Chat with us

Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service

(254)
Joe M.
Review left Oct 03 2021
Shipment processed Sep 23 2021
$5,370.48 payout, $282.66 fees

Great way to sell lots of cards without the hassle

Review

If you've ever been burned by eBay, don't have time, or just want a simple buy-list process I highly recommend. Customer service and communication was great - could monitor progress throughout the transaction.
If you've ever been burned by eBay, don't have time, or just want a simple buy-list process I highly recommend. Customer service and communication was great - could monitor progress throughout the transaction.
Ray B.
Review left Sep 29 2021
Shipment processed Sep 14 2021
$639.56 payout, $53.17 fees

Detailed and a friendly, easy way to sell your cards

Review

I would highly, highly recommend Card Conduit as a service.

Used it for the first time ever. I packed a small USPS flat-rate box full of cards. Created a shipment on their site, shipped it, anxiously waited.

And waited. And waited. And about a week later, they received my cards, but told me th ... Read more
I would highly, highly recommend Card Conduit as a service.

Used it for the first time ever. I packed a small USPS flat-rate box full of cards. Created a shipment on their site, shipped it, anxiously waited.

And waited. And waited. And about a week later, they received my cards, but told me that they haven't received it to PROCESS yet.

Then they did, and then it was another wait... about a week or so.

And then they sent me the craziest novel of an email... to tell me, in detail, about how most of my shipment was in NM to LP condition with few exceptions, told me about my payout, and provided an analysis on my shipment on their site to peruse. THIS was amazing, and it wasn't some canned crap either. Nick Anderson was VERY thorough and passionate about what he was doing, and I was very grateful for it.

And of course, being the nerd I am, responded in kind, to ask for clarity, and basically share the same passion with MTG.

And he followed up with me, personally, checked in with the grader, and answered my questions, again in DETAIL, and I felt like I was doing a pen pal chat via email. This is the level of personal correspondence. I loved this part of the whole experience. On top of this, he was a fantastic client advocate and changed my standard order to a curated order, netting ME $60 more than what the initial payout was.

Sure, $60 is probably cheap to them to buy a loyal customer, but it sure as hell worked. What company actually wants to GIVE a customer MORE? Card Conduit, that's who.

Took about another week for the payment department, but then they let me know that because of USPS's delays, my check may take a while to get to me. I suggested that they offered instant payouts with PayPal and whatnot, and they answered back that they actually offered electronic payment with Zelle.

I was able to sign up for Zelle, set it up, and then received the payment the NEXT day.

HIGHLY RECOMMENDED! =) Thanks!!
Jordan
Review left Sep 22 2021
Shipment processed Sep 11 2021
$259.05 payout, $12.20 fees

Easy experience

Review

Literally just pack your cards up and ship them and wait two weeks. Much easier than dealing with Card Kingdom and payout was about what I expected. Thanks guys!
Literally just pack your cards up and ship them and wait two weeks. Much easier than dealing with Card Kingdom and payout was about what I expected. Thanks guys!
Emily
Review left Sep 17 2021
Shipment processed Aug 11 2021

Above and beyond

Review

We had a superb experience with Card Conduit. Nick was extremely responsive on email, answered all of my questions in detail, and made the whole selling experience easy. The process and fees are super transparent, with no hidden surprises. As a data nerd, I also really loved the reporting/stats we ... Read more
We had a superb experience with Card Conduit. Nick was extremely responsive on email, answered all of my questions in detail, and made the whole selling experience easy. The process and fees are super transparent, with no hidden surprises. As a data nerd, I also really loved the reporting/stats we received about our collection after processing. This was SO much easier than trying to sell cards ourselves individually. Thanks!
James H.
Review left Sep 13 2021
Shipment processed Sep 02 2021
$3,071.22 payout, $161.64 fees

Fantastic service and turnaround!

Review

First time using the service and couldn't have been more pleased with the results. Took the time to do a bit of pre-sorting and used their curated service and everything was graded better than I expected :3 Highly recommend to anyone looking to liquidate part of their collection for a good turnaroun ... Read more
First time using the service and couldn't have been more pleased with the results. Took the time to do a bit of pre-sorting and used their curated service and everything was graded better than I expected :3 Highly recommend to anyone looking to liquidate part of their collection for a good turnaround and with zero hassle.
Jarred O.
Review left Sep 11 2021
Shipment processed Sep 08 2021
$640.39 payout, No fees
*Fees were waived during our curated service launch promotion.

Extremely impressed

Review

Process was super easy to follow. Not having to to manually grade and sort the cards was also godsend. Value was what I expected and then some. 10/10 would recommend if you don't particularly know the finer details of card selling.
Process was super easy to follow. Not having to to manually grade and sort the cards was also godsend. Value was what I expected and then some. 10/10 would recommend if you don't particularly know the finer details of card selling.
Isaac A.
Review left Sep 10 2021
Shipment processed Sep 07 2021
$6,735.53 payout, $968.20 fees

Fantastic communication

Review

Blown away with the ease of the entire process. The Card Conduit team kept me in the loop and I feel well compensated for the collection I sent in.
Blown away with the ease of the entire process. The Card Conduit team kept me in the loop and I feel well compensated for the collection I sent in.
Joel G.
Review left Sep 02 2021
Shipment processed Jun 25 2021
$3,367.12 payout, $406.18 fees

Great Service

Review

Process could not be easier. You just box up your cards, send them, and you're done. Would I use this service for a few, high value cards? Probably not. But if you have a box of rares that is taking up space, or you broke down some commander decks, or you just don't have the time/will to sort everyt ... Read more
Process could not be easier. You just box up your cards, send them, and you're done. Would I use this service for a few, high value cards? Probably not. But if you have a box of rares that is taking up space, or you broke down some commander decks, or you just don't have the time/will to sort everything and manually type it into a buylist, this service is great. The grading is fair and the fact that they shop your cards to several different buylists means you are getting the best bang for your buck. I recommend this service on convenience alone, and that isn't even factoring the customer service (which was great in my, albeit limited, experience). I love that they send you a little personalized assessment of your collection besides the total breakdown of what they valued every card at. This is a 5 star service and if you are on the fence, I hope I persuaded you to give it a shot.
Chris Nicholson
Review left Aug 27 2021
Shipment processed Aug 17 2021
$3,378.63 payout, $423.51 fees

Solid Experience

Review

I'm moving to a new apartment and wanted to downsize my magic collection, and about three hours into sorting my collection and buylisting the cards myself I knew it was going to take me way to long to do myself (especially after the website I was using to grade my collection crashed and wiped my pro ... Read more
I'm moving to a new apartment and wanted to downsize my magic collection, and about three hours into sorting my collection and buylisting the cards myself I knew it was going to take me way to long to do myself (especially after the website I was using to grade my collection crashed and wiped my progress). That's when I looked for alternatives and found this service. The time frames were pretty accurate for what was expressed by the service online, and any part of the process that took longer than expected I was informed pretty quickly and what the new expectations were going to be. Overall value was a bit more than I expected and they saved me days worth of sorting, grading, and shipping I'd have to do on my own. Very much recommend if you have a ton of rares and mythics you have that you'd like to sell off.
Paul
Review left Aug 18 2021
Shipment processed Aug 14 2021
$284.80 payout, $13.42 fees

Amazing service

Review

This was my first time trying out card conduits service. It was super easy to do and the customer support was amazing, whenever I had questions I got a response super quick. the overall process was pretty quick, it only took about 3 weeks from shipping my magic cards to getting money for my magic ca ... Read more
This was my first time trying out card conduits service. It was super easy to do and the customer support was amazing, whenever I had questions I got a response super quick. the overall process was pretty quick, it only took about 3 weeks from shipping my magic cards to getting money for my magic cards. The value was great, I got paid pretty much the same I would have if I buylisted and this was a fraction of the effort. I've already preached the good word of card conduit to friends at my LGS and recommend all you out there reading these reviews to give it a try. Overall review, not only will I be using this service again, but this is the first place im going to when I want to sell magic cards.
Toby Z.
Review left Jul 25 2021
Shipment processed Jun 20 2021
$1,121.81 payout, $59.04 fees

Quick, simple and reliable

Review

The process for a curated shipment was very simple and I was able to get a very decent return for a medium sized collection. This is a great option for someone like me that cannot be bothered to deal with selling/shipping individual cards on TCGPlayer but wants more value than selling to a store.
The process for a curated shipment was very simple and I was able to get a very decent return for a medium sized collection. This is a great option for someone like me that cannot be bothered to deal with selling/shipping individual cards on TCGPlayer but wants more value than selling to a store.
Robby B
Review left Jul 16 2021
Shipment processed Jul 10 2021
$1,620.44 payout, $76.36 fees

Fantastic Service!

Review

This is my first time selling MTG cards online and it couldn't have been easier! I used the curated option, so I simply picked the cards I would like to sell and mailed them off. No researching prices, haggling over condition or going to the post office to ship every individual sale. Card Conduit de ... Read more
This is my first time selling MTG cards online and it couldn't have been easier! I used the curated option, so I simply picked the cards I would like to sell and mailed them off. No researching prices, haggling over condition or going to the post office to ship every individual sale. Card Conduit definitely provides the easiest path to turn your cards into cash!
H
Review left Jul 10 2021
Shipment processed Jun 05 2021
$183.23 payout, $11.10 fees

Great experience! Multiple time user.

Review

Have used card conduit at least 10 times thus far and plan to continue with all my MTG selling needs. Selling cards in bulk has never been easier. The grading is fair, and whenever I've had an issue customer service has always provided a reasonable explanation and worked with me to resolve. This ser ... Read more
Have used card conduit at least 10 times thus far and plan to continue with all my MTG selling needs. Selling cards in bulk has never been easier. The grading is fair, and whenever I've had an issue customer service has always provided a reasonable explanation and worked with me to resolve. This service saves you so much time and headache its ridiculous.
Alan S.
Review left May 28 2021
Shipment processed Apr 22 2021
$114.42 payout, $31.75 fees

Professional and reasonable

Review

I have played Magic off and on since the first sets and accumulated many cards that were not in decks. I sent in about 8000 cards (the usual mix of commons, uncommons, and rares) in 4 separate shipments. These cards returned about $1000 in total. It was nice to know that the cards were going back ... Read more
I have played Magic off and on since the first sets and accumulated many cards that were not in decks. I sent in about 8000 cards (the usual mix of commons, uncommons, and rares) in 4 separate shipments. These cards returned about $1000 in total. It was nice to know that the cards were going back into use and circulation. The reports and statistics provided were interesting and fun to read. It would have taken many months of my time to provide what Card Conduit did in under 2 weeks per shipment.
Matt P
Review left May 23 2021
Shipment processed Apr 18 2021
$1,007.53 payout, $121.72 fees

Quick and easy

Review

Card conduit made the process as easy as I was hoping it would be. While you're still getting buylist pricing, you can literally just send all your stuff away and get a check for it. If you're tired of going through your collection or no longer have time like you used to, this is the perfect service ... Read more
Card conduit made the process as easy as I was hoping it would be. While you're still getting buylist pricing, you can literally just send all your stuff away and get a check for it. If you're tired of going through your collection or no longer have time like you used to, this is the perfect service for you. It was quick and efficient, and payment was prompt. Would do it again and would recommend. If you're not familiar with how card pricing works, I would take a look, and realize that you're probably going to get about 50-60% of what the "retail" value is. But as far as I'm aware, that's pretty standard for bulk sales. Thanks guys!
Rubin F.
Review left Apr 23 2021
Shipment processed Mar 14 2021
$535.44 payout, $61.08 fees

Excellent Service

Review

Card Conduit is a convenient, reliable service. They were timely and I am satisfied with the funds that I got in return for my cards. Avoiding the hassle I would've gone through without them by trying to sell my cards myself was definitely worth their fee! I would recommend this service to anyone lo ... Read more
Card Conduit is a convenient, reliable service. They were timely and I am satisfied with the funds that I got in return for my cards. Avoiding the hassle I would've gone through without them by trying to sell my cards myself was definitely worth their fee! I would recommend this service to anyone looking to sell their collection who aren't already experienced with selling their cards on their own.
Nate P.
Review left Apr 20 2021
Shipment processed Mar 07 2021
$1,938.29 payout, $212.05 fees

Amazing customer service!

Review

The site is well designed and has features to let me have an approximation of the payout range based on my cards conditions. I felt the prices offered were good and chose to sell some of my cards. I was very impressed with the customer service along the process. The communication was sufficient to e ... Read more
The site is well designed and has features to let me have an approximation of the payout range based on my cards conditions. I felt the prices offered were good and chose to sell some of my cards. I was very impressed with the customer service along the process. The communication was sufficient to ease any concerns I had, and I had a small issue come up that I expected to be a loss as part of my misunderstanding, but they proactively offered a solution and made my day. If you are looking to sell some cards, I highly recommend this service.
Hunter B.
Review left Apr 05 2021
Shipment processed Feb 26 2021
$845.13 payout, $99.57 fees

Great Value and Great Customer Service

Review

Cards are graded and valued at market price at a reasonable pace, and Customer Service is very patient and helpful if you have any questions or concerns with your shipment.

If you have ever traded in a large number of cards to any other card store or distributor, you know the feeling of being und ... Read more
Cards are graded and valued at market price at a reasonable pace, and Customer Service is very patient and helpful if you have any questions or concerns with your shipment.

If you have ever traded in a large number of cards to any other card store or distributor, you know the feeling of being undervalued and even with store credit you still can't shake the feeling of being ripped off.

At Card Conduit, since they sell to their distributors and take a percentage of the cards value as payment, it is in their best interest to get you the most value for your collection.

I have never sold cards through any other source besides Card Conduit that has actually made me feel that I got fair value for my collection.
JP
Review left Mar 17 2021
Shipment processed Feb 07 2021
$436.05 payout, $49.65 fees

Easy.... So, So Easy

Review

I wanted a one-stop shop to sell my cards valued at around $6 or less. I didn’t want to bother selling on my own; I didn’t want to grade them; I didn’t want to check multiple buylists. Instead, I can simply ship them to CardConduit, wait a bit, and get a payment that, even after fees, is wort ... Read more
I wanted a one-stop shop to sell my cards valued at around $6 or less. I didn’t want to bother selling on my own; I didn’t want to grade them; I didn’t want to check multiple buylists. Instead, I can simply ship them to CardConduit, wait a bit, and get a payment that, even after fees, is worth far more to me than the time and energy I’d have to spend otherwise.

Great service, great transparency, and so, so easy a way to deal with those lower valued cards.
Craig Norton
Review left Mar 05 2021
Shipment processed Jan 23 2021
$40.06 payout, $18.44 fees

Great service with great results

Review

The process is quick and painless and the customer service went above and beyond for me. All in all I had a very large collection that was processed and cashed out in a very fast and fair process.
The process is quick and painless and the customer service went above and beyond for me. All in all I had a very large collection that was processed and cashed out in a very fast and fair process.
« 1 2
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every previous customer to leave a review. Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page. We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).