed low. They sent it back without a fuss, and I ebay'd it myself.
Doris
Review left Jan 10 2026
Review
Process was easy,fair value paid as soon as the process was complete
Process was easy,fair value paid as soon as the process was complete
Anto
Review left Jan 10 2026
Shipment processed Dec 31 2025
Review
super simple to work with and never any trouble. love not worrying about sorting everything.
super simple to work with and never any trouble. love not worrying about sorting everything.
John Boyer
Review left Jan 10 2026
Review
This was my second shipment through CC and I could not be happier with the results. The process is seamless and I love seeing what cards were worth the most and the little facts about the artists too.
This was my second shipment through CC and I could not be happier with the results. The process is seamless and I love seeing what cards were worth the most and the little facts about the artists too.
Robert Kaplan
Review left Jan 09 2026
Review
Straight to the point these guys were terrific, from the start to finish. Their estimations on what the values of the cards would be was dead on, and I received close to 100% of that estimate, no nonsense, cut and dry, timely. Thanks all.
Straight to the point these guys were terrific, from the start to finish. Their estimations on what the values of the cards would be was dead on, and I received close to 100% of that estimate, no nonsense, cut and dry, timely. Thanks all.
3am Cards
Review left Jan 09 2026
Review
Perfect service for getting rid of my unneeded cards.
Perfect service for getting rid of my unneeded cards.
Brad HG
Review left Jan 08 2026
Review
Easy process, good reimbursement, efficient. Will use again!
Easy process, good reimbursement, efficient. Will use again!
Jose
Review left Jan 08 2026
Shipment processed Dec 31 2025
Review
Their shipping process was easy and their card processing time speedy considering the task. Their customer service was very helpful, keeping me informed at every step. They even helped in splitting the order when it turned out I had went over their limit on cards per shipment. I would definitely recommend their services.
Their shipping process was easy and their card processing time speedy considering the task. Their customer service was very helpful, keeping me informed at every step. They even helped in splitting the order when it turned out I had went over their limit on cards per shipment. I would definitely recommend their services.
Larry G
Review left Jan 08 2026
Review
Basically all that you want. Plus very fair prices and charges in my opinion, especially for not having to build a list of what's included in large orders. Would definitely use again and recommend to anyone. Thanks CC!
Basically all that you want. Plus very fair prices and charges in my opinion, especially for not having to build a list of what's included in large orders. Would definitely use again and recommend to anyone. Thanks CC!
Coree
Review left Jan 08 2026
Shipment processed Dec 05 2025
Review
I shipped the cards in and a week or 2 later, I got a good and fair price for them. Very easy process.
I shipped the cards in and a week or 2 later, I got a good and fair price for them. Very easy process.
Travis
Review left Jan 08 2026
Review
In about 5 shipments now and very little issues if at all, and if so they are handled quickly and fairly. No complaints. Best way to move those intermediate card that you cant really find buyers for and you know youll never need or use. I have thousands more to move through C.C and I look forward to keeping my collection clean and tidy this way!!
In about 5 shipments now and very little issues if at all, and if so they are handled quickly and fairly. No complaints. Best way to move those intermediate card that you cant really find buyers for and you know youll never need or use. I have thousands more to move through C.C and I look forward to keeping my collection clean and tidy this way!!
Max Luna
Review left Jan 07 2026
Review
Great reports with a quick payout helps me feel secure when selling to CC.
Great reports with a quick payout helps me feel secure when selling to CC.
Max Luna
Review left Jan 07 2026
Review
Good payout and great reports, this always helps me feel secure when selling to CC.
Good payout and great reports, this always helps me feel secure when selling to CC.
Donnie
Review left Jan 07 2026
Review
I had a very good experience with Card Conduit. I’d been wanting to unload a large bulk amount of cards for a long time, but the thought of sorting, pricing, and selling everything myself was overwhelming. Card Conduit made the process quick and easy, offering options that range from very simple t
...
Read more
I had a very good experience with Card Conduit. I’d been wanting to unload a large bulk amount of cards for a long time, but the thought of sorting, pricing, and selling everything myself was overwhelming. Card Conduit made the process quick and easy, offering options that range from very simple to more involved paths for higher returns. I chose the fast, straightforward route and couldn’t be happier. Communication throughout the process was excellent, everything moved along quickly, and their customer service was exceptional. I’ll definitely be using their service again in the future.
joseph kock
Review left Jan 07 2026
Review
was smooth, efficient and communication was good and fast
was smooth, efficient and communication was good and fast
Miles
Review left Jan 07 2026
Review
This was such an easy experience! I chose to organize my own sell list to lower the fees to a very reasonable amount and received payment within the estimated time (less than a week from when my cards were delivered to them). Also, when I realized I had labeled my shipment incorrectly, Nick Anderson
...
Read more
This was such an easy experience! I chose to organize my own sell list to lower the fees to a very reasonable amount and received payment within the estimated time (less than a week from when my cards were delivered to them). Also, when I realized I had labeled my shipment incorrectly, Nick Anderson from the support team was super quick to respond and fix my mistake. Will definitely sell to Card Conduit in the future!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).