Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

The processing of this shipment (5 days) and issuing of payment (3 days after) was in line with the timeline we provide for shipments of this type. The customer was upset that this timeframe was not expedited since the shipment was only five cards, and they expected that we would change the timelime proscribed. Unfortunately, that expectation does not take into account all the other shipments we have to process each week – which is why those timeframes exist. Anyone working with us should expect us to adhere to the timing expectations we set forth absent discussing it specifically with us (we do try to accommodate urgent circumstances where we can).

As to the values, the payout here was 72.6% of TCGPlayer Low on cards with an average value below $5. Most would consider that an exceptional result when considering the cost to sell those via a marketplace like TCGPlayer. We do our best to set pricing expectations ahead of time, and to make it clear that obtaining retail prices via our service (or any buylist) is simply not possible. We always encourage anyone considering our service to use our price check tool and/or collection estimate tool to ensure the pricing meets expectations.