Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
L
Review left Feb 25 2026
Autosift for the win!
Review
I sent in about 15,000 cards through the new AutoSift order. Honestly, the hardest part was finding a box and enough tape that I felt comfortable shipping that many cards in.
This new service definitely looks promising. However, I’m taking off two stars due to some unexpected requests and a slower process than advertised.
After submitting my order (which was within the stated price and quantity limits), support asked me to create a second AutoSift order due to an internal administrative process on their end to handle large submissions. I complied, but I’m still unclear why this was necessary if my original order met the published guidelines. All I know is that this helps them out.
But because of this request, the payout timeline was impacted. Based on the original estimates, I should have already been paid for the full submission. Instead, splitting the order pushed the processing time for the remaining half back by an additional two weeks (showing March 5th). I was assured by support this wouldn't be the case, but it appears they were wrong (or the website doesn't have the exact date due to the nature of the unusual order?).
Also worth noting: the information currently reflected for this shipment only covers half of the original AutoSift order.
Overall, promising concept, but the backend process and communication around large orders could use improvement.
I will update the final score with the final review of this service and will post a more detailed review on Reddit. Stay tuned.
This new service definitely looks promising. However, I’m taking off two stars due to some unexpected requests and a slower process than advertised.
After submitting my order (which was within the stated price and quantity limits), support asked me to create a second AutoSift order due to an internal administrative process on their end to handle large submissions. I complied, but I’m still unclear why this was necessary if my original order met the published guidelines. All I know is that this helps them out.
But because of this request, the payout timeline was impacted. Based on the original estimates, I should have already been paid for the full submission. Instead, splitting the order pushed the processing time for the remaining half back by an additional two weeks (showing March 5th). I was assured by support this wouldn't be the case, but it appears they were wrong (or the website doesn't have the exact date due to the nature of the unusual order?).
Also worth noting: the information currently reflected for this shipment only covers half of the original AutoSift order.
Overall, promising concept, but the backend process and communication around large orders could use improvement.
I will update the final score with the final review of this service and will post a more detailed review on Reddit. Stay tuned.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).