Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
Aaron Friend
Review left Mar 31 2026
Professional / Easy / Thorough
Review
I have sold many Magic cards throughout my life. From different shops/LGS, online retailers (Star City Games, Channel Fireball, etc), and even individuals, Card Conduit is currently the best experience I have had selling cards. From the beginning they project a time window of when you will receive your payout, and it is very accurate. I have had nightmares with other companies where they sent payment to an incorrect PayPal account, or told me the condition of a card was way worse than it was when I mailed it.
Card Conduit was fair throughout the entire process. The online buy-list and shipping instructions were easy to navigate and tracking the process was easy. When they sent the final report and payment, I had a few questions to review on condition, and they kindly sent photos of some of the wear on corners of a card and surface scratches that kept the card from being NM. They were professional and the process is the most fair I have dealt with recently. Sure you can find individual buyers that may pay a little more but the security isn't there. You may be able to get more store credit from Star City Games, but they don't always have the card you need in stock. If you are looking to buy into another format, or are looking to pick up a few higher end cards, this has got to be the best way to go.
Card Conduit was fair throughout the entire process. The online buy-list and shipping instructions were easy to navigate and tracking the process was easy. When they sent the final report and payment, I had a few questions to review on condition, and they kindly sent photos of some of the wear on corners of a card and surface scratches that kept the card from being NM. They were professional and the process is the most fair I have dealt with recently. Sure you can find individual buyers that may pay a little more but the security isn't there. You may be able to get more store credit from Star City Games, but they don't always have the card you need in stock. If you are looking to buy into another format, or are looking to pick up a few higher end cards, this has got to be the best way to go.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).