Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

I just have to comment on how professional this outfit is. The description of the service was spot-on, the tools available before you even create the shipment to price out your cards and identify the ones that don't make the cut, the well-defined process, the expectations set around the process, the communication throughout the process, and the speed of payment was all top-notch. This was my first time using the company, and I had sent in a wide variety of cards, from a value and condition perspective, to see what happened, and I wasn't disappointed. As far as that goes, the only thing I'd change is that they had a plugin for their estimation tools to the magic scanning apps, so that was less guessing at how much of a difference the buy list price to TCGLow was, for instance, especially since their curated service had a minimum buy list value of .50.

I docked one star because the one unknown as part of shipping is how it is graded, and while I think it was consistent how they graded, in some cases, it was a little harsh. I have a lot of speculation on why that might have been and if there were some things I could have done differently to affect this. But the lower grades had less than a 10% affect on my expectations of the payment based on their estimates at different levels. And that was easily offset by the convenience and speed of the process, so I will definitely use the service again, just exclude really old cards.