Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service

See all reviews
Andrew Fletchall
Review left Aug 08 2026
Shipment processed Jul 30 2026
$2,531.24 payout, $130.61 fees

Not worth it

Review

Process was easy. That is probably the only part of this that is redeemable. They don't take a massive cut, and they don't buy them for too much under tcg low. BUT, they grade like asshats. Calling a week old fresh pack rip moderately played so they don't have to give you $60 for it, they have to give you 40. Just to relist it as near-mint on their TCG marketplace. Or take any $1-2 card and grade it low enough so it dips under 50ยข and they won't have to pay you for it. These guys are professional scammers trying to give you as little as possible. Everything looks good on the front end, business side of things. But as soon as they have your cards they turn into thieves. Never using again, I'd rather sell on TCG myself after this experience. Turning a $4000 collection + 5 boxes of bulk into ~2500 because "cards can be moderately played out of the pack" is some serious scam shit
Card Conduit Team

Replied Aug 08 2026

The best you can do if you are surprised by any grades is to reach out to us. We are always happy to provide context, pictures, and support for the grades we have assigned the cards. This is the reason every shipment sent in has the opportunity to review before we finalize it - we want you to be happy with your shipment, and if you are unhappy, we are more than willing to return your cards to you at our expense. We must grade cards in the condition they are received, though, and that cannot and does not factor in how recently it was opened from a booster pack.

Most importantly in response to this review, the grade we assign every card in every shipment is the grade it is listed for sale. The allegation that we do otherwise is false.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every previous customer to leave a review. Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page. We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).