Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service

Good Stuff
Review left Aug 16 2023
Shipment processed Aug 05 2023

Review

Easy process for you to offload your cards. If you’re short on time or energy they will help you
Easy process for you to offload your cards. If you’re short on time or energy they will help you
Jordan Fairburn
Review left Aug 14 2023
Shipment processed Aug 04 2023
$1,018.28 payout, $18.67 fees

Review

Process was easy, shipped everything already sorted, thought that the value was a bit low but I am happy nonetheless.
Process was easy, shipped everything already sorted, thought that the value was a bit low but I am happy nonetheless.
Jeremy J. Jensen
Review left Aug 01 2023
Shipment processed Jul 28 2023
$268.42 payout, $14.13 fees

Review

much better pricing than my LGS which is why i continue to come back.
much better pricing than my LGS which is why i continue to come back.
Brad
Review left Jul 31 2023
Shipment processed Jul 20 2023
$470.08 payout, $9.59 fees

Review

I appriciate the pay out is very competitive for doing whole selling. The statistics I thought was a nice touch but may not be necessary. I would for sure reccomend yhe service for people wanting the most money for their cards. I might add a sorted <$1 option too. People like me would like probab ... Read more
I appriciate the pay out is very competitive for doing whole selling. The statistics I thought was a nice touch but may not be necessary. I would for sure reccomend yhe service for people wanting the most money for their cards. I might add a sorted <$1 option too. People like me would like probably like to sell them in with >$1 cards just to have them out of their collection. We are doing most of the works sorting, but I suppose the set up in your system might me more of a hassle.
Dan
Review left Jul 28 2023
Shipment processed Jul 17 2023
$945.89 payout, $17.33 fees

Review

The different tiers and methods of uploading card lists is a little complicated, but the service and payment were fast and easy. Card Conduit has great customer service and realistic pricing. I would definitely recommend them above any other single buylist site.
The different tiers and methods of uploading card lists is a little complicated, but the service and payment were fast and easy. Card Conduit has great customer service and realistic pricing. I would definitely recommend them above any other single buylist site.
Morgan
Review left Jul 26 2023
Shipment processed Jul 15 2023
$42.14 payout, $0.86 fees

Review

Got less than expected due to the card condition, but otherwise happy. Wish they had a better way to catalogue cards.
Got less than expected due to the card condition, but otherwise happy. Wish they had a better way to catalogue cards.
Carlos
Review left Jul 05 2023
Shipment processed Jun 24 2023
$42.51 payout, $25.91 fees

Review

The process was easy, except the fees charged. Almost feels like your should send less than 500 cards or else you will get heavier fees. Over all quick payment and turn time made sense.
The process was easy, except the fees charged. Almost feels like your should send less than 500 cards or else you will get heavier fees. Over all quick payment and turn time made sense.
Brian Thompson
Review left Jun 21 2023
Shipment processed Jun 17 2023
$346.77 payout, $16.34 fees

Review

Easy shipping process overall and better than trying to manage buylists by myself. Pleased with the service and will be using again, would recommend to friends.
Only small complaint is in the quality of cards sent in, not sure how to address it but there was a fair discrepancy between what I expe ... Read more
Easy shipping process overall and better than trying to manage buylists by myself. Pleased with the service and will be using again, would recommend to friends.
Only small complaint is in the quality of cards sent in, not sure how to address it but there was a fair discrepancy between what I expected for a payout based on the estimate tool and what the collection was graded at. A guide for how you grade the collections would be greatly appreciated to help avoid the misunderstandings in the future.

Overall very pleased with the service and process.
Adam
Review left Jun 14 2023
Shipment processed Jun 10 2023
$465.75 payout, $9.51 fees

Review

Over all a very positive experience. Comminucated frequently and very timely. Only problem were some of the higher value cards had big swings in value from when i checked price, to when made list, to when checked and graded. So if sending high dollar cards be mindfull of sudden changes. Rest of the ... Read more
Over all a very positive experience. Comminucated frequently and very timely. Only problem were some of the higher value cards had big swings in value from when i checked price, to when made list, to when checked and graded. So if sending high dollar cards be mindfull of sudden changes. Rest of the cards were fine. I still highly reccomend this site and people. Great job and i will send more cards when i need to.
Dylan Johnson
Review left Jun 07 2023
Shipment processed May 27 2023
$831.80 payout, $16.98 fees

Review

Not bad, I needed money and to sell my collection. It was sad and hard to watch it leave but I think I got a reasonable price for what I had. Quick easy and customer service was fast and kind
Not bad, I needed money and to sell my collection. It was sad and hard to watch it leave but I think I got a reasonable price for what I had. Quick easy and customer service was fast and kind
Jonnie
Review left Jun 05 2023
Shipment processed May 31 2023
$664.88 payout, $31.33 fees

Review

Took a bit longer then expected, (couple days) and there pretty tough on there grading conditions, but overall better then ur local game store, and i use again,
Took a bit longer then expected, (couple days) and there pretty tough on there grading conditions, but overall better then ur local game store, and i use again,
Mike
Review left May 20 2023
Shipment processed May 13 2023
$1,420.00 payout, $74.74 fees

Review

The process was very easy. Took about 2 weeks in total. They even upgraded my service to curated which was very much appreciated. Nick Anderson was awesome! I give him 2 thumbs up for his email and kindness. While I think the grading was maybe a little harsh for some stuff, overall it didn't bo ... Read more
The process was very easy. Took about 2 weeks in total. They even upgraded my service to curated which was very much appreciated. Nick Anderson was awesome! I give him 2 thumbs up for his email and kindness. While I think the grading was maybe a little harsh for some stuff, overall it didn't bother me enough to give them less than 5 stars as I've had more issues with TCGplayer over the years.

I will be using this service again as this was my test run. Thank you.
Erik Metzler
Review left May 14 2023
Shipment processed May 03 2023
$382.00 payout, $18.00 fees

Review

Card Conduit has made it MUCH easier for me to sell significant quantities of sealed Magic product. It was much more difficult to sell these through other channels, and I thought I would either be unable to move them, or have to sell with much more trouble and expense. From my perspective, CC looks ... Read more
Card Conduit has made it MUCH easier for me to sell significant quantities of sealed Magic product. It was much more difficult to sell these through other channels, and I thought I would either be unable to move them, or have to sell with much more trouble and expense. From my perspective, CC looks to be a relatively new at this, and they still need to develop a price list for sealed products; however, their support channel has been super-responsive in getting me quotes on all sort of things, from loose, individual booster packs to SDCC limited edition collectibles. I strongly endorse this sales channel for individual collectors looking to sell Magic product.
Shawn Beson
Review left May 12 2023
Shipment processed May 02 2023
$330.25 payout, $5.37 fees

Review

Process was very easy and great customer service. I did find the grading to be a little strict but other than that very good service!
Process was very easy and great customer service. I did find the grading to be a little strict but other than that very good service!
Chad
Review left May 08 2023
Shipment processed Apr 27 2023
$1,054.50 payout, $55.50 fees

Review

The entire process was easy with the only pain being mine upon parting with some of my favorites. The condition grading did crush me on some rarer cards, with some that weren't as expensive/rare and otherwise similar condition being graded higher. Overall I would use the service again and probably w ... Read more
The entire process was easy with the only pain being mine upon parting with some of my favorites. The condition grading did crush me on some rarer cards, with some that weren't as expensive/rare and otherwise similar condition being graded higher. Overall I would use the service again and probably will soon, as I did get value for something that was otherwise collecting dust.

In addition, the e-mail communication was professional and timely. While the cards were in their care after being shipped the updates on the ticket page were consistent with the estimated times given for each step.
Richard Lee
Review left Apr 22 2023
Shipment processed Apr 06 2023
$243.60 payout, $4.46 fees

Review

I like the service Card Conduit provides and their fees are very fair. My only hangup is some of the higher value cards I had were sold as damaged or otherwise lower than LP even though when I checked them they seemed to be in great quality and you don't really get a say about whether or not you wou ... Read more
I like the service Card Conduit provides and their fees are very fair. My only hangup is some of the higher value cards I had were sold as damaged or otherwise lower than LP even though when I checked them they seemed to be in great quality and you don't really get a say about whether or not you would like to sell them at the final offer price you receive once you ship cards off. Other than that they are great for saving time and effort when you have a decent amount of cards you are looking to sell all at once.
David F
Review left Apr 14 2023
Shipment processed Apr 06 2023
$670.17 payout, $12.28 fees

Review

Process is super easy, and payout was quick. Very strict grading, especially compared to sites like Tcgplayer. Overall a good experience, and will use again.
Process is super easy, and payout was quick. Very strict grading, especially compared to sites like Tcgplayer. Overall a good experience, and will use again.
Blair Chantrill
Review left Mar 29 2023
Shipment processed Mar 18 2023
$329.27 payout, $47.43 fees

Review

The process was easy and the communication was great about my shipment. The only downside is that there is a cost per card for processing so it is best to put some effort in and go through and only ship cards that actually have some value. I got a lot more cash than I expected for my shipment and was overall happy with the process.
The process was easy and the communication was great about my shipment. The only downside is that there is a cost per card for processing so it is best to put some effort in and go through and only ship cards that actually have some value. I got a lot more cash than I expected for my shipment and was overall happy with the process.
Andrew
Review left Mar 27 2023
Shipment processed Mar 16 2023
$853.17 payout, $17.41 fees

Review

The process was very easy, even for being self sorting of cards. The prices of some of the market values seemed really low to me, yet I understand that it can sometimes be a struggle. Some card conditions were also not what I was expecting, yet that went both ways. Overall, for the ease of service, I was very satisfied with my experience
The process was very easy, even for being self sorting of cards. The prices of some of the market values seemed really low to me, yet I understand that it can sometimes be a struggle. Some card conditions were also not what I was expecting, yet that went both ways. Overall, for the ease of service, I was very satisfied with my experience
James Ailstock
Review left Mar 17 2023
Shipment processed Mar 07 2023
$396.69 payout, $7.27 fees

Review

I used the sorted shipment to try and maximize buylist value of cards I already knew I was going to trade in.
The process of creating an account, selecting a service, and creating a buylist of cards was extremely easy and seamless.
The process of sorting the cards in order, packaging, and shipping ... Read more
I used the sorted shipment to try and maximize buylist value of cards I already knew I was going to trade in.
The process of creating an account, selecting a service, and creating a buylist of cards was extremely easy and seamless.
The process of sorting the cards in order, packaging, and shipping the cards was also very easy.
The time it took to receive, process, and payout my buylist was a little longer than other buylist I have used (about 3-7 days longer), but Card Conduit was transparent about that timeline from the beginning. The major issue with the longer timeline (and my overall issue with this process) is that your buylist value fluctuates during that entire time until it is full processed. Unlike other buylist where the value is locked in (as long as it is mailed within 7 days), this buylist can fluctuate. In theory, that means your buylist can increase as well, but I was sending a decent amount of cards from a newly released set. While some cards can increase in value after release, the majority decrease in value. This means I was losing value as time went by. At the time I submitted my buylist, it was valued at ~$422. Once it was processed it was valued at ~$403 (before grading and fees). The $19 I lost in value while I was waiting on it to be processed was probably a large portion of the total amount I gained in sending here as opposed to a single buylist. That kind of defeats the purpose once you throw in the 2% fee.
I submitted 50 cards for buylist. Only 1 card came back as less than NM, and it was a card I traded for that I would have also marked at a played condition. I was very pleased with the grading and with the personalized note that comes back with your report.

So overall I would recommend this service to friends and fellow players with one caveat: if a decent % of your buylist is from a set that was released within the last 30 days (when card prices are more volatile) , I would just submit to a single buylist vendor.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every previous customer to leave a review. Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page. We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).