Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(4057)
Tyler
Review left Jun 20 2021
Review
2nd time using them for selling my cards. They’re always responsive to my emails and this time I sent in some more valued cards, easily had some 10-20$ cards in this order, any worry of them scamming you or not paying out for the value of your cards should be forefit. For what they do, sort thru y
...
Read more
2nd time using them for selling my cards. They’re always responsive to my emails and this time I sent in some more valued cards, easily had some 10-20$ cards in this order, any worry of them scamming you or not paying out for the value of your cards should be forefit. For what they do, sort thru your collection of cards big or small, they are definitely worth it if you don’t want to deal with it yourself. Yes you pay a fee but for both my shipments now, it’s been more then worth. I will without a doubt recommend and support using this guys for anyone who wishes to sell off magic cards without putting any work in of sorting thru. Thanks again card conduit!
Rick B
Review left Jun 20 2021
Shipment processed Jun 12 2021
Review
Put a bunch of cards in a box and send them, or curate the cards using their price check, either way you can sell a lot of cards easily. I researched other companies and found the Card Conduit’s buy prices to be very competitive. Nick has provided excellent communication especially when USPS lost
...
Read more
Put a bunch of cards in a box and send them, or curate the cards using their price check, either way you can sell a lot of cards easily. I researched other companies and found the Card Conduit’s buy prices to be very competitive. Nick has provided excellent communication especially when USPS lost one on my shipments. It had been miss delivered next door. Now I use UPS and have not had another problem.
Katherine S.
Review left Jun 17 2021
Review
I have experimented with selling but disliked looking across multiple sites for the best available price AND disliked the grading process. Why bother to grade if the buyer is going to dispute or overrule anyway? I prefer selling to individuals but find postage to be cost prohibitive and keeping inv
...
Read more
I have experimented with selling but disliked looking across multiple sites for the best available price AND disliked the grading process. Why bother to grade if the buyer is going to dispute or overrule anyway? I prefer selling to individuals but find postage to be cost prohibitive and keeping inventory maddening. Card Conduit solves these problems for me.
For this first shipment, I just put a bunch of extra cards in the box while working my collection and shipped it off. I used it as a learning opportunity. My next shipment will be just bulk, also a learning opportunity. Based on these tests, I believe the best options for me will be to split my shipments into Curated and Standard with Exclusions. The Price Check and Collection Estimate tools work well for deciding which box a card belongs.
Card Conduit is probably NOT the best option for anyone who likes and/or feels comfortable with grading and shopping around for the best place to sell a card. It works well for the rest of us. They do what they say they are going to do and they are upfront about everything if you bother to read through everything including the Terms.
For this first shipment, I just put a bunch of extra cards in the box while working my collection and shipped it off. I used it as a learning opportunity. My next shipment will be just bulk, also a learning opportunity. Based on these tests, I believe the best options for me will be to split my shipments into Curated and Standard with Exclusions. The Price Check and Collection Estimate tools work well for deciding which box a card belongs.
Card Conduit is probably NOT the best option for anyone who likes and/or feels comfortable with grading and shopping around for the best place to sell a card. It works well for the rest of us. They do what they say they are going to do and they are upfront about everything if you bother to read through everything including the Terms.
warcode
Review left Jun 16 2021
Shipment processed Jun 13 2021
Review
Selling my cards to buy lists individually would have been a hassle and cost of tracking down good prices and shipping multiple packages.
Here I packed up the cards I had with any value, shipped them to card conduit, had them evaluated and paid out within 2 weeks. Highly recommended!
Here I packed up the cards I had with any value, shipped them to card conduit, had them evaluated and paid out within 2 weeks. Highly recommended!
Selling my cards to buy lists individually would have been a hassle and cost of tracking down good prices and shipping multiple packages.
Here I packed up the cards I had with any value, shipped them to card conduit, had them evaluated and paid out within 2 weeks. Highly recommended!
Here I packed up the cards I had with any value, shipped them to card conduit, had them evaluated and paid out within 2 weeks. Highly recommended!
Samuel B.
Review left Jun 15 2021
Review
Prompt service, prompt payment, overall very satisfied
Prompt service, prompt payment, overall very satisfied
DeHaven F.
Review left Jun 13 2021
Review
This is my second experience with Card Conduit. I appreciate the prompt manner in which receipt of my shipments have been acknowledged. As well, it has not been long thereafter that I am notified of the valuation of my cards.
Card Conduit is a very trustworthy and reliable resale entity which I recommend highly.
Card Conduit is a very trustworthy and reliable resale entity which I recommend highly.
This is my second experience with Card Conduit. I appreciate the prompt manner in which receipt of my shipments have been acknowledged. As well, it has not been long thereafter that I am notified of the valuation of my cards.
Card Conduit is a very trustworthy and reliable resale entity which I recommend highly.
Card Conduit is a very trustworthy and reliable resale entity which I recommend highly.
Nick
Review left Jun 13 2021
Review
Very happy with my second shipment. Fast and easy. Will continue to use this service!
Very happy with my second shipment. Fast and easy. Will continue to use this service!
Rodger Moore
Review left Jun 12 2021
Review
Easy and painless way to sell my excess magic cards.
Easy and painless way to sell my excess magic cards.
Matt
Review left Jun 10 2021
Review
The process was simple. The best part is they take any and all cards, and I didn’t have to spend hours sorting and checking the price of every card.
The process was simple. The best part is they take any and all cards, and I didn’t have to spend hours sorting and checking the price of every card.
Wesley G.
Review left Jun 10 2021
Review
It was easy to use this service. Definitely better than going to a local shop who would short you on value. Nothing wrong with your local shop doing that, they are just trying to run a business, but with Card Conduit you will definitely come out ahead. This method will take a little longer, but p
...
Read more
It was easy to use this service. Definitely better than going to a local shop who would short you on value. Nothing wrong with your local shop doing that, they are just trying to run a business, but with Card Conduit you will definitely come out ahead. This method will take a little longer, but patience will always pay you more in the end. So just ask yourself, do you want $30 now or $100 in a couple of weeks?
Summer Westlake
Review left Jun 07 2021
Shipment processed May 02 2021
Review
I believe it was a good assessment. Of course anyone would like to get more money for their cards but this is a good option to move your cards fast instead of letting it go for pennies. They do a good job.
I believe it was a good assessment. Of course anyone would like to get more money for their cards but this is a good option to move your cards fast instead of letting it go for pennies. They do a good job.
James A
Review left Jun 06 2021
Review
Process was easy... the difficult part was shipping 70 lbs of cards (about 12k cards in total)... I’ve been out of the MtG game since 1997 so I forgot the value of most cards and for me to catalog 12k cards to see for a potentially higher profit was unrealistic to me. So I’m glad I found card co
...
Read more
Process was easy... the difficult part was shipping 70 lbs of cards (about 12k cards in total)... I’ve been out of the MtG game since 1997 so I forgot the value of most cards and for me to catalog 12k cards to see for a potentially higher profit was unrealistic to me. So I’m glad I found card conduit. Made about $6.5 in total for those cards. Very pleased,
Lily
Review left Jun 04 2021
Review
Thrilled with my experience and would definitely use again if I needed to. Thank you so much!
Thrilled with my experience and would definitely use again if I needed to. Thank you so much!
Matt G
Review left Jun 04 2021
Review
A fair and speedy process that makes me feel like I’m trading in at the card store without leaving my apartment. I’m a big fan of this service.
A fair and speedy process that makes me feel like I’m trading in at the card store without leaving my apartment. I’m a big fan of this service.
Ahmad R
Review left Jun 03 2021
Review
Quick and easy service. I will most definitely use this service again.
Quick and easy service. I will most definitely use this service again.
Krysta S.
Review left Jun 03 2021
Review
It was a breeze to send in the cards we are not using any more! Payment was prompt and easy.
It was a breeze to send in the cards we are not using any more! Payment was prompt and easy.
Justin T
Review left Jun 03 2021
Review
First time user. The process was quick and easy. Their communication was excellent, and the payment even got to me a little ahead of the stated schedule. I would definitely use them again.
First time user. The process was quick and easy. Their communication was excellent, and the payment even got to me a little ahead of the stated schedule. I would definitely use them again.
Eric
Review left Jun 02 2021
Review
The only reservation I had about using this more was the fact that they treated bulk box of 3000 the same as a well manicured grip of 100 or so cards. Now that the curated option is here I can confidently say I will be using this much more often. Well done card conduit can’t wait to send you more!
The only reservation I had about using this more was the fact that they treated bulk box of 3000 the same as a well manicured grip of 100 or so cards. Now that the curated option is here I can confidently say I will be using this much more often. Well done card conduit can’t wait to send you more!
Daniel M.
Review left May 29 2021
Shipment processed May 16 2021
Review
It was easy to navigate the site and get a shipment started. The que and appraisal process was a bit nerve wracking but that more about me then the service.
It was easy to navigate the site and get a shipment started. The que and appraisal process was a bit nerve wracking but that more about me then the service.
Alan S.
Review left May 28 2021
Review
I have played Magic off and on since the first sets and accumulated many cards that were not in decks. I sent in about 8000 cards (the usual mix of commons, uncommons, and rares) in 4 separate shipments. These cards returned about $1000 in total. It was nice to know that the cards were going back
...
Read more
I have played Magic off and on since the first sets and accumulated many cards that were not in decks. I sent in about 8000 cards (the usual mix of commons, uncommons, and rares) in 4 separate shipments. These cards returned about $1000 in total. It was nice to know that the cards were going back into use and circulation. The reports and statistics provided were interesting and fun to read. It would have taken many months of my time to provide what Card Conduit did in under 2 weeks per shipment.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).