Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

The process was easy but to be honest I was projected a payout of $4,100 roughlly and ended up getting a payout of $3,200 and some change and I understand that the projected payout is just that "projected" but when I went through my list I made sure to pay extra close attention to the condition when I made the list and marked them accordingly to try and get a close to an accurate payout as possible and it ended up being $900 less than projected I wasn't super happy, and it seemed that a lot of the high value cards (even ones that I pulled from a pack and went into a seal sleeve immediately was marked down to HP and even in one case a DMG condition I do find that a little misleading, now at the time of writing this I haven't even gotten my payment yet which Im sure wont have an issues with or anything but I wish they would take pictures of the cards that I mark as NM or LP when they says its HP or DMG so I could see where they got that grading result from. I have been in the MTG community now for over 15 YRS and have been buying and selling cards the whole time and I'm by no means an expert but I would like to say I have a decent understanding of how to grade cards. I would have been happier to have paid a processing fee for them going trough it and them just sent me back the cards vs selling them at the price they gave me, I understand the terms and conditions for when I sent my cards to them but I WONT be using the service in the Future not without taking pitchers of them before hand so I can have a leg to stand on when they grade a card completely different then what I have it as