Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service

Seabrook Dougherty
Review left Jan 28 2025
Shipment processed Jan 20 2025
$137.10 payout, $2.80 fees

Review

What an amazing experience. They were quick and very professional. Highly rec.
What an amazing experience. They were quick and very professional. Highly rec.
William Shelton
Review left Jan 27 2025
Shipment processed Jan 24 2025

Review

Always feel taken care of throughout the entire process! Loving the slight tracking upgrades they've recently implemented. Keep it up!
Always feel taken care of throughout the entire process! Loving the slight tracking upgrades they've recently implemented. Keep it up!
Jim Dean
Review left Jan 27 2025
Shipment processed Jan 17 2025
$318.66 payout, $6.50 fees

Review

I've used a few different services for stopping my MTG cards over the years, and Card Conduit by far accepted more cards than others I've used and offered fair pricing. It's also nice that they offer you the choice to accept the graded payout before they finalize the transaction. Other services don' ... Read more
I've used a few different services for stopping my MTG cards over the years, and Card Conduit by far accepted more cards than others I've used and offered fair pricing. It's also nice that they offer you the choice to accept the graded payout before they finalize the transaction. Other services don't give you the ability to easily accept/decline the grading and once you send in your cards they're gone. I'd definitely sell to Card Conduit again in the future!
david ding
Review left Jan 26 2025
Shipment processed Dec 28 2024
$82.32 payout, $1.68 fees

Review

The processing with timely and I felt that I received good value.
The processing with timely and I felt that I received good value.
Chris Scott
Review left Jan 26 2025
Shipment processed Jan 03 2025
$171.57 payout, $23.71 fees

Review

Great transaction, they make it very easy for me, I shipped the cards and had my payment shortly after!
Great transaction, they make it very easy for me, I shipped the cards and had my payment shortly after!
Erik R
Review left Jan 26 2025
Shipment processed Jan 11 2025
$1,775.65 payout, $32.54 fees

Review

Easy process and great card value. Would recommend for anyone looking to sell their collection and is willing to do a bit of work to avoid being lowballed.
Easy process and great card value. Would recommend for anyone looking to sell their collection and is willing to do a bit of work to avoid being lowballed.
Tony
Review left Jan 25 2025
Shipment processed Jan 10 2025

Review

Very easy process and they always keep you updated. Payment was processed fast with no hiccups.
Very easy process and they always keep you updated. Payment was processed fast with no hiccups.
savion
Review left Jan 25 2025
Shipment processed Jan 17 2025
$1,445.36 payout, $68.10 fees

Review

Due to the price and overall condition of my cards they. Upgraded the service from what I originally went for. Easily the nicest support folks I've spoken in a long time as well. I will 100% be using this site again.
Due to the price and overall condition of my cards they. Upgraded the service from what I originally went for. Easily the nicest support folks I've spoken in a long time as well. I will 100% be using this site again.
Daniel
Review left Jan 25 2025
Shipment processed Jan 17 2025
$743.32 payout, $39.12 fees

Review

Can't recommend this service enough. It probably helps a lot to send in mostly stuff worth more than .50 based on their BL prices and desleeving but from ship to payment was between 2-3 weeks and it was minimal effort on my part. Felt really good to move everything I had been sitting on in one fell swoop.
Can't recommend this service enough. It probably helps a lot to send in mostly stuff worth more than .50 based on their BL prices and desleeving but from ship to payment was between 2-3 weeks and it was minimal effort on my part. Felt really good to move everything I had been sitting on in one fell swoop.
Michael Evans
Review left Jan 25 2025
Shipment processed Jan 17 2025
$1,355.02 payout, $71.32 fees

Review

I had so much on my hands that organizing, listing, and shipping my collection was completely unfeasible. Card Conduit takes all the hard work out of the process and leaves you to do whatever it is you may need to do, be it go back to watching netflix, practicing for a tournament, or whatever else you may need. 10/10 recommendation.
I had so much on my hands that organizing, listing, and shipping my collection was completely unfeasible. Card Conduit takes all the hard work out of the process and leaves you to do whatever it is you may need to do, be it go back to watching netflix, practicing for a tournament, or whatever else you may need. 10/10 recommendation.
Jake
Review left Jan 25 2025
Shipment processed Jan 17 2025

Review

The process was simple, with detailed steps throughout. Everything was very clear and fair, all I had to do was put cards in a specific order, pack them safely, and ship them. Wait a bit, then I got money. Easy peasy. 10/10 for 10 would recommend.
The process was simple, with detailed steps throughout. Everything was very clear and fair, all I had to do was put cards in a specific order, pack them safely, and ship them. Wait a bit, then I got money. Easy peasy. 10/10 for 10 would recommend.
Geoff
Review left Jan 25 2025
Shipment processed Jan 18 2025
$1,021.69 payout, $53.77 fees

Review

The quick processing and great breakdowns of your cards make this site by far the best place to sell online.
The quick processing and great breakdowns of your cards make this site by far the best place to sell online.
Michael McClaran
Review left Jan 25 2025
Shipment processed Jan 07 2025
$450.71 payout, $54.01 fees

Review

The process was easy! Great communication & and reporting. And after using them several time I think they are very fair.
My only gripe is that sometimes they downgrade cards to another condition and from someone who opens their cards and puts them directly into sleeves it doesn’t make sense.
Otherwise a great service with great customer service!
The process was easy! Great communication & and reporting. And after using them several time I think they are very fair.
My only gripe is that sometimes they downgrade cards to another condition and from someone who opens their cards and puts them directly into sleeves it doesn’t make sense.
Otherwise a great service with great customer service!
Nathan Bundy
Review left Jan 24 2025
Shipment processed Jan 10 2025
$106.21 payout, $2.17 fees

Review

I decided to recoup the cost of a few events by selling out of more expensive singles, but was looking at other expenses that store credit doesn't cover. Card conduit made it simple, outlining the whole process, and walking things through each step of the way, while remaining transparent about expec ... Read more
I decided to recoup the cost of a few events by selling out of more expensive singles, but was looking at other expenses that store credit doesn't cover. Card conduit made it simple, outlining the whole process, and walking things through each step of the way, while remaining transparent about expectations and final results.

Very satisfied, and highly likely to use them in the future.
Nick
Review left Jan 24 2025
Shipment processed Jan 09 2025

Review

Card Conduit was recommended to me from a few other collectors. The process was simple to get things wrapped up and sent out. The offer was fair and their grading system was much more accurate than my best guess.
Card Conduit was recommended to me from a few other collectors. The process was simple to get things wrapped up and sent out. The offer was fair and their grading system was much more accurate than my best guess.
Jaya Prime
Review left Jan 24 2025
Shipment processed Jan 11 2025

Review

Very clean process, from price-checking to the list provided with the final value. Also, a huge thanks to Card Conduit for supporting some of my favorite creators, such as Jack & Joel Are Magic as well as MtG Goldfish. You rock!
Very clean process, from price-checking to the list provided with the final value. Also, a huge thanks to Card Conduit for supporting some of my favorite creators, such as Jack & Joel Are Magic as well as MtG Goldfish. You rock!
Matt
Review left Jan 23 2025
Shipment processed Jan 12 2025
$155.63 payout, $49.72 fees

Review

CardConduit provides an incredibly smooth and user-friendly experience for submitting card shipments through their web application. I appreciated being able to track the status of my shipment and review the detailed grading and valuation of each card—this level of transparency was a standout featu ... Read more
CardConduit provides an incredibly smooth and user-friendly experience for submitting card shipments through their web application. I appreciated being able to track the status of my shipment and review the detailed grading and valuation of each card—this level of transparency was a standout feature. The money I received felt fair, especially considering that I avoided the hassle of selling individual cards. However, I’d only recommend this service for rarer or higher-value cards, as common bulk doesn’t bring much return. Overall, it’s a great option for offloading valuable cards with minimal effort.
Richard
Review left Jan 23 2025
Shipment processed Jan 10 2025
$1,995.12 payout, $105.01 fees

Review

This is my second time using Card Conduit, and the experience is just as flawless and streamlined as the first time. Fair pricing, transparency every step of the way, and fast processing overall. Huge fan!
This is my second time using Card Conduit, and the experience is just as flawless and streamlined as the first time. Fair pricing, transparency every step of the way, and fast processing overall. Huge fan!
William Shelton
Review left Jan 23 2025
Shipment processed Jan 15 2025

Review

They really know what they're doing and I feel always taken care of by Card Conduit and I will continue to use their services as my relationship with the magic continues to ebb and flow. They make it super easy.
They really know what they're doing and I feel always taken care of by Card Conduit and I will continue to use their services as my relationship with the magic continues to ebb and flow. They make it super easy.
Luis
Review left Jan 23 2025
Shipment processed Jan 11 2025
$354.15 payout, $7.23 fees

Review

The process was super easy and they were transparent about any changes. It was easy to follow and I feel I got a good deal for the cards I sent
The process was super easy and they were transparent about any changes. It was easy to follow and I feel I got a good deal for the cards I sent
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... 189 190
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every previous customer to leave a review. Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page. We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).