Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
Joshua
Review left Feb 24 2024
Terrible grading scale/ buy list expensive lands
Review
Well unfortunately I wouldn't recommend them to anybody they have a grading scale that is everything you think is mint is lp and they buy list expensive lands they literally buylist 15$ urza's powerplants and tower as buylist I sent over 1500 cards 76 if which I had almost sent to another buylist company for 150$ which was huge mistake I didn't because these people literally didn't even give me 100$ for over 1600 cards I highly recommend going anywhere else what's worse is once they process your order they own it you have no chance to back out you just have to accept it one of the worst experiences ive ever had I recommend sending your cards anywhere but here
Card Conduit Team
Replied Feb 24 2024
We understand it can be frustrating when your expectations are not met using our service. In this case, the customer mistakenly identified their Foreign Chronicles cards for Antiquities cards – which is certainly easy to do since Foreign Chronicles cards have a black border and look much closer to the Antiquities versions than English Chronicles (which have a white border) – but this misidentification has resulted in the customer having incorrect value expectations coming into the process. Furthermore, the vast majority of the cards sent in this shipment were bulk; we waived half of our fees since it was clear there was misunderstanding of how bulk affects payouts, but even with half the fees waived, the fees to process the shipment were nearly $25.
We understand that grading cards may not be everyone's forte. We are always happy to provide additional information regarding grading to help get on the same page for that shipment and any future shipments. You do agree that the cards will not be returned, but ultimately our goal is to find an agreeable solution – but, that cannot happen if you do not reach out to us to discuss the situation. For anyone considering the service that is concerned with the grading and/or their ability to assess the grades of their own cards, we always recommend you request a hold for review, which gives you the opportunity to review and discuss the report with us prior to it being finalized.
We understand that grading cards may not be everyone's forte. We are always happy to provide additional information regarding grading to help get on the same page for that shipment and any future shipments. You do agree that the cards will not be returned, but ultimately our goal is to find an agreeable solution – but, that cannot happen if you do not reach out to us to discuss the situation. For anyone considering the service that is concerned with the grading and/or their ability to assess the grades of their own cards, we always recommend you request a hold for review, which gives you the opportunity to review and discuss the report with us prior to it being finalized.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).