Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
Christopher Stevens
Review left Feb 12 2024
Review
The process was simple, fast, and easy. The grading was fair and payment was fast.
The process was simple, fast, and easy. The grading was fair and payment was fast.
Andy Rogener
Review left Feb 11 2024
Review
Really great people to do business with. Great communication throughout the process, would certainly use again
Really great people to do business with. Great communication throughout the process, would certainly use again
Kenneth Merrill
Review left Feb 11 2024
Shipment processed Feb 01 2024
Review
The process was easy. Communication was prompt and professional. Whole service was a joy to work with. 10/10 would work with them again.
The process was easy. Communication was prompt and professional. Whole service was a joy to work with. 10/10 would work with them again.
Jon
Review left Feb 11 2024
Review
Great service for us oldheads that don’t play magic anymore outside of arena. They even upgraded my shipment to curated and saved me some money on fees.
Great service for us oldheads that don’t play magic anymore outside of arena. They even upgraded my shipment to curated and saved me some money on fees.
Chris Corrente
Review left Feb 11 2024
Review
Communicated throughout process, fair buy list based pricing, would use again
Communicated throughout process, fair buy list based pricing, would use again
Chris Pebler
Review left Feb 11 2024
Shipment processed Feb 01 2024
Review
Service is fine, does what it says on the tin. I'd enjoy seeing more clarity towards foreign cards though. Things like worldly tutor, grave pact, sylvan library shouldn't just be classed as "bulk" because they're not English. That's disingenuous at best. As someone that owns a Zodiac Dragon in simpl
...
Read more
Service is fine, does what it says on the tin. I'd enjoy seeing more clarity towards foreign cards though. Things like worldly tutor, grave pact, sylvan library shouldn't just be classed as "bulk" because they're not English. That's disingenuous at best. As someone that owns a Zodiac Dragon in simplified Chinese, I would now look elsewhere if I were interested in selling it.
Even if the policy doesn't change, there should be a clear statement towards how foreign cards are handled, and it should take into account certain known high profile cards.
Even if the policy doesn't change, there should be a clear statement towards how foreign cards are handled, and it should take into account certain known high profile cards.
Card Conduit Team
Replied Feb 11 2024
Non-English cards are addressed in our FAQ, in which we explain they typically have little to no value via our service, and we suggest not shipping them in. The guidance we give when customers ask us about it is that we do our best to find a price, but that most US vendors will not buy non-English cards, and so expectations should be very tempered; typically speaking we can find a price for cards that buylist for more than $10, and the price expected is usually 40-60% of the English equivalent – but there are no guarantees. We do not recommend sending in foil non-English cards.
In the case of the items mentioned, the Sylvan Library was not bulk, and had a price – though it was only 21% of the English equivalent. The Worldly Tutor falls below the threshold we can typically find any price for, and Grave Pact was not included within this shipment. A card like Zodiac Dragon in simplified Chinese would not be a good card to send via our service, as the sales rate is extremely slow – and so vendors prices for it will reflect the very low liquidity of the card.
In the case of the items mentioned, the Sylvan Library was not bulk, and had a price – though it was only 21% of the English equivalent. The Worldly Tutor falls below the threshold we can typically find any price for, and Grave Pact was not included within this shipment. A card like Zodiac Dragon in simplified Chinese would not be a good card to send via our service, as the sales rate is extremely slow – and so vendors prices for it will reflect the very low liquidity of the card.
Non-English cards are addressed in our FAQ, in which we explain they typically have little to no value via our service, and we suggest not shipping them in. The guidance we give when customers ask us about it is that we do our best to find a price, but that most US vendors will not buy non-English cards, and so expectations should be very tempered; typically speaking we can find a price for cards that buylist for more than $10, and the price expected is usually 40-60% of the English equivalent – but there are no guarantees. We do not recommend sending in foil non-English cards.
In the case of the items mentioned, the Sylvan Library was not bulk, and had a price – though it was only 21% of the English equivalent. The Worldly Tutor falls below the threshold we can typically find any price for, and Grave Pact was not included within this shipment. A card like Zodiac Dragon in simplified Chinese would not be a good card to send via our service, as the sales rate is extremely slow – and so vendors prices for it will reflect the very low liquidity of the card.
In the case of the items mentioned, the Sylvan Library was not bulk, and had a price – though it was only 21% of the English equivalent. The Worldly Tutor falls below the threshold we can typically find any price for, and Grave Pact was not included within this shipment. A card like Zodiac Dragon in simplified Chinese would not be a good card to send via our service, as the sales rate is extremely slow – and so vendors prices for it will reflect the very low liquidity of the card.
Carter
Review left Feb 11 2024
Review
Sending the cards was extremely simple and the payout was far more than I was expecting given how convenient the whole process was for me. Extremely fair evaluation and a detailed inventory with pricing really put in perspective how much for goes into dealing with large amounts of bulk. Highly recommended and appreciated!
Sending the cards was extremely simple and the payout was far more than I was expecting given how convenient the whole process was for me. Extremely fair evaluation and a detailed inventory with pricing really put in perspective how much for goes into dealing with large amounts of bulk. Highly recommended and appreciated!
Michael Mazzola
Review left Feb 11 2024
Review
Great experience if you just want to unload your collection of rares/mythics without the hassle of buy listing
Great experience if you just want to unload your collection of rares/mythics without the hassle of buy listing
Jordan Swanson
Review left Feb 11 2024
Review
Process we easy to understand, and pretty quick considering how many cards they processed.
Process we easy to understand, and pretty quick considering how many cards they processed.
Aaron Sienkiewich
Review left Feb 11 2024
Review
Put your cards in a box, take it to UPS, let them pack it and ship it for you. Get your money in a couple weeks. Fair money for my cards and no stress for me! Great customer service!
Put your cards in a box, take it to UPS, let them pack it and ship it for you. Get your money in a couple weeks. Fair money for my cards and no stress for me! Great customer service!
Travis Rosario
Review left Feb 10 2024
Review
After extensively researching services that buy your Magic: The Gathering cards, I decided to use Card Conduit. The process was very quick and easy. I did a combination of a sorted shipment and a bulk shipment, as I already had my $1+ cards sorted out of my bulk cards. Most of my cards surprisingly
...
Read more
After extensively researching services that buy your Magic: The Gathering cards, I decided to use Card Conduit. The process was very quick and easy. I did a combination of a sorted shipment and a bulk shipment, as I already had my $1+ cards sorted out of my bulk cards. Most of my cards surprisingly were graded for what I thought they'd be, despite a lot of claims online that the Card Conduit team grades the cards at a lower grade. I also received an email at every step of the process; the process starting, the cards arriving to their location, the start of the processing, and finally, the completion and payment being sent via Zelle. I highly recommend this service for those who need to sell their cards and don't want to deal with the hassle of selling them themselves.
Daniel Santos
Review left Feb 09 2024
Review
I thought the grading process was fair, I liked that someone reached out to me and told me all about my shipment, and I thought that that certain shipment method was the best value.
I thought the grading process was fair, I liked that someone reached out to me and told me all about my shipment, and I thought that that certain shipment method was the best value.
LN
Review left Feb 09 2024
Review
Extremely happy with the whole selling process. Organizing my cards was easy thanks to their online system and once they got my shipment the process was quick and painless. Loved seeing the detailed report of the value of my cards, along with statistics of my collection. Payment was processed quickly and without problems.
Extremely happy with the whole selling process. Organizing my cards was easy thanks to their online system and once they got my shipment the process was quick and painless. Loved seeing the detailed report of the value of my cards, along with statistics of my collection. Payment was processed quickly and without problems.
Reb
Review left Feb 09 2024
Review
This process was super easy. I had several boxes of rares that I kept meaning to buy list, but I'm so busy with other things that I never get around to sorting them or grading them. Sending them in made the process super smooth for me, and I've already recommended card conduit to multiple other people!
This process was super easy. I had several boxes of rares that I kept meaning to buy list, but I'm so busy with other things that I never get around to sorting them or grading them. Sending them in made the process super smooth for me, and I've already recommended card conduit to multiple other people!
Kent Stevens
Review left Feb 07 2024
Review
Very satisfied with the service and honestly, I got a better deal than going to my LGS which offers less. Overall, if I know of anyone that wants the most for their cards and/or are planning to quit (like I have, fortunately), I will heavily recommend you guys.
Very satisfied with the service and honestly, I got a better deal than going to my LGS which offers less. Overall, if I know of anyone that wants the most for their cards and/or are planning to quit (like I have, fortunately), I will heavily recommend you guys.
Curtis Heil
Review left Feb 07 2024
Review
I've been accumulating my collection for nearly 20 years, and ive submitted cards to a few places before trying to offload my bulk. Every company out there would make me sort these. This is the first company that did this for me, and it made sending in my collection a breeze. So happy with this serv
...
Read more
I've been accumulating my collection for nearly 20 years, and ive submitted cards to a few places before trying to offload my bulk. Every company out there would make me sort these. This is the first company that did this for me, and it made sending in my collection a breeze. So happy with this service. I'm sending in the rest of my collection in several new shipments as we speak.
Daniel Zeffert
Review left Feb 07 2024
Review
I get extremely good rates on my cards without any additional effort. Getting 75ish % of tcg low for a large collection of cards is insane, given how little work this is compared to actually listing individual cards on tcgplayer, where you have to pay a sellers fee, ship cards individually, and deal with each individual buyer.
I get extremely good rates on my cards without any additional effort. Getting 75ish % of tcg low for a large collection of cards is insane, given how little work this is compared to actually listing individual cards on tcgplayer, where you have to pay a sellers fee, ship cards individually, and deal with each individual buyer.
Dan Gabriele
Review left Feb 07 2024
Review
Sent a bunch of cards in of moderate value. Analysis was prompt and speedy, and they even gave me a break on the per-card fee because of the overall quality of my shipment. Would definitely use again.
Sent a bunch of cards in of moderate value. Analysis was prompt and speedy, and they even gave me a break on the per-card fee because of the overall quality of my shipment. Would definitely use again.
James
Review left Feb 07 2024
Shipment processed Jan 27 2024
Review
Was very easy to send in my cards I no longer needed and then received a great payout that saved me the time of manually listing every card and shipping things out slowly over time. Will be returning in the future for sure!
Was very easy to send in my cards I no longer needed and then received a great payout that saved me the time of manually listing every card and shipping things out slowly over time. Will be returning in the future for sure!
Troy Hale
Review left Feb 07 2024
Review
This was amazing! Nick was great and very communicative along the way!
This was amazing! Nick was great and very communicative along the way!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).