Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

TLDR: Card Conduit's process was easy to follow, the price was reasonable, and payment was quick.

I had amassed a small hoard of MTG cards over the years, always justifying purchases by telling myself, “If I ever need to, I can sell these back.” When that day finally came, the process felt more daunting than I expected. I needed to sell around 250 cards, wanted a fair price, and—most importantly—wanted to offload everything at once instead of selling cards individually over months or years.

After some quick Googling, I came across Card Conduit. I was skeptical at first, so I did some research, read reviews, and checked the FAQ before deciding to give it a try. I’m glad I did.

I chose the sorted service, which required extra work on my end—sorting the cards, entering them into the tracker, organizing them in the provided order, and shipping them out (this service costs 2%). Because I had a lot going on personally, this took longer than expected, but I was surprised to receive a thoughtful email from Nick Anderson at Card Conduit. He reassured me about their process and offered additional resources, which really helped.

I also asked about limits on shipment value and insurance. Nick explained there’s no minimum or maximum they accept, and while insurance is optional, it’s recommended. I did insure my package ($1,500 for about $23 via USPS).

Ultimately my conversation with Nick is what solidified my decision to sell my cards.

After shipping and providing the tracking number, the website clearly showed each step of the process. Once sorting and grading were complete, I received a detailed report listing each card, condition, and value.

Overall, the process was simple, transparent, and fair. Customer service was excellent, and I was very satisfied with the grading and final value. I highly recommend Card Conduit if you’re looking for a fast, straightforward way to sell cards you no longer need.