Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
Jordan
Review left May 29 2024
Shipment processed May 16 2024
Easy way to cash out of your collection
Review
I have used CardConduit several times over the last few years as I scaled down my activity in paper magic. MTGGoldfish recommended them and I have been happy with my experiences.
When I sent my first shipment I did some comparison with buylist prices from major vendors and everything checked out. I have used all of their service levels from "box it all up and let them sort it out" to the more traditional buylist experience where you do more of the work in picking and sorting. Their turnaround time on my initial mass collection dump was good given the large number of cards they had to go through.
The only negative if there is one is that they are strict on grading- the first shipment I sent was a bit of a shock in that many of the "Lightly Played" cards I had been buying from reputable sources and carefully sleeving and storing received a downgrade to "Moderately Played" or worse. I talked to Nick about it and after reviewing a few of the high-dollar cards I was convinced that their grading was strict, but fair if you go by the book. I think there is a broader issue of grade inflation on the sales side of the industry, and I am probably guilty of ignoring minor flaws in the excitement of opening and inspecting my shiny new cards. Anyway, after I got a sense of their grading I was sufficiently satisfied to send several more shipments, and their grading has consistently matched my recalibrated expectations.
In conclusion, if you want to cash out of your Magic collection and you place any value on your time and effort, CardConduit is the "easy button" solution to get a fair price with minimal hassle.
When I sent my first shipment I did some comparison with buylist prices from major vendors and everything checked out. I have used all of their service levels from "box it all up and let them sort it out" to the more traditional buylist experience where you do more of the work in picking and sorting. Their turnaround time on my initial mass collection dump was good given the large number of cards they had to go through.
The only negative if there is one is that they are strict on grading- the first shipment I sent was a bit of a shock in that many of the "Lightly Played" cards I had been buying from reputable sources and carefully sleeving and storing received a downgrade to "Moderately Played" or worse. I talked to Nick about it and after reviewing a few of the high-dollar cards I was convinced that their grading was strict, but fair if you go by the book. I think there is a broader issue of grade inflation on the sales side of the industry, and I am probably guilty of ignoring minor flaws in the excitement of opening and inspecting my shiny new cards. Anyway, after I got a sense of their grading I was sufficiently satisfied to send several more shipments, and their grading has consistently matched my recalibrated expectations.
In conclusion, if you want to cash out of your Magic collection and you place any value on your time and effort, CardConduit is the "easy button" solution to get a fair price with minimal hassle.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).