Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

The process was the best part, it was quite smooth and easy, and the guys keep to the estimated time frame including issuing the payment. My main caution regarding future sales would be around the grading of the cards. Out of the cards I sold, I graded 31 NM and 25 came back as NM which is pretty close. I graded 1 as HP and 1 came back as HP which is very good. However, I graded 49 as LP and only 4 came back as LP. That meant that some of the NM as well as most of the LP came back as MP - I graded 18 MP and 69 came back as MP. This meant my grading was close for NM, precise for MP and HP, but way off for LP. Now there may be a number of reasons for that, and it may have been because I don't know how to grade, or cards just become MP quite easily. It also might not have affected the final pay out - apparently sometimes MP can pay more than LP as unintuitive as that feels. However this means that for me, I'll avoid sending in cards that I think are LP. For people like me, I'd recommend sending in cards that are clearly NM, MP, and HP, and perhaps sending LPs elsewhere unless you are resigned to have them graded as MP. Aside from grading, everything else was all that I could ask for - smooth process, clear communication, quick payout. In the end, the payout was about $90 less than what was estimated from my grading, but it was still more than what I think I could gotten elsewhere, and as cash instead of credit - that was key in my decision making. For now, I would use these guys again for NM, MP, and HP cards.