Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(4363)
Matthew
Review left Nov 18 2024
Review
Can't complain, worked as advertised. Haven't received the check yet, but the entire process was as smooth as butter.
Can't complain, worked as advertised. Haven't received the check yet, but the entire process was as smooth as butter.
Daniel Needham
Review left Nov 17 2024
Review
Process was easy to start, only issue was the imported file pulled a hundred or so cards as the wrong type or just didn't register them, going to have to do a second shipment to finish, didn't see an easy way to add the un-included cards.
Process was easy to start, only issue was the imported file pulled a hundred or so cards as the wrong type or just didn't register them, going to have to do a second shipment to finish, didn't see an easy way to add the un-included cards.
Mike J
Review left Nov 17 2024
Review
What else can you ask for? Great service, and probably the best way to let somebody handle 1000+ cards that you just dont feel like sorting through. I recommend this service if you are a guy like me who doesn't mind getting about 70% for their cards at the cost of having to do 0 of the work of sorting/selling/shipping/e.t.c. A+ service!
What else can you ask for? Great service, and probably the best way to let somebody handle 1000+ cards that you just dont feel like sorting through. I recommend this service if you are a guy like me who doesn't mind getting about 70% for their cards at the cost of having to do 0 of the work of sorting/selling/shipping/e.t.c. A+ service!
Anna R
Review left Nov 15 2024
Shipment processed Nov 05 2024
$89.45
payout, $1.83
fees
Review
Very straightforward card selection forum with detailed instructions and made every step of the process clear. Would highly recommend to anyone.
Very straightforward card selection forum with detailed instructions and made every step of the process clear. Would highly recommend to anyone.
Michael
Review left Nov 15 2024
Review
Have sent one batch of cards in to test and they paid fair to value. I have since sent a larger batch in and am waiting for results on those.
The sorting is worth it to avoid extra fees but is quite a bit of work up front. My suggestion would be to alphabetize your cards that you know they will ... Read more
The sorting is worth it to avoid extra fees but is quite a bit of work up front. My suggestion would be to alphabetize your cards that you know they will ... Read more
Have sent one batch of cards in to test and they paid fair to value. I have since sent a larger batch in and am waiting for results on those.
The sorting is worth it to avoid extra fees but is quite a bit of work up front. My suggestion would be to alphabetize your cards that you know they will want so when they provide you the list you can easily find them in your stack. They do request that cards not be sleeved and I feel like there are a lot of mint condition cards that once you take them out of the sleeves and prepare for sorting and shipping takes them from mint to near mint, which can lower the payout. I do not know how to get around this. so if you are sending in expensive cards maybe just leave them sleeved and eat the cost for them to remove the sleeves.
Great service though, I plan to use them for more batches.
The sorting is worth it to avoid extra fees but is quite a bit of work up front. My suggestion would be to alphabetize your cards that you know they will want so when they provide you the list you can easily find them in your stack. They do request that cards not be sleeved and I feel like there are a lot of mint condition cards that once you take them out of the sleeves and prepare for sorting and shipping takes them from mint to near mint, which can lower the payout. I do not know how to get around this. so if you are sending in expensive cards maybe just leave them sleeved and eat the cost for them to remove the sleeves.
Great service though, I plan to use them for more batches.
Marshall Collier
Review left Nov 15 2024
Review
Second time using your service and all I got to say is A+++ Really appreciate what you do, and I hope to continue to do business with you!!
Second time using your service and all I got to say is A+++ Really appreciate what you do, and I hope to continue to do business with you!!
Nick M
Review left Nov 14 2024
Review
Although I am sad to have to get out of the magic scene, you guys made it painless and profitable to liquidate my connection. Thanks a bunch!
Although I am sad to have to get out of the magic scene, you guys made it painless and profitable to liquidate my connection. Thanks a bunch!
Nick Burger
Review left Nov 13 2024
Review
I have used this service many times now, and it is nothing if not easy, transparent, and consistent. A breeze to use, and customer service is excellent. As always, would highly recommend!
I have used this service many times now, and it is nothing if not easy, transparent, and consistent. A breeze to use, and customer service is excellent. As always, would highly recommend!
James
Review left Nov 13 2024
Shipment processed Nov 02 2024
Review
Processing was fast and easy, many of the cards I had where in various conditions so I wasn't sure of the prices but card conduits full breakdown was transparent and trustworthy. In addition to the full report their customer service followed up with an email explaining the price difference due to t
...
Read more
Processing was fast and easy, many of the cards I had where in various conditions so I wasn't sure of the prices but card conduits full breakdown was transparent and trustworthy. In addition to the full report their customer service followed up with an email explaining the price difference due to the condition, this was very helpful. If your looking to sell MTG card conduit is the best option I have seen and would recommend their services highly. Thanks for helping find my old cards a new home!
Michael Mazzola
Review left Nov 13 2024
Review
Easy and good payout for the amount of effort we have to do
Easy and good payout for the amount of effort we have to do
Dylan
Review left Nov 13 2024
Shipment processed Oct 10 2024
Review
I've sold to card conduit a few times and everytime my experience has been great. It's fast and easy to use and the amount you get back is always great. I've already had friends use them and they are just as satisfied!!!!!
I've sold to card conduit a few times and everytime my experience has been great. It's fast and easy to use and the amount you get back is always great. I've already had friends use them and they are just as satisfied!!!!!
Quinton
Review left Nov 12 2024
Review
They did a great job, already recommended to other people in my group. Was very quick and simple. When some of the card proces were a little lower than expected, they shot me an email explaining why certain card git rated as damaged. Over all, very happy with my experience
They did a great job, already recommended to other people in my group. Was very quick and simple. When some of the card proces were a little lower than expected, they shot me an email explaining why certain card git rated as damaged. Over all, very happy with my experience
Alex C
Review left Nov 11 2024
Shipment processed Oct 31 2024
Review
Throughout each step of the equation of selling, there was visibility; the stance of what my cards held as a value and where I was within the process
Throughout each step of the equation of selling, there was visibility; the stance of what my cards held as a value and where I was within the process
Carl
Review left Nov 11 2024
Shipment processed Nov 08 2024
Review
I really like the clarity of the selection, submission, and tracking process. The website handles everything far better than expected!
I really like the clarity of the selection, submission, and tracking process. The website handles everything far better than expected!
Joe
Review left Nov 11 2024
Review
I've used card conduit about 6 times now they always give more money than I would at an lgs. It's easier/cheaper than ebay because it's only 1 shipment instead of multiple. Overall once you ship it you will get your money within about a week and half using the direct to your bank method. Overall love the service theirs a reason I've used it more than once.
I've used card conduit about 6 times now they always give more money than I would at an lgs. It's easier/cheaper than ebay because it's only 1 shipment instead of multiple. Overall once you ship it you will get your money within about a week and half using the direct to your bank method. Overall love the service theirs a reason I've used it more than once.
Kori
Review left Nov 11 2024
Review
So much better than selling cards 1 by 1 and the fact that if you sort your cards properly they take less fee out was awesome, grateful something like this exists!
So much better than selling cards 1 by 1 and the fact that if you sort your cards properly they take less fee out was awesome, grateful something like this exists!
Dino Hall
Review left Nov 11 2024
Review
Have used Card Conduit a number of times and always find them to be transparent, easy to work with, fair, and efficient. Cannot recommend them enough.
Have used Card Conduit a number of times and always find them to be transparent, easy to work with, fair, and efficient. Cannot recommend them enough.
Eric Kozfkay
Review left Nov 11 2024
Review
process was easy and explained every step of the way. was able to get value from a lot of the bulk sent, and even though most of the commons and uncommons weren't worth anything the rares and Mythics did net quite a bit of value.
process was easy and explained every step of the way. was able to get value from a lot of the bulk sent, and even though most of the commons and uncommons weren't worth anything the rares and Mythics did net quite a bit of value.
Isaiah Luck
Review left Nov 11 2024
Review
Grateful for a service like this. Its tedious work on their end and gives the consumer great reward. This is a service that I would highly recommend to anyone in the MTG community.
Grateful for a service like this. Its tedious work on their end and gives the consumer great reward. This is a service that I would highly recommend to anyone in the MTG community.
Alex N
Review left Nov 11 2024
Review
I had an abundance of Rare/Mythic Magic cards collected over the years, and a lack of time to individually look up, itemize, and ship each card. Card Conduit made it incredibly easy to sell thousands of these cards. The entire process was transparent, and I was provided with a detailed report of eve
...
Read more
I had an abundance of Rare/Mythic Magic cards collected over the years, and a lack of time to individually look up, itemize, and ship each card. Card Conduit made it incredibly easy to sell thousands of these cards. The entire process was transparent, and I was provided with a detailed report of every card that was processed, alongside the price Card Conduit was buying these cards from me at. I think the fee's charged were well worth the convenience.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).