Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(4357)
Scott H.
Review left Aug 10 2024
Review
The process of selling my cards was very easy. The conversations with Nick were informative and transparent. Value for the cards I sold was right on par with what was suggested beforehand and honest. Would highly recommend their service to everyone. I understand that everyone's experience will vary but I am happy with how the sale went for me. Thanks guys!
The process of selling my cards was very easy. The conversations with Nick were informative and transparent. Value for the cards I sold was right on par with what was suggested beforehand and honest. Would highly recommend their service to everyone. I understand that everyone's experience will vary but I am happy with how the sale went for me. Thanks guys!
Jonathan McNatt
Review left Aug 10 2024
Review
It's so easy to make a list and ship it to them and the value I get is way better than any of my local shops. This is absolutely my preferred method to sell cards. A+
It's so easy to make a list and ship it to them and the value I get is way better than any of my local shops. This is absolutely my preferred method to sell cards. A+
LooksLikeAJobFor
Review left Aug 10 2024
Review
I'm glad this service exist. I'm a little OCD about holding on cards I don't use. With the state of magic I'm constantly updating my current decks for more optimal cards. I use to exchange unused cards at my LGS for store credit but would be lucky to get 20% value from the cards I turned in. First t
...
Read more
I'm glad this service exist. I'm a little OCD about holding on cards I don't use. With the state of magic I'm constantly updating my current decks for more optimal cards. I use to exchange unused cards at my LGS for store credit but would be lucky to get 20% value from the cards I turned in. First time, using card conduit I received way more than I was I expecting. Combine that on top of the excellent customer service. You can email the people directly in charge of operations and they even recommended packages to ensure I get more money. Magic isn't a cheap hobby so make sure you get your money's worth using card conduit!
AC
Review left Aug 09 2024
Review
The website / process was pretty simple and easy to figure out. Getting paid was a breeze.
The website / process was pretty simple and easy to figure out. Getting paid was a breeze.
Amitayus
Review left Aug 09 2024
Review
I've had two experiences with Card Conduit so far, and they have both been fantastic. This service has saved me SO MUCH time in selling those cards that are worth something, but not really worth enough to put them into individual packages. Their communication has always been prompt and courteous. Can't recommend enough!
I've had two experiences with Card Conduit so far, and they have both been fantastic. This service has saved me SO MUCH time in selling those cards that are worth something, but not really worth enough to put them into individual packages. Their communication has always been prompt and courteous. Can't recommend enough!
Anthony
Review left Aug 09 2024
Review
I have loved using this website to sell my cards; the process is easy and transparent. However, the one risk I will state is the subjective nature of the card review process; when cards sent in are NM or LP, in my perspective, they are dinged and reviewed as MP. My review process is not perfect, but
...
Read more
I have loved using this website to sell my cards; the process is easy and transparent. However, the one risk I will state is the subjective nature of the card review process; when cards sent in are NM or LP, in my perspective, they are dinged and reviewed as MP. My review process is not perfect, but the issue is that certain high-priced cards were selected to be as such and sold at what I would say is still lower than the average price. Overall, understand this site is once again a third-party and you run risks of not selling your cards yourself.
Dillon Tiller
Review left Aug 09 2024
Review
I’ve put in 2 shipments so far (1 complete, 1 in progress) and the process has been very simple and convenient! The original estimate was only slightly off of what the final payout was and I will definitely be using this service again!
I’ve put in 2 shipments so far (1 complete, 1 in progress) and the process has been very simple and convenient! The original estimate was only slightly off of what the final payout was and I will definitely be using this service again!
Nicholas Bills
Review left Aug 09 2024
Review
I had a few cards I wanted to sell because I didn't really need them for any of my decks anymore, but I don't have an LGS to sell to, so after some research, I settled on Card Conduit as my best option. When I received my initial report, I was a bit confused by two cards that were reported as "damag
...
Read more
I had a few cards I wanted to sell because I didn't really need them for any of my decks anymore, but I don't have an LGS to sell to, so after some research, I settled on Card Conduit as my best option. When I received my initial report, I was a bit confused by two cards that were reported as "damaged," so I asked in the email I received with the report if they could elaborate. Sure enough, within 2 hours of my response, they sent me an explanation with photos to explain their grading. One of the cards had a slight tear that I hadn't noticed before I sent it in, but I am certain was there because that card has seen a lot of play from me, and there were plenty of other imperfections on the card that I was aware of. The other card was unfortunately damaged during shipping, which was unfortunate, but it was my fault for not packing the cards better before I sent them in. My cards were all very "well loved" as one might put it, yet I feel I still got my money's worth, and I agree with the grades they gave my cards 100%. I would absolutely recommend this service to a friend and I will be using Card Conduit again in the future if I ever have more cards I want to get rid of.
SuperSaiyaJon
Review left Aug 08 2024
Review
I cannot express enough how amazing it is - take my cards- mail them in - and get paid out to buy more cards <3
Its a no brainer - ill be a customer for life :)
Its a no brainer - ill be a customer for life :)
I cannot express enough how amazing it is - take my cards- mail them in - and get paid out to buy more cards <3
Its a no brainer - ill be a customer for life :)
Its a no brainer - ill be a customer for life :)
Kristian Woodmansee
Review left Aug 08 2024
Shipment processed Aug 06 2024
Review
I was a little hesitant being a first time customer to the process, given the context also that I had some higher end cards I was looking to off load. The communication the entire way as well as the expectations with the process really made me feel comfortable. I obviously would always appreciate
...
Read more
I was a little hesitant being a first time customer to the process, given the context also that I had some higher end cards I was looking to off load. The communication the entire way as well as the expectations with the process really made me feel comfortable. I obviously would always appreciate top dollar for my cards and given how effortless CardConduit made this, I am truly pleased with the price points established. Will be a continuous customer and referring to my MTG friends. 10/10
Rick B
Review left Aug 08 2024
Review
The sorting process was a lot easier than I thought it would be. I spent hours curating my shipments in the past. Using this tool was a breeze.
The sorting process was a lot easier than I thought it would be. I spent hours curating my shipments in the past. Using this tool was a breeze.
Josh King
Review left Aug 08 2024
Review
Simple process, reasonable timeline, and a quick turnaround for payment! I was quite pleased.
Simple process, reasonable timeline, and a quick turnaround for payment! I was quite pleased.
Rory
Review left Aug 08 2024
Review
Great service! Saves you heaps of time and time is $$$
Cheers
Cheers
Great service! Saves you heaps of time and time is $$$
Cheers
Cheers
Thomas Borgerding
Review left Aug 08 2024
Review
Simple to add cards into a list and organize. Been selling for the past 2 years now and still can't match the value Card Conduit provides!
Simple to add cards into a list and organize. Been selling for the past 2 years now and still can't match the value Card Conduit provides!
Steven Tutein
Review left Aug 08 2024
Review
Very easy to navigate the website to register your shipment. Smooth and fast process!
Very easy to navigate the website to register your shipment. Smooth and fast process!
Steven Tutein
Review left Aug 08 2024
Review
Very easy to navigate the website to register your shipment. Smooth and fast process!
Very easy to navigate the website to register your shipment. Smooth and fast process!
Sam Gardner
Review left Aug 08 2024
Review
I was moving out of my parents' house and had to get rid of my old Magic cards, and wanted to make sure I got a good price from a buyer without a ton of effort, and Card Conduit was exactly the sort of service that I needed. The process was very intuitive, the customer support was prompt and polite,
...
Read more
I was moving out of my parents' house and had to get rid of my old Magic cards, and wanted to make sure I got a good price from a buyer without a ton of effort, and Card Conduit was exactly the sort of service that I needed. The process was very intuitive, the customer support was prompt and polite, and the payout was quite good compared to what was offered to me at a local game store. I would recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell their higher-value magic cards!
Ryan
Review left Aug 07 2024
Review
The process was easy and straight forward. I was a little concerned about it but all my cards were listed and priced well, better than if id taken it in to a local shop. Just have to make sure to account for shipping cost of sending the cards, I pre curated many if the cards by feeling if they had a
...
Read more
The process was easy and straight forward. I was a little concerned about it but all my cards were listed and priced well, better than if id taken it in to a local shop. Just have to make sure to account for shipping cost of sending the cards, I pre curated many if the cards by feeling if they had any value and avoided sending more than 3/4 if my collection. Donate the bulk to a local charity, but for your value cards this is the way for the casual seller.
Great Service
Review left Aug 07 2024
Shipment processed Jul 18 2024
Review
amazing service - detailed report, couldn't be happier
amazing service - detailed report, couldn't be happier
Jason B
Review left Aug 07 2024
Review
I had a ton of boxes, with thousands of cards, that I was sick of moving from home to home. Trying to decide what to do with my cards was really stressful and then I found Card Conduit. This service is amazing and very professional. The care they take with the cards, the detailed analysis they share
...
Read more
I had a ton of boxes, with thousands of cards, that I was sick of moving from home to home. Trying to decide what to do with my cards was really stressful and then I found Card Conduit. This service is amazing and very professional. The care they take with the cards, the detailed analysis they share with you and their great online tools made it a service I'd be more than happy to recommend to any of you with a lot of cards you want to get fair market value for. You will save time by using this service, just do it
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).