Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

This was my first time using the service, and I thought that I would be able to get more value out of my cards here than if I used a single store buy list like Card Kingdom. I was excited when I submitted the cards that I wanted to sell, and I thought that the process was clear and professional. I was mostly disappointed when it came to the condition grading of my cards.

I usually buy NM/LP when I do buy singles. I double sleeve all my decks and am careful when shuffling/ handling. I knew that some of my older cards were closer to MP but there was also a few cards that I opened from packs/ secret lair boxes and immediately sleeved and not played with that were marked at MP. It just seemed like any bit of wear would automatically drop a card down from NM to MP. Also if I knew that some of these higher priced cards would drop over half their value going from NM to LP I probably wouldn't have sent them.

I appreciate the service, but I don't think I will try again.