Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service

Jeffrey Ovadya
Review left Jan 06 2025
Shipment processed Dec 28 2024
$763.27 payout, $101.12 fees

Review

I cannot properly express the amazingness of Card Conduit's service. It's like a magic button that converts your hard-to-sell, low-end singles into near market value money. They save you countless dollars worth of time and do it all for you. I have used them multiple times and will continue to do so indefinitely. Thanks for everything!
I cannot properly express the amazingness of Card Conduit's service. It's like a magic button that converts your hard-to-sell, low-end singles into near market value money. They save you countless dollars worth of time and do it all for you. I have used them multiple times and will continue to do so indefinitely. Thanks for everything!
CJ
Review left Jan 06 2025
Shipment processed Jan 04 2025
$1,059.04 payout, $49.90 fees

Review

The process of selling through Card Conduit always made me hesitant. I feel like any collector or long-time player is rightfully nervous about offloading the things they're done with, as the market for selling can be very time-consuming, labor-intensive, and down-right draining in many ways. When it ... Read more
The process of selling through Card Conduit always made me hesitant. I feel like any collector or long-time player is rightfully nervous about offloading the things they're done with, as the market for selling can be very time-consuming, labor-intensive, and down-right draining in many ways. When it comes to getting rid of large amounts of cards for reasonable value, it can become an even more daunting task. Card Conduit genuinely makes the process as simple as it's ever been. With built-in collection pricing tools and partnerships with tracking tools such as Moxfield, it really has become as simple as:
1) Scan
2) Appraise
3) Ship

With their standard shipment the process is even more simple & their fees are incredibly reasonable accross the board. I've never felt better about putting the sale of my cards in someone else's hands, and will definitely be doing further work with Card Conduit in the future.
Matthew Wright
Review left Jan 05 2025
Shipment processed Dec 27 2024
$878.73 payout, $17.93 fees

Review

This is my second time selling with Card Conduit, but first time using the more curated features. It was a breeze to sell and sort these cards, and I couldn't be happier.
This is my second time selling with Card Conduit, but first time using the more curated features. It was a breeze to sell and sort these cards, and I couldn't be happier.
Will S.
Review left Jan 04 2025
Shipment processed Jan 03 2025

Review

Second round and just as good as the first! Keep up the fabulous work!
Second round and just as good as the first! Keep up the fabulous work!
Mike Caputo
Review left Jan 04 2025
Shipment processed Dec 20 2024

Review

This is the second time I've used Card Conduit. I had a predictable experience which is exactly what I wanted. If I need to sell cards again I'll continue to use Card Conduit.
This is the second time I've used Card Conduit. I had a predictable experience which is exactly what I wanted. If I need to sell cards again I'll continue to use Card Conduit.
Dillon Morrow
Review left Jan 04 2025
Shipment processed Dec 20 2024
$600.10 payout, $11.00 fees

Review

Did 2 shipments together, one bulk rares and mythics and the other sorted cards over $1. Got back around what I thought I could get after seeing their initial pricing. Going to keep using them.
Did 2 shipments together, one bulk rares and mythics and the other sorted cards over $1. Got back around what I thought I could get after seeing their initial pricing. Going to keep using them.
Stafford Lumsden
Review left Jan 03 2025
Shipment processed Dec 29 2024
$536.62 payout, $9.84 fees

Review

After a stellar first experience with Card Conduit, I entrusted them with a second shipment of approximately 400 Magic cards. Once again, the process was smooth and hassle-free. The team's professionalism and efficiency in handling my collection were impressive. Opting for the PayPal payout option a ... Read more
After a stellar first experience with Card Conduit, I entrusted them with a second shipment of approximately 400 Magic cards. Once again, the process was smooth and hassle-free. The team's professionalism and efficiency in handling my collection were impressive. Opting for the PayPal payout option added to the convenience, with funds promptly appearing in my account. For anyone looking to sell their Magic cards without the usual headaches, Card Conduit remains my top recommendation.
Stafford Lumsden
Review left Jan 03 2025
Shipment processed Dec 24 2024
$975.00 payout, $19.90 fees

Review

I recently used Card Conduit to offload a couple of hundred Magic: The Gathering cards that were surplus to requirements. I couldn't be more satisfied with the service. Despite my shipment originating in Australia, the process was seamless and efficient. Card Conduit handled my really random shipmen ... Read more
I recently used Card Conduit to offload a couple of hundred Magic: The Gathering cards that were surplus to requirements. I couldn't be more satisfied with the service. Despite my shipment originating in Australia, the process was seamless and efficient. Card Conduit handled my really random shipment of cards, ranging from near mint to heavily played, with professionalism and care. I received a detailed report on each card's condition and a (more than) fair return. Their excellent communication and prompt responses made the experience stress-free, even when shipping valuable items internationally. I've already sent a second batch and highly recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell their Magic cards.
Walt
Review left Jan 03 2025
Shipment processed Dec 25 2024
$1,518.69 payout, $71.56 fees

Review

Super awesome service and fast turn around time. Can’t wait to use again! All I need now is some more bulk!
Super awesome service and fast turn around time. Can’t wait to use again! All I need now is some more bulk!
Justin T.
Review left Jan 03 2025
Shipment processed Dec 24 2024
$2,281.51 payout, $46.56 fees

Review

This was my first time selling a large amount of cards at once, and the process was so smooth and had great step by step instructions. The fact that they have a breakdown of how many cards were in what condition was expected; but they also give you graphs about the most cards you sold from what sets ... Read more
This was my first time selling a large amount of cards at once, and the process was so smooth and had great step by step instructions. The fact that they have a breakdown of how many cards were in what condition was expected; but they also give you graphs about the most cards you sold from what sets, your top creatures by price, etc., and that was just a fun addition to me. Big recommend, especially if you are nervous or anxious about selling a chunk of cards for the first time.
Justin
Review left Jan 03 2025
Shipment processed Dec 25 2024

Review

The entire process was so easy throughout that I can’t imagine going anywhere else to sell cards. The UI that tracks order status is great, the payout was excellent, and the communication was awesome.
The entire process was so easy throughout that I can’t imagine going anywhere else to sell cards. The UI that tracks order status is great, the payout was excellent, and the communication was awesome.
Kristen
Review left Jan 03 2025
Shipment processed Dec 21 2024
$469.91 payout, $9.59 fees

Review

I researched all of the places I could sell my MTG cards and this was the best price and process. Very happy with their services!
I researched all of the places I could sell my MTG cards and this was the best price and process. Very happy with their services!
Nolan Brown
Review left Jan 03 2025
Shipment processed Dec 19 2024
$2,769.16 payout, $130.48 fees

Review

Process was super easy. Packed up my cards and shipped them out and they did the rest. They kept me updated the entire time through the process and was transparent about everything. Gave me a detailed review of what they found with grading the cards and explained how they come to their value. Best customer service, best overall service.
Process was super easy. Packed up my cards and shipped them out and they did the rest. They kept me updated the entire time through the process and was transparent about everything. Gave me a detailed review of what they found with grading the cards and explained how they come to their value. Best customer service, best overall service.
Kyle Savage
Review left Jan 03 2025
Shipment processed Dec 21 2024
$443.70 payout, $9.05 fees

Review

This was a seamless process. Really liked the transparency and ease of sale.
This was a seamless process. Really liked the transparency and ease of sale.
Travis LeClair
Review left Jan 03 2025
Shipment processed Dec 23 2024
$1,356.03 payout, $27.67 fees

Review

I’ve used Card Conduit dozens of times. It’s my favorite buylisting option. The cash offer is the best I’ve seen from buylisting and the staff is professional and reliable.
I’ve used Card Conduit dozens of times. It’s my favorite buylisting option. The cash offer is the best I’ve seen from buylisting and the staff is professional and reliable.
Zach
Review left Jan 03 2025
Shipment processed Dec 23 2024
$760.28 payout, $15.52 fees

Review

The Card Conduit platform is extremely easy to navigate. I love being able to import a list and the transparency of viewing values on the fly. My shipment values were not locked in until grading started and I was able to easily keep tabs on things until then. My overall value went up between shippin ... Read more
The Card Conduit platform is extremely easy to navigate. I love being able to import a list and the transparency of viewing values on the fly. My shipment values were not locked in until grading started and I was able to easily keep tabs on things until then. My overall value went up between shipping and grading which was nice. Grading seems consistent and in line with my expectations.

I recommend Card Conduit to my playgroup.
Ian
Review left Jan 02 2025
Shipment processed Dec 19 2024
$3,063.01 payout, $161.21 fees

Review

Leaving the country for a while and decided to liquidate collections and decks that would otherwise keep sitting. Sent in 2 medium USPS boxes as quick as I could catalog them. Sleeved and all. The guy Nick who processed my order was so kind in updating me all the way and even combined my orders and ... Read more
Leaving the country for a while and decided to liquidate collections and decks that would otherwise keep sitting. Sent in 2 medium USPS boxes as quick as I could catalog them. Sleeved and all. The guy Nick who processed my order was so kind in updating me all the way and even combined my orders and edited costs because he was so impressed with the state of the collection when I was scared whoever opened it would be mad at 1000+ sleeved cards. Overall I got about 5500 dollars direct deposited when the expected price was about 6500. So they’re right on with the mint cards. I honestly expected less.
The ease of uploading a list and sending it in is what really made this whole process worth it. I barely had time to make those lists let alone sort them, so I probably could have made more, but I’m way happier using my time trying to do everything else.

Overall a wonderful experience thst even brought s tear to my eye when I read how happy he was going through the collection. Will continue to use card conduit in the future. Have a list to send in tomorrow already!
Kevin Chou
Review left Jan 02 2025
Shipment processed Dec 22 2024
$1,654.44 payout, $33.76 fees

Review

Sold my entire collection to card conduit using the sorted service. Super easy to use, good communication with updates along the way, and fast payment. As other reviews have mentioned, grading is not the most generous, though I do not consider them harsh by any means, so just keep that in mind. Overall I would still recommend their service.
Sold my entire collection to card conduit using the sorted service. Super easy to use, good communication with updates along the way, and fast payment. As other reviews have mentioned, grading is not the most generous, though I do not consider them harsh by any means, so just keep that in mind. Overall I would still recommend their service.
J
Review left Jan 02 2025
Shipment processed Dec 31 2024
$818.45 payout, $38.56 fees

Review

The price estimate + importing tools made sorting the cards very simple. The FAQ covers everything you need to ship the cards safely and the team provided updates on every step of the process. Will definitely use this service again to sell the rest of my collection.
The price estimate + importing tools made sorting the cards very simple. The FAQ covers everything you need to ship the cards safely and the team provided updates on every step of the process. Will definitely use this service again to sell the rest of my collection.
Cass Dobbins
Review left Jan 02 2025
Shipment processed Nov 29 2024
$476.34 payout, $9.72 fees

Review

Couldn't ask for better. Payouts were fair and the process is simple and, most importantly, transparent.
Couldn't ask for better. Payouts were fair and the process is simple and, most importantly, transparent.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... 189 190
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every previous customer to leave a review. Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page. We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).