Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(4587)
I Rivera
Review left May 02 2025
Shipment processed Apr 22 2025
Review
3rd processing submittal with company. Very easy and fair exchange. Money was direct deposited into my account with no issues. Will do business again.
3rd processing submittal with company. Very easy and fair exchange. Money was direct deposited into my account with no issues. Will do business again.
Chezarae Ramone Gholson
Review left May 02 2025
Review
Best place to ever sell my magic the Gathering cards took less than a week. These are cards I got for free do its all profit!
Best place to ever sell my magic the Gathering cards took less than a week. These are cards I got for free do its all profit!
Georgie The Magic Man
Review left May 01 2025
Review
Thank you, yet again! You all keep going the extra mile and I really appreciate all of the work that goes into this process. Strongly recommend using this service.
Thank you, yet again! You all keep going the extra mile and I really appreciate all of the work that goes into this process. Strongly recommend using this service.
Heather B
Review left May 01 2025
Review
What an awesome service - all I had to do was sort the cards in order, pack, and ship. A little bit of extra work but I didn’t mind at all. The only thing that took the longest was ensuring that all cards being sent were from the correct release set (which is something Manabox can have a hard time with). Overall would highly recommend CardConduit!!
What an awesome service - all I had to do was sort the cards in order, pack, and ship. A little bit of extra work but I didn’t mind at all. The only thing that took the longest was ensuring that all cards being sent were from the correct release set (which is something Manabox can have a hard time with). Overall would highly recommend CardConduit!!
Gabriel Ferbeyre
Review left May 01 2025
Shipment processed Apr 23 2025
Review
Excellent service. The hardest part was separating the cards on my own but you guys provide a service to avoid that. Fast and easy shipping, turn around time was amazing and the value was spot on.
Excellent service. The hardest part was separating the cards on my own but you guys provide a service to avoid that. Fast and easy shipping, turn around time was amazing and the value was spot on.
Joe Raimondi
Review left May 01 2025
Review
The process was easy, effective, and communicative. I will ALWAYS recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to offload some of their surplus collection.
The process was easy, effective, and communicative. I will ALWAYS recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to offload some of their surplus collection.
Evan
Review left May 01 2025
Review
The process was extremely simple -- I sent my cards (nearly the maximum allowed), and within a couple of weeks I had the payment along with a detailed inventory of what I had sent. The CK grading was fair. There was a small issue with the report (but not the total paid out), and they resolved the re
...
Read more
The process was extremely simple -- I sent my cards (nearly the maximum allowed), and within a couple of weeks I had the payment along with a detailed inventory of what I had sent. The CK grading was fair. There was a small issue with the report (but not the total paid out), and they resolved the reporting issue within a couple of hours of contact. Will be working with them again.
Zoron Hensley
Review left Apr 30 2025
Review
easy process, everything was great this time, I feel like the grading process went in my favor more this time. I sell a lot to you guys and sometimes I feel like it's not the best, but this order was perfect thank you.
easy process, everything was great this time, I feel like the grading process went in my favor more this time. I sell a lot to you guys and sometimes I feel like it's not the best, but this order was perfect thank you.
David A
Review left Apr 30 2025
Review
Another easy sale through CC. Will be back in near future
Another easy sale through CC. Will be back in near future
Tim H.
Review left Apr 30 2025
Review
The process was easy and rewarded me the more work I put into it and the less work I created on the sorting end. With reasonable fees, good buy prices, and a streamlined and transparent process, I would recommend this service to anyone looking to offload your magic cards. I was given a personal emai
...
Read more
The process was easy and rewarded me the more work I put into it and the less work I created on the sorting end. With reasonable fees, good buy prices, and a streamlined and transparent process, I would recommend this service to anyone looking to offload your magic cards. I was given a personal email from an actual representative giving their rationale for the grading of my cards and was paid a fair price for the value of said cards. Highly recommend. The shipping process is not super quick but it is very reasonable and stuck to the outlined timeline I was given when I shipped the cards. Cannot complain. Highly recommend again!
Christian Reinagel
Review left Apr 29 2025
Shipment processed Apr 19 2025
Review
I'd recommend using Card Conduit to sell your bulk cards. The whole process was very smooth and streamlined, I never had any issues throughout it and was able to get paid within about a week of me shipping my cards out. All in all a pleasant experience.
I'd recommend using Card Conduit to sell your bulk cards. The whole process was very smooth and streamlined, I never had any issues throughout it and was able to get paid within about a week of me shipping my cards out. All in all a pleasant experience.
Matt
Review left Apr 29 2025
Shipment processed Apr 19 2025
Review
Card Conduit is one of the best ways to sell cards especially if you sort the cards yourself. I sent them a box of about 350 cards and everything went smoothly. Their grading is as strict as TCG player though so be aware that you'll get dinged pretty hard for your old beat up cards. A huge upside of
...
Read more
Card Conduit is one of the best ways to sell cards especially if you sort the cards yourself. I sent them a box of about 350 cards and everything went smoothly. Their grading is as strict as TCG player though so be aware that you'll get dinged pretty hard for your old beat up cards. A huge upside of card conduit vs card kingdom is they pay via ACH transfer so you don't have to declare hobby income. Also their store on TCG player (Spellfinder) consistently has competitive prices for all the older cards and I've always been pleasantly surprised at how clean their MP and HP cards are.
Matthew Graham
Review left Apr 29 2025
Review
The process is straightforward, the payout is great, and the detailed breakdown in the end was my favorite part. I've got another shipment inbound lol.
The process is straightforward, the payout is great, and the detailed breakdown in the end was my favorite part. I've got another shipment inbound lol.
Adam C
Review left Apr 29 2025
Shipment processed Apr 19 2025
$3,117.32
payout, $164.07
fees
Review
I did the Curated option for my shipment and it was well worth it. Card Conduit worked quickly, had great communication, and gave me much better value than I expected to receive. Would heartily recommend to anyone looking to move their collection.
I did the Curated option for my shipment and it was well worth it. Card Conduit worked quickly, had great communication, and gave me much better value than I expected to receive. Would heartily recommend to anyone looking to move their collection.
Joseph
Review left Apr 29 2025
Review
Easy process in general. Good instructions. Would recommend
Easy process in general. Good instructions. Would recommend
Nick P
Review left Apr 29 2025
Review
I needed to cash out some of my collection - I was impressed with the process. One of the cards I intended to sell was speculated to be unbanned in EDH, and I went to sell it 3 weeks before the announcement.
The processing time stretched out, and I watched as the estimated value of my order went ... Read more
The processing time stretched out, and I watched as the estimated value of my order went ... Read more
I needed to cash out some of my collection - I was impressed with the process. One of the cards I intended to sell was speculated to be unbanned in EDH, and I went to sell it 3 weeks before the announcement.
The processing time stretched out, and I watched as the estimated value of my order went from $550 to $450 right after the anounvement that my card was NOT unbanned.
They gave me the price of my list, and the price they offered for that card in particular was ridiculous: 20% of its original estimated value.
I felt pretty betrayed, so I reached out, and not only did customer service inform me of why the price change occured (their prices are based directly on market value), they offered a better deal (70%) and offered to send it back no questions asked.
I loved the transparency, the experience went well - if a bit more lengthy than I'd like.
The processing time stretched out, and I watched as the estimated value of my order went from $550 to $450 right after the anounvement that my card was NOT unbanned.
They gave me the price of my list, and the price they offered for that card in particular was ridiculous: 20% of its original estimated value.
I felt pretty betrayed, so I reached out, and not only did customer service inform me of why the price change occured (their prices are based directly on market value), they offered a better deal (70%) and offered to send it back no questions asked.
I loved the transparency, the experience went well - if a bit more lengthy than I'd like.
Prajit Deb
Review left Apr 29 2025
Shipment processed Apr 25 2025
Review
I am a returning customer and have always received fantastic communication, support, and service from the Card Conduit Team, particularly from Nathaniel and Nick. Highly recommend.
I am a returning customer and have always received fantastic communication, support, and service from the Card Conduit Team, particularly from Nathaniel and Nick. Highly recommend.
Daniel
Review left Apr 27 2025
Review
The process was easy, automated, timely, and as advertised.
The process was easy, automated, timely, and as advertised.
Tyler B
Review left Apr 26 2025
Review
Very easy process, great customer service, and still competitive rates on top of all that. If your looking to offload some or all of your collection, you can't go wrong with Card Conduit.
Very easy process, great customer service, and still competitive rates on top of all that. If your looking to offload some or all of your collection, you can't go wrong with Card Conduit.
Anthony McClellan
Review left Apr 25 2025
Review
Love the business model. They are incentivised to get top dollar for your cards since their payout is a percentage of the total. The itemized report shows which cards were poor condition and how much they pay for each specific card. Very easy and fair way to sell your MTG cards.
Love the business model. They are incentivised to get top dollar for your cards since their payout is a percentage of the total. The itemized report shows which cards were poor condition and how much they pay for each specific card. Very easy and fair way to sell your MTG cards.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).