Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
James Baird
Review left Oct 16 2026
Fine for Fast Money but Grading Suffers
Review
I was weary of sending a bunch of my collection in the mail, they originally quoted around $6k which was better than my local game store probably would have given me so I pulled the trigger on it and tried because I did need money.
The good - they walk you through the process well and every step of the way feels easy.
The bad - sending this amount of cards obviously comes with some trepidation and therefore I'd recommend insuring your shipment - this comes at a cost that eats into whatever they finally decide your cards are worth.
The Even worse - the grading is the worst part. I've seen many reviews say this and it is true, they don't grade your cards accordingly. I am pretty sure every single foil card was graded LP, I probably wouldn't even send them foil cards if I were you. 90% of my cards were taken directly from packs and placed into sleeves/Binders and were sitting on a shelf untouched.
By the end I got a semi-decent chunk of change but was considerably less than originally quoted, I understand they need to make money but they are already giving you well below Market anyway, granted, I know maybe in the 90% of untouched cards there could have been some minor misalignments or something but kind of disappointing when you know your cards have hardly ever been touched and still get a LP grade.
Overall:
I would recommend this service if you really need money and don't mind losing value on your collection but I probably won't do it again. I would also add a caveat: Keep your foils/sell them on your own or to a local game shop - they mark all of them LP. ( maybe easier to find faults in foils? not sure, but probably get more elsewhere).
The good - they walk you through the process well and every step of the way feels easy.
The bad - sending this amount of cards obviously comes with some trepidation and therefore I'd recommend insuring your shipment - this comes at a cost that eats into whatever they finally decide your cards are worth.
The Even worse - the grading is the worst part. I've seen many reviews say this and it is true, they don't grade your cards accordingly. I am pretty sure every single foil card was graded LP, I probably wouldn't even send them foil cards if I were you. 90% of my cards were taken directly from packs and placed into sleeves/Binders and were sitting on a shelf untouched.
By the end I got a semi-decent chunk of change but was considerably less than originally quoted, I understand they need to make money but they are already giving you well below Market anyway, granted, I know maybe in the 90% of untouched cards there could have been some minor misalignments or something but kind of disappointing when you know your cards have hardly ever been touched and still get a LP grade.
Overall:
I would recommend this service if you really need money and don't mind losing value on your collection but I probably won't do it again. I would also add a caveat: Keep your foils/sell them on your own or to a local game shop - they mark all of them LP. ( maybe easier to find faults in foils? not sure, but probably get more elsewhere).
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).