Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
Chelsea Burfeind
Review left May 03 2024
Smooth, transparent processes, friendly staff, and great prices!
Review
I've used three different buylist services at this point (CC, CardKingdom, and selling to my LGC), and they've all been great experiences.
What stood out about CC In particular:
- I spoke to several people over the course of the process (I used their curated service) and everyone was really friendly and helpful.
- You're provided with a detailed report at the end of the grading process, and their methods are very transparent and thorough
- Their buylist is extensive and larger than other similar places, especially when it comes to foils
- The amount they offer for cards is generally the highest I've found, even after fees
A few other notes that aren't really cons but I'm noting to be thorough:
- CC tends to be a bit more tough when it comes to grading. That said, they're the ones getting all of my foils, and I'm guessing those are easier for me to scratch up. That being said, I didn't have any issues or arguments with the grades in the report I got.
- Card values aren't locked in until time of processing, so you're at the mercy of the whims of the market until then.
The only time that I wouldn't recommend CC is if you have a highly volatile card whose price is jumping all over the place on a day by day basis. Otherwise, I think they're my new go-to! It's nice how easy it is to get into contact with a real person, and they've all been so great; I like knowing that I'm working with people who are enthusiastic and passionate about what they do.
Highly recommend :)
What stood out about CC In particular:
- I spoke to several people over the course of the process (I used their curated service) and everyone was really friendly and helpful.
- You're provided with a detailed report at the end of the grading process, and their methods are very transparent and thorough
- Their buylist is extensive and larger than other similar places, especially when it comes to foils
- The amount they offer for cards is generally the highest I've found, even after fees
A few other notes that aren't really cons but I'm noting to be thorough:
- CC tends to be a bit more tough when it comes to grading. That said, they're the ones getting all of my foils, and I'm guessing those are easier for me to scratch up. That being said, I didn't have any issues or arguments with the grades in the report I got.
- Card values aren't locked in until time of processing, so you're at the mercy of the whims of the market until then.
The only time that I wouldn't recommend CC is if you have a highly volatile card whose price is jumping all over the place on a day by day basis. Otherwise, I think they're my new go-to! It's nice how easy it is to get into contact with a real person, and they've all been so great; I like knowing that I'm working with people who are enthusiastic and passionate about what they do.
Highly recommend :)
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).