Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
Jeremy
Review left Aug 23 2025
fast and easy, but conditions are inaccurate
Review
While the overall process of using the service was straightforward and fairly quick, the person/people reviewing card conditions is generally just assigning random conditions to the cards. Out of the over 400 cards sent in, the majority had been in sleeves from the time they were opened from a pack until the day before they were sent off, so 99% of them would have been NM with some maybe drawing LP status. The large amount of cards marked below LP is preposterous and shows a real lack of accuracy when evaluating card conditions. Overall, this service was useful for quick cash, but I probably wouldn't use it again as i dont feel cards are evaluated properly.
Card Conduit Team
Replied Aug 23 2025
The best approach to take if you are surprised by the grading provided is to reach out to ask for additional information. We are always happy to provide additional support for the grades. In this case, there was a hold on the order - which means the customer was able to review the results prior to finalization. Not only did the customer not express any concern or ask for additional information, this customer actively approved the shipment (an indicator that the results are satisfactory).
The biggest source of grading surprises is from assumptions. We always recommend carefully reviewing cards prior to them being sent in - specifically without sleeves, as sleeves can hide numerous kinds of wear. "Straight from pack to sleeve" is a common assumption that results in disappointment, as sleeves do not make cards impervious to wear, and some cards don't exit a pack in NM condition.
Regardless of assumptions, we always recommend you contact us if you are concerned or surprised by any pricing or grading. We are here to help and we want you to feel great about having chosen our service every single shipment you send.
The biggest source of grading surprises is from assumptions. We always recommend carefully reviewing cards prior to them being sent in - specifically without sleeves, as sleeves can hide numerous kinds of wear. "Straight from pack to sleeve" is a common assumption that results in disappointment, as sleeves do not make cards impervious to wear, and some cards don't exit a pack in NM condition.
Regardless of assumptions, we always recommend you contact us if you are concerned or surprised by any pricing or grading. We are here to help and we want you to feel great about having chosen our service every single shipment you send.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).