Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
Patrick
Review left Aug 02 2024
Fair grading, good prices
Review
I tried both the sorted and unsorted services and was happy with both.
I knew I had some less-than-perfect cards in this set, and I think their grading was very fair.
Of course, they are a bit harsher than I would be, but they have to be able to resell them at the graded qualities, so if it's on the edge, they have to go lower. Also, unlike some other vendors, I feel the grading was consistent from card to card. I've had experiences in the past with other vendors where basically all my cards under $2 were marked NM, but basically all my >$10 cards (including pack-fresh ones) got LP or worse. The grading here seems to be of equal scrutiny regardless of value. A 25 cent card I thought was on the edge of damaged/ HP they marked damaged, while many of my most valuable cards that I thought were NM but weren't quite 100% mint were evaluated as NM.
While a tiny bit more harsh than I might grade myself, the grading seems fairly applied regardless of card value, and it gives me confidence that when I send future orders, I can safely estimate the value I'll get and that the value will be fair.
I knew I had some less-than-perfect cards in this set, and I think their grading was very fair.
Of course, they are a bit harsher than I would be, but they have to be able to resell them at the graded qualities, so if it's on the edge, they have to go lower. Also, unlike some other vendors, I feel the grading was consistent from card to card. I've had experiences in the past with other vendors where basically all my cards under $2 were marked NM, but basically all my >$10 cards (including pack-fresh ones) got LP or worse. The grading here seems to be of equal scrutiny regardless of value. A 25 cent card I thought was on the edge of damaged/ HP they marked damaged, while many of my most valuable cards that I thought were NM but weren't quite 100% mint were evaluated as NM.
While a tiny bit more harsh than I might grade myself, the grading seems fairly applied regardless of card value, and it gives me confidence that when I send future orders, I can safely estimate the value I'll get and that the value will be fair.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).