Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

About a year ago I was bored so I catalogued all my 6000 magic cards into a phone app called Mana Box. Using that app, I was able to generate card data for my collection and upload it into Card Conduit's system (they walk you through this) and this let me see what the most valuable cards were at the time. Card Conduit's system flags the cards that are worth at least 50 cents for you (because it's not worthwhile to sell them the others). If you've also got your cards physically sorted, this process becomes pretty easy to choose those cards you wish to sell and send them in. I sent in a test batch of 54 cards and got a little over $80 for them. I made the choice to mail this first batch in a small priority mail box because there was one pretty valuable card in there and I didn't want any chance of the cards being sent through an automated envelope sorter. Most cards were played, but some were straight out of the package and into storage, but I don't think any cards got graded as NM, I guess because the newest of them were opened five years ago and aged in the box and lose that new card smell? Overall, I found the process to be pretty painless for me (a tech savvy former game store owner who "gets" the collector mentality). Just make sure you follow all of the directions, including putting your cards in the correct order when you package them up. The easier you make it on their staff, the more you get for your cards. I'll be doing this again. It's way easier than taking cards in person to a shop or trying to sell them on Ebay.