Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

I went with the pre sorted option so I can't speak for how the process is when sending in larger, more unorganized shipments. But the process was very straightforward. You look up a card you want to sell and if it's over the $1 buylist value you can add it to your list. Anything under $1 can't be added. But at the same time if the price of something drops under that between the time of selecting it and actually being able to ship it, they'll still accept it. You wouldn't get the price you initially added it for, but you aren't penalized for keeping it on the list and sending it. Once you add the cards you're looking to sell your provided a list/Excel sheet. It lists the card in order, top to bottom, of how they should be arranged in your shipment. Once you have your pile sorted only thing left to do is to get them set up in a box that you feel confident will keep them safe without moving around too much during transit.

Price wise it's not bad. It's not incredible, but not bad. Most cards are valued around the expected buylist price. There were the occasional cards I entered that had a much lower than expected value when searching. But that's not exactly on CC. At the same time there were cards I saw at above buylist value which was nice. You'd make double, possibly triple or even more if you sat down and tried to sell each individual card yourself. Only going for the best offers. But that's incredibly time consuming, slow, and just all around not ideal outside of big money cards. So this is a good option for people like me when it comes to that. Especially if you have a ton of single digit prices cards you wouldn't go through the effort of selling individually.

Overall wait time between shipping it and getting my report wasn't too long. And I enjoyed looking over it due to how the info was presented.